This discussion originated from a panel at the 2018 APA Pacific Division, which was organized by Anand Vaidya and included papers by Linda Martín Alcoff, Eva Feder Kittay, and Keya Maitra, with a response by the author, Vrinda Dalmiya. The session was chaired by Ashby Butnor, who gathered these papers for publication. The fourth paper, by Nilanjan Das, was added later and then incorporated into the author's response.