Pure Immanence: Essays on a Life (review)

Trying to review the three short essays by Deleuze that are collected and newly translated in Pure Immanence: Essays on a Life is almost impossible. All the essays are very rich, and each sentence contains another step in Deleuze's argumentation of his ideas on immanence. Therefore I can only try to give an impression of his thoughts. In the first essay, "Immanence: A Life," which Deleuze wrote just before his death and can be considered as his philosophical testament, he discusses his philosophical method, which he calls "transcendental empiricism." According to Deleuze pure immanence is a life, and nothing else. When a life is actualized in the particular life of somebody, it is

Reviews Panel:

Peter Anders, Fred Allan Andersson, Wilfred Arnold, Roy Ascott, Curtis Bahn, Claire Barliant, Marc Battier, Roy R. Behrens, Andreas Broeckmann, Annick Bureaud, Robert Coburn, Nicolas Collins, Donna Cox, Sean Cubitt, Shawn Decker, Sara Diamond, Victoria Duckett, Bulat M. Galeyev, George Gessert, Elisa Giaccardi, Thom Gillespie, Craig Harris, Josepha Haveman, Paul Hertz, Stephen Jones, George K. Shortess, Eduardo Kac, Richard Kade, Douglas Kahn, Curtis E.A. Karnow, Nisar Keshvani, Rahma Khazam, Julien Knebusch, Daniela Kutschat, Sybille Lammes, Jim Laukes, Mike Legget, Roger F. Malina, Jacques Mandelbrojt, Rick Mitchell, Robert A. Mitchell, Mike Mosher, Axel Mulder, Kevin Murray, Frieder Nake, Angela Ndalianis, Simone Osthoff, Jack Ox, Robert Pepperell, Cliff Pickover, Patricia Pisters, Michael Punt, Harry Rand, Sonya Rapoport, Henry See, Edward Shanken, Rhonda Shearer, Joel Slayton, Christa Sommerer, Yvonne Spielmann, David Topper, Rene van Peer, Stefaan van Ryssen, Barbara Lee Williams, Stephen Wilson, Arthur Woods.

transcended, but always as a product of immanence. Deleuze recalls Charles Dickens' description of a disreputable man, a rogue, who is abandoned by everyone and who is found the moment he is dying. Those who take care of him treat him with respect, as he tries to fight for his life. And "between his life and his death, there is a moment that is only that of a life playing with death" (p. 28). With this artistic example Deleuze explains what he means by the indefiniteness of immanent life (the plane of immanence) that is at the heart of his philosophy.

According to Deleuze, immanence can only be thought through radical empiricism, and in the second essay of the book, he looks deeper into the nature of empiricism through the work of Hume. According to Hume, human nature (subjectivity) is constituted by two principles: principles of association, from which relations derive, and principles of passion, from which "inclinations" follow. Fiction and imagination (and thus art, the sensible) play a big role in both principles. Deleuze explains how, according to Hume, the constitution of an identity of the self requires the intervention of all sorts of fictive uses of associations and relations. The self is not given, but constituted in fiction and experience. In respect to the principle of passion, the imagination is necessary to make passion go beyond its natural partiality and presentness. Aesthetic and moral sentiments are formed in this way and are at the same time very important constitutive principles.

The third essay in Pure Immanence is about Nietzsche. Also for Nietzsche the aesthetic is important to the point that the philosopher becomes a creator. Deleuze explains that Nietzsche's will to power consists not in taking but in creating and giving. In discussing the stages of Nietzsche's nihilism, Deleuze explains how at the moment of the completion of nihilism everything is ready for a creative transmutation that consists of an active becoming of forces, a triumph of affirmation (instead of negation) in the will to power. And what is affirmed is the earth, life in its multiplicity and becomings.

Although the three essays in this book discuss very different aspects of the affirmative and immanent implications of Deleuze's philosophy, the aesthetic dimension seems very important. As John Rajchman explains in the introduction: "Through affect and...