Professions and Professionalism-Should We Jump Off the Bandwagon, Better to Study Where It Is Going?

T Watson - International Studies of Management & Organization, 2002 - Taylor & Francis
T Watson
International Studies of Management & Organization, 2002Taylor & Francis
Social scientists are invited to contemplate the possibility of abandoning the concepts of"
profession" and" professionalism" as analytical resources for the study of occupations and
occupational strategies. It might be more fruitful to treat the way the people in society
generally, and spokespersons for occupational groupings in particular, use notions of
profession and professionalism to achieve particular purposes. The language of
professionalism is highly ambiguous, with its meaning constantly slipping from one …
Social scientists are invited to contemplate the possibility of abandoning the concepts of "profession" and "professionalism" as analytical resources for the study of occupations and occupational strategies. It might be more fruitful to treat the way the people in society generally, and spokespersons for occupational groupings in particular, use notions of profession and professionalism to achieve particular purposes. The language of professionalism is highly ambiguous, with its meaning constantly slipping from one emphasis to another. This alone makes it problematic as a source of concepts for the critical analysis of occupational activity. But it is made even more problematic by the fact that it is frequently deployed in the occupational world to serve sectional interests. It is unlikely that social scientists will abandon concepts of professionalism. But they would be wise to reflect on the analytical and critical implications of their using such a slippery and pejorative terminology.
Taylor & Francis Online