Rude & Barbarous Kingdom Revisited: Essays in Russian History and Culture in Honor of Robert O. Crummey

CΛУЖҼбHaЯ

CAY>Ke6Hasl AeSlTeAbHOCTb 60Slp B XVII BeKe1 D .E. KOweAeBa H Ii.H. MOP030B OCHOBHOM 065I3aHHOCTbRJ 11 O;,\HOBpeMeHHO rrpl1Bl1llerneM lll1l\, I1MeBIIII1X ;,\YMHbI M 'II1H, 5IBll5IllOCb I1X Y"aCTl1e B l\apCKOM COBeTe. KpoMe TOro, OHI1 HeClll1 BOeHHYIO 11 rpa)!(;,\aHcryRJ clly)!(6bl , COBMeIl\eHl1e KOTOPblX 6blllO XapaKTepHbl M ;'\ll5I yrrpaBlleH'IeCKOrO arrrrapaTa C ]leO;,\allbHoro rocy;'\apCTBa. E05Ipe, KaK rre pBblM ;,\YMHbIM 'II1H, 3aHI1Malll1 MeCTa BblCIIIero PYKOBO;,\CTBa, C'II1TaBIIIl1eC5I Hal160llee rrpeCTI1)!(HbIMI1. OHI1 0CYIl\eCTBll5Illl1 KOMaH;,\OBaHl1e apMl1eM, BO rllaBY EOllbIIIOro, ITepe;,\OBOrO 11 CTOpO)!(eBoro rrOllKOB BOeBO;,\aMI1 CTaBl1lll1Cb TOllbKO 605Ipe 11 Hal160llee 3HaTHble 113 OKOllbHI1'II1X. I1x ;,\e5ITellbHOCTb KOHTPOlll1pOBallaCb Pa3p5I;'\HbIM 11 TaMHblM rrpl1Ka 3aMI1, Ky;'\a OHI1 ;,\Oll)!(Hbl 6bl lll1 rrpl1CblllaTb rrO;'\p06HeMIIIl1e OTrrl1CKI1 0 xo;'\e BOeHHblx KaMrraHI1M . ITllaH bl KpyrrHblx BOeHHblx MaHeBpOB 06cy)!(;,\allI1Cb BCeM AYMOM, 1 3TOT TeKCT Ha4aA rOTOBMThOl eIl.\e B Hal.laAe 1980-x rr., HO TeMhI, CBJl 3aHHble c lt13Yl .JeHMeM POC01l1CKOH 3AMTbi XVII H., 6blAM « H eaKTyaAbHbl» M51 Toro BpeMeHM, 11 OH ocraACJI H eorry6A I1KonaHHhlM. AaHHhIH npo6eA BO MHorOM 6bIA 33nOAHeH BhlweAllleM B 1983 r. KHMroM P. KpaMMM «Aristocrats and Servitors. T he Boyar Elite in Russia. 1613-1689». BOAelo CYAb6hl l1,4el1 P. KpaMMl1 110 l1C(Ae,40BaHHIO n epcoHaAhHoro coCT3Ba DOJlPCKOM AYM bI Ha OCHOBe apXl1BHblX AOKYMeHToB CMOfAl1 oCYlll,eCTBAJlTbOI B POCCHl1 C 1991 f., KOfA,a aBTopbl 3Tl1X CTPOK COBMeCTHO C P. MapT11HoM 11 M. ITo HaqaAl1 pa60ry Ha,4 npoeKToM «El1orpaKe6HOrO nOllO)l(eH l15l npeACTaBl1TeAew BLlcmero o6w.ecTBa B HallaAbHblM rrepHoA craHOBAeHl1J1 a6coAloTM3Ma B POCCHH (1645-1682 rr.»> (M., 2001). HaKoHeQ, He;'\3BHO BhlWAH KHHrM, np"Mo oCBew.alOLQl1e l1CTOPl11 0 BblCWl1X CAoeB pyccKoro o6w.ecTBa B XVII B.: ITpaB.Hw.aR 3llMTa PYCCKOro rocYAapcTBa IX - Ha4aAa XVIII BB.: 04epKM HCTOPHH / E.A. AHHCMMOB , B.r. BOBMHa, ll.M. MBHHa HAp. OTB. peA. A .n. naBAOB. Cn 6., 2006 (XVII B. nOCBJIlll,eH Ha1160Aee 3Hal.ll1TeAhHbIM pa 3,.i\eA); CeAoB Il.B. 3aKaT MOCKoBcKoro Qapcna. lJ,apcKMM ABOP KOHQa XVII B. Cn 6., 2006. OAHaKo, aBTOphl nOllaralOT, 4TO M Aa HHblI1: TeKCT I1M eeT H e TOA bKO l1CTOp110r pacpW.JeCKl1i1: l1H Tep ec. Rude & Barbarous Kingdom Revisited: Essays in Russian History and Culture in Honor of Robert 0. Crummey. Chester 5. L. Dun ning, Russell E. Martin, and Danie l Rowland, eds. Bloomington, IN: Siavica Publishers, 2008,13 1- 53. 132 O.E. KOWEAEBA V1 5.H. MOP030B TaKOBbI, Harrpl1Mep, peIIIeHI1>! AYMbI 0 BOe HHbIX 4eMcrBI1>!X rrepe4 KOHOTOrrCKI1M cpa)J(eHl1eM 1659 r 2 I1lll1 0 Ql1rl1pl1HcKOM rrOX04e 1677 r 3 CaMocro>!TellbHble 4eMcTBI1>! BoeB04aM KaK rrpaBI1ll0 B036paH>!1lI1Cb, TaK KH. M.A. XOBaHCKI1M 4 rrollyql1ll BblroBOP OT l\ap>! 3a caMoBollbHbIM rrpl1cryrr K r. il>!xoBw,aM s , OKOllbHWII1M KH. I1.A. AOllropYKI1M 3a KorrbICCKI1M rrpl1cryrr6 11 T.4. CTpOrl1M KOHTPOllb 3a BoeB04aMI1 6bIll BO MHOroM 06YClloBlleH TeM, 'ITO BOeB04a rrpe)J(4e Bcero 113611pallC>! rro rrpl1Hl\l1rry P040BI1TOCTI1 11 Mor 6bITb '1ellOBeKOM COBepIIIeHHO Hecrroc06HbIM K BOeHHOM CllY)J(6e. Qacro crOllbHI1K, rrOCllaHHbIM 113 TaMHoro rrpl1Ka 3a B rrOllK C KaKI1M-1l1160 rropyqeHl1eM, I1Mell eIIJ,e TaMHbIM: HaKa3 BbI5ICHMTb, 'liTO AeAaeTC5I B IlOAK)' 11 KaK rrp05IBA.»eT ce6.» BOeB04a. TaKOB HaKa3 CTOllbHI1KY . KOllTOBCKOMY, rrOCllaHHOMY B rrOllK K KH. M.A. XOBaHcKoM/, I1lll1 M. KOllbI'Ie BY, rroCllaHHoMY K KH. 1.1.1.1. il06aHoBYPOCTOBCKOMY . BbIIlOllH>!>! rropyqeHl1e, KOllbI'IeB BbI>!CHl1ll, 'ITO BOeB04a co06Il \aeT l\apIO 3aHI1)J(eHHble l\11(PpbI «ypoHa paTHbIX llI04eM», 11M 6bIllO rrpoBe4eHO Clle4CTBI1e B rrOllKY rro 3 TOMY 4elly. MHOr4a TaMHOMY rrpl1Ka3y rrpl1X0411ll0Cb 4eMCTBOBaTb 3a crrl1HOIO BOe B04bI '1epe3 ero rrOMOIl\HI1KOB. IToKa3aTellbHbIM rrpe4CTaBll>!eTC>! TaMHbIM HaKa3 , rrollyqeHHbIM crpellel\KI1M rollOBOM, 40BepeHHbI M lll1l\OM l\ap>! A.c. MaTBeeBbIM , KOTOPbIM 6bIll rrOCllaH B rrOllK K KH. 1.1.1.1. il06aHoBY-POCTOBCKOMY. OH 40ll)J(eH 6bIll crrpOCI1Tb 0 340pOBbe BoeB04bI, rrpOBe4aTb, 'ITO 4ellaeTC>! B rrOllKY, a rllaBHoe, rrepe4aTb l\apCKI1M YKa3 B3>!Tb rop04 ObIXOB. Ho COMHe Ba >!Cb B B03MO)J(HOCTI1 OCYIl\eCTBI1Tb 3TOT rrpl1Ka 3, l\apb Bellell MaTBeeBY CHa- 'lalla Y3HaTb BTaMHe Y TOBapl1Il\a BoeB04bI CTOllbHI1Ka C. 3MeeBa ero MHeHl1e 0 rrpl1cryrre K rop04Y. B TO )J(e BpeM>! MaTBeeB 40ll)J(eH 6bIll «He 40e3)J(a>! rrOAKOB OCTaBJ1Tb CTp.HIJllerO KOHlOxa, fAe MOQHO, J1 yqeT\IJ1 ARM, BelleTb eMY 3a C060M rrpl1rHaTb, 6Y4TO C MOCKBbI rOHel\ K HeMY, ApTeMoHY». ECllI1 3MeeB«CKa)l(eT, lITO caMbI MM CKOPbI MM AHHMltI Ha EbIXOB rrpOMbICAY y-Il1HJ1Tb HJ1KaK He MO'llHO», TO rrpueAeT KOHIOX, KaK-6YATO 6bI C rpaMOTO:H 113 MOCKBbI J1...