Normativity and Expressive Agency in Hegel, Nietzsche, and Deleuze

This article synthesizes several different studies of Hegel’s and Nietzsche’s expressive conceptions of action and agency and identifies a related account in Deleuze’s Logic of Sense. It argues that such conceptions not only challenge familiar voluntarist accounts of action and agency; they also demand a reassessment of standard approaches to the relation between norms and action. For the voluntarist, an agent’s action is caused by the separate, prior intention of the agent. For expressivists, an agent’s intention is inseparable from the action expressing it and nonisolatable from the expression of this intention-action in interpretative activity. For the voluntarist, the norms governing action can be thought of as more or less freestanding, entering into the prior formation of the agent’s intention. For the expressivist, the norm or principle on which an agent acts will be produced over time, through the unfolding of the action expressing it, as well as through interpretative struggle over the meaning of that action, all of which takes place in a social space governed by more basic norms concerning the offering of act-descriptions, recognition, and social and hermeneutical struggle. A number of important differences among Hegel’s, Nietzsche’s, and Deleuze’s accounts are identified, and their significance is explored.