Brain death without definitions

W Chiong - Hastings Center Report, 2005 - Wiley Online Library
Hastings Center Report, 2005Wiley Online Library
Most of the world now accepts the idea, first proposed four decades ago, that death means
“brain death.” But the idea has always been open to criticism because it doesn't square with
all of our intuitions about death. In fact, none of the possible definitions of death quite works.
Death, perhaps surprisingly, eludes definition, and “brain death” can be accepted only as a
refinement of what is in fact a fuzzy concept.
Most of the world now accepts the idea, first proposed four decades ago, that death means “brain death.” But the idea has always been open to criticism because it doesn't square with all of our intuitions about death. In fact, none of the possible definitions of death quite works. Death, perhaps surprisingly, eludes definition, and “brain death” can be accepted only as a refinement of what is in fact a fuzzy concept.
Wiley Online Library