Transactions of the Charles S. Peirce Society: A Quarterly Journal in American Philosophy
Vol. 41 (2005) through current issue
Published by: Indiana University Press
Volume 53, 2017
Volume 52, 2016
- Volume 52, Number 4, Winter 2016
- Volume 52, Number 3, Summer 2016
- Volume 52, Number 2, Spring 2016
- Volume 52, Number 1, Winter 2016
Volume 51, 2015
- Volume 51, Number 4, Winter 2015
- Volume 51, Number 3, Summer 2015
- Volume 51, Number 2, Spring 2015
- Volume 51, Number 1, Winter 2015
Volume 50, 2014
- Volume 50, Number 4, Fall 2014
- Volume 50, Number 3, Summer 2014
- Volume 50, Number 2, Spring 2014
- Volume 50, Number 1, Winter 2014
Volume 49, 2013
- Volume 49, Number 4, Fall 2013
- Volume 49, Number 3, Summer 2013
- Volume 49, Number 2, Spring 2013
- Volume 49, Number 1, Winter 2013
Volume 48, 2012
- Volume 48, Number 4, Fall 2012
- Volume 48, Number 3, Summer 2012
- Volume 48, Number 2, Spring 2012
- Volume 48, Number 1, Winter 2012
Volume 47, 2011
- Volume 47, Number 4, Fall 2011
- Volume 47, Number 3, Summer 2011
- Volume 47, Number 2, Spring 2011
- Volume 47, Number 1, Winter 2011
Volume 46, 2010
- Volume 46, Number 4, Fall 2010
- Volume 46, Number 3, Summer 2010
- Volume 46, Number 2, Spring 2010
- Volume 46, Number 1, Winter 2010
Volume 45, 2009
- Volume 45, Number 4, Fall 2009
- Volume 45, Number 3, Summer 2009
- Volume 45, Number 2, Spring 2009
- Volume 45, Number 1, Winter 2009
Volume 44, 2008
- Volume 44, Number 4, Fall 2008
- Volume 44, Number 3, Summer 2008
- Volume 44, Number 2, Spring 2008
- Volume 44, Number 1, Winter 2008
Volume 43, 2007
- Volume 43, Number 4, Fall 2007
- Volume 43, Number 3, Summer 2007
- Volume 43, Number 2, Spring 2007
- Volume 43, Number 1, Winter 2007
Volume 42, 2006
- Volume 42, Number 4, Fall 2006
- Volume 42, Number 3, Summer 2006
- Volume 42, Number 2, Spring 2006
-
Volume 42, Number 1, Winter 2006
Volume 41, 2005
E-ISSN: 1558-9587
Print ISSN: 0009-1774
Transactions of the Charles S. Peirce Society: A Quarterly Journal in American Philosophy
Submission Guidelines
Indexing/Abstracting
Advertising Information
Editorial Boards
Volume 53, Number 2, Spring 2017
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
Cornelis de Waal
EDITORS
Robert Lane
BOOK REVIEW EDITOR
Henrik Rydenfeldt
CONSULTING EDITORS
Thomas Alexander
Mats Bergman
Richard J. Bernstein
Rosa M. Calcaterra
James Campbell
Vincent Colapietro
Gary A. Cook
Marilyn Fischer
Mathias Girel
Susan Haack
Larry A. Hickman
David Hildebrand
John Lachs
James Liszka
John J. McDermott
Erin McKenna
Robert G. Meyers
Cheryl Misak
Matthew Moore
Jaime Nubiola
Jose-Antonio Orosco
Gregory Fernando Pappas
Ahti-Veikko Pietarinen
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
John Ryder
John R. Shook
T. L. Short
Beth Singer
John J. Stuhr
Shannon Sullivan
Paul C. Taylor
Jennifer Welchman
CHARLES S. PEIRCE SOCIETY
President
Robert Neville
Vice President
Rossella Fabbrichesi
Secretary-Treasurer
Richard Atkins
FELLOWS OF THE SOCIETY
Founder
Frederic Harold Young, (1905–2003)
Living Past Presidents
Robert Almeder
Douglas R. Anderson
Karl-Otto Apel
Richard J. Bernstein
Joseph Brent
Vincent Colapietro
André De Tienne
Cornelius F. Delaney
Susan Haack
Carl R. Hausman
Risto Hilpinen
Jaakko Hintikka
Christopher J. Hookway
Nathan Houser
Ivo A. Ibri
Kenneth L. Ketner
John Lachs
Larry Laudan
Isaac Levi
James Liszka
Cheryl Misak
Murray G. Murphey
Klaus Oehler
Jaime Nubiola
Andrew J. Reck
Nicholas Rescher
B. Gresham Riley
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
Lucia Santaella
Israel Scheffler
Dimitra Sfendoni-Mentzou
Michael Shapiro
Thomas L. Short
Claudine Tiercelin
Volume 53, Number 1, Winter 2017
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
Cornelis de Waal
EDITORS
Robert Lane
BOOK REVIEW EDITOR
Henrik Rydenfeldt
CONSULTING EDITORS
Thomas Alexander
Mats Bergman
Richard J. Bernstein
Rosa M. Calcaterra
James Campbell
Vincent Colapietro
Gary A. Cook
Marilyn Fischer
Mathias Girel
Susan Haack
Larry A. Hickman
David Hildebrand
John Lachs
James Liszka
John J. McDermott
Erin McKenna
Robert G. Meyers
Cheryl Misak
Matthew Moore
Jaime Nubiola
Jose-Antonio Orosco
Gregory Fernando Pappas
Ahti-Veikko Pietarinen
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
John Ryder
John R. Shook
T. L. Short
Beth Singer
John J. Stuhr
Shannon Sullivan
Paul C. Taylor
Jennifer Welchman
CHARLES S. PEIRCE SOCIETY
President
Robert Neville
Vice President
Rossella Fabbrichesi
Secretary-Treasurer
Richard Atkins
FELLOWS OF THE SOCIETY
Founder
Frederic Harold Young, (1905–2003)
Living Past Presidents
Robert Almeder
Douglas R. Anderson
Karl-Otto Apel
Richard J. Bernstein
Joseph Brent
Vincent Colapietro
André De Tienne
Cornelius F. Delaney
Susan Haack
Carl R. Hausman
Risto Hilpinen
Jaakko Hintikka
Christopher J. Hookway
Nathan Houser
Ivo A. Ibri
Kenneth L. Ketner
John Lachs
Larry Laudan
Isaac Levi
James Liszka
Cheryl Misak
Murray G. Murphey
Klaus Oehler
Jaime Nubiola
Andrew J. Reck
Nicholas Rescher
B. Gresham Riley
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
Lucia Santaella
Israel Scheffler
Dimitra Sfendoni-Mentzou
Michael Shapiro
Thomas L. Short
Claudine Tiercelin
Volume 52, Number 4, Winter 2016
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
Cornelis de Waal
EDITORS
Robert Lane
BOOK REVIEW EDITOR
Henrik Rydenfeldt
CONSULTING EDITORS
Thomas Alexander
Mats Bergman
Richard J. Bernstein
Rosa M. Calcaterra
James Campbell
Vincent Colapietro
Gary A. Cook
Marilyn Fischer
Mathias Girel
Susan Haack
Larry A. Hickman
David Hildebrand
John Lachs
James Liszka
John J. McDermott
Erin McKenna
Robert G. Meyers
Cheryl Misak
Matthew Moore
Jaime Nubiola
Jose-Antonio Orosco
Gregory Fernando Pappas
Ahti-Veikko Pietarinen
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
John Ryder
John R. Shook
T. L. Short
Beth Singer
John J. Stuhr
Shannon Sullivan
Paul C. Taylor
Jennifer Welchman
CHARLES S. PEIRCE SOCIETY
President
André De Tienne
Vice President
Robert Neville
Secretary-Treasurer
Shannon Dea
FELLOWS OF THE SOCIETY
Founder
Frederic Harold Young, (1905–2003)
Living Past Presidents
Robert Almeder
Douglas R. Anderson
Karl-Otto Apel
Richard J. Bernstein
Joseph Brent
Vincent Colapietro
Cornelius F. Delaney
Susan Haack
Carl R. Hausman
Risto Hilpinen
Jaakko Hintikka
Christopher J. Hookway
Nathan Houser
Ivo A. Ibri
Kenneth L. Ketner
John Lachs
Larry Laudan
Isaac Levi
James Liszka
Cheryl Misak
Murray G. Murphey
Klaus Oehler
Jaime Nubiola
Andrew J. Reck
Nicholas Rescher
B. Gresham Riley
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
Lucia Santaella
Israel Scheffler
Dimitra Sfendoni-Mentzou
Michael Shapiro
Thomas L. Short
Claudine Tiercelin
Volume 52, Number 3, Summer 2016
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
Cornelis de Waal
EDITORS
Robert Lane
BOOK REVIEW EDITOR
Henrik Rydenfeldt
CONSULTING EDITORS
Thomas Alexander
Mats Bergman
Richard J. Bernstein
Rosa M. Calcaterra
James Campbell
Vincent Colapietro
Gary A. Cook
Marilyn Fischer
Mathias Girel
Susan Haack
Larry A. Hickman
David Hildebrand
John Lachs
James Liszka
John J. McDermott
Erin McKenna
Robert G. Meyers
Cheryl Misak
Matthew Moore
Jaime Nubiola
Jose-Antonio Orosco
Gregory Fernando Pappas
Ahti-Veikko Pietarinen
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
John Ryder
John R. Shook
T. L. Short
Beth Singer
John J. Stuhr
Shannon Sullivan
Paul C. Taylor
Jennifer Welchman
CHARLES S. PEIRCE SOCIETY
President
André De Tienne
Vice President
Robert Neville
Secretary-Treasurer
Shannon Dea
FELLOWS OF THE SOCIETY
Founder
Frederic Harold Young, (1905–2003)
Living Past Presidents
Robert Almeder
Douglas R. Anderson
Karl-Otto Apel
Richard J. Bernstein
Joseph Brent
Vincent Colapietro
Cornelius F. Delaney
Umberto Eco
Susan Haack
Carl R. Hausman
Risto Hilpinen
Jaakko Hintikka
Christopher J. Hookway
Nathan Houser
Ivo A. Ibri
Kenneth L. Ketner
John Lachs
Larry Laudan
Isaac Levi
James Liszka
Cheryl Misak
Murray G. Murphey
Klaus Oehler
Jaime Nubiola
Andrew J. Reck
Nicholas Rescher
B. Gresham Riley
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
Lucia Santaella
Israel Scheffler
Michael Shapiro
Thomas L. Short
Claudine Tiercelin
Volume 52, Number 2, Spring 2016
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
Cornelis de Waal
EDITORS
Robert Lane
BOOK REVIEW EDITOR
Henrik Rydenfeldt
CONSULTING EDITORS
Thomas Alexander
Mats Bergman
Richard J. Bernstein
Rosa M. Calcaterra
James Campbell
Vincent Colapietro
Gary A. Cook
Marilyn Fischer
Mathias Girel
Susan Haack
Larry A. Hickman
David Hildebrand
John Lachs
James Liszka
John J. McDermott
Erin McKenna
Robert G. Meyers
Cheryl Misak
Matthew Moore
Jaime Nubiola
Jose-Antonio Orosco
Gregory Fernando Pappas
Ahti-Veikko Pietarinen
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
John Ryder
John R. Shook
T. L. Short
Beth Singer
John J. Stuhr
Shannon Sullivan
Paul C. Taylor
Jennifer Welchman
CHARLES S. PEIRCE SOCIETY
President
André De Tienne
Vice President
Robert Neville
Secretary-Treasurer
Shannon Dea
FELLOWS OF THE SOCIETY
Founder
Frederic Harold Young, (1905–2003)
Living Past Presidents
Robert Almeder
Douglas R. Anderson
Karl-Otto Apel
Richard J. Bernstein
Joseph Brent
Vincent Colapietro
Cornelius F. Delaney
Umberto Eco
Susan Haack
Carl R. Hausman
Risto Hilpinen
Jaakko Hintikka
Christopher J. Hookway
Nathan Houser
Ivo A. Ibri
Kenneth L. Ketner
John Lachs
Larry Laudan
Isaac Levi
James Liszka
Cheryl Misak
Murray G. Murphey
Klaus Oehler
Jaime Nubiola
Andrew J. Reck
Nicholas Rescher
B. Gresham Riley
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
Lucia Santaella
Israel Scheffler
Michael Shapiro
Thomas L. Short
Claudine Tiercelin
Volume 52, Number 1, Winter 2016
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
Cornelis de Waal
EDITORS
Robert Lane
Scott Pratt
BOOK REVIEW EDITOR
Sami Pihlström
ASSISTANT REVIEW EDITOR
Henrik Rydenfeldt
CONSULTING EDITORS
Thomas Alexander
Mats Bergman
Richard J. Bernstein
Rosa M. Calcaterra
James Campbell
Vincent Colapietro
Gary A. Cook
Marilyn Fischer
Mathias Girel
Susan Haack
Larry A. Hickman
David Hildebrand
John Lachs
James Liszka
John J. McDermott
Erin McKenna
Robert G. Meyers
Cheryl Misak
Matthew Moore
Jaime Nubiola
Jose-Antonio Orosco
Gregory Fernando Pappas
Ahti-Veikko Pietarinen
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
John Ryder
John R. Shook
T. L. Short
Beth Singer
John J. Stuhr
Shannon Sullivan
Paul C. Taylor
Jennifer Welchman
CHARLES S. PEIRCE SOCIETY
President
André De Tienne
Vice President
Robert Neville
Secretary-Treasurer
Shannon Dea
FELLOWS OF THE SOCIETY
Founder
Frederic Harold Young, (1905–2003)
Living Past Presidents
Robert Almeder
Douglas R. Anderson
Karl-Otto Apel
Richard J. Bernstein
Joseph Brent
Vincent Colapietro
Cornelius F. Delaney
Umberto Eco
Susan Haack
Carl R. Hausman
Risto Hilpinen
Jaakko Hintikka
Christopher J. Hookway
Nathan Houser
Kenneth L. Ketner
John Lachs
Larry Laudan
Isaac Levi
James Liszka
Cheryl Misak
Murray G. Murphey
Klaus Oehler
Jaime Nubiola
Andrew J. Reck
Nicholas Rescher
B. Gresham Riley
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
Lucia Santaella
Israel Scheffler
Michael Shapiro
Thomas L. Short
Claudine Tiercelin
Volume 51, Number 4, Winter 2015
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
Cornelis de Waal
EDITORS
Robert Lane
Scott Pratt
BOOK REVIEW EDITOR
Sami Pihlström
ASSISTANT REVIEW EDITOR
Henrik Rydenfeldt
CONSULTING EDITORS
Thomas Alexander
Mats Bergman
Richard J. Bernstein
Rosa M. Calcaterra
James Campbell
Vincent Colapietro
Gary A. Cook
Marilyn Fischer
Mathias Girel
Susan Haack
Larry A. Hickman
David Hildebrand
John Lachs
James Liszka
John J. McDermott
Erin McKenna
Robert G. Meyers
Cheryl Misak
Matthew Moore
Jaime Nubiola
Jose-Antonio Orosco
Gregory Fernando Pappas
Ahti-Veikko Pietarinen
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
John Ryder
John R. Shook
T. L. Short
Beth Singer
John J. Stuhr
Shannon Sullivan
Paul C. Taylor
Jennifer Welchman
CHARLES S. PEIRCE SOCIETY
President
Ivo A. Ibri
Vice President
André De Tienne
Secretary-Treasurer
Shannon Dea
FELLOWS OF THE SOCIETY
Founder
Frederic Harold Young, (1905–2003)
Living Past Presidents
Robert Almeder
Douglas R. Anderson
Karl-Otto Apel
Richard J. Bernstein
Joseph Brent
Vincent Colapietro
Cornelius F. Delaney
Umberto Eco
Susan Haack
Carl R. Hausman
Risto Hilpinen
Jaakko Hintikka
Christopher J. Hookway
Nathan Houser
Kenneth L. Ketner
John Lachs
Larry Laudan
Isaac Levi
James Liszka
Cheryl Misak
Murray G. Murphey
Klaus Oehler
Jaime Nubiola
Hilary Putnam
Andrew J. Reck
Nicholas Rescher
B. Gresham Riley
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
Lucia Santaella
Israel Scheffler
Michael Shapiro
Thomas L. Short
Claudine Tiercelin
Volume 51, Number 3, Summer 2015
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
Cornelis de Waal
EDITORS
Robert Lane
Scott Pratt
BOOK REVIEW EDITOR
Henrik Rydenfeldt
CONSULTING EDITORS
Thomas Alexander
Mats Bergman
Richard J. Bernstein
Rosa M. Calcaterra
James Campbell
Vincent Colapietro
Gary A. Cook
Marilyn Fischer
Mathias Girel
Susan Haack
Larry A. Hickman
David Hildebrand
John Lachs
James Liszka
John J. McDermott
Erin McKenna
Robert G. Meyers
Cheryl Misak
Matthew Moore
Jaime Nubiola
Jose-Antonio Orosco
Gregory Fernando Pappas
Ahti-Veikko Pietarinen
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
John Ryder
John R. Shook
T. L. Short
Beth Singer
John J. Stuhr
Shannon Sullivan
Paul C. Taylor
Jennifer Welchman
CHARLES S. PEIRCE SOCIETY
President
Ivo A. Ibri
Vice President
André De Tienne
Secretary-Treasurer
Shannon Dea
FELLOWS OF THE SOCIETY
Founder
Frederic Harold Young, (1905–2003)
Living Past Presidents
Robert Almeder
Douglas R. Anderson
Karl-Otto Apel
Richard J. Bernstein
Joseph Brent
Vincent Colapietro
Cornelius F. Delaney
Umberto Eco
Susan Haack
Carl R. Hausman
Risto Hilpinen
Jaakko Hintikka
Christopher J. Hookway
Nathan Houser
Kenneth L. Ketner
John Lachs
Larry Laudan
Isaac Levi
Cheryl Misak
Murray G. Murphey
Klaus Oehler
Jaime Nubiola
Hilary Putnam
Andrew J. Reck
Nicholas Rescher
B. Gresham Riley
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
Lucia Santaella
Israel Scheffler
Michael Shapiro
Thomas L. Short
Claudine Tiercelin
Volume 51, Number 2, Spring 2015
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
Cornelis de Waal
EDITORS
Robert Lane
Scott Pratt
BOOK REVIEW EDITOR
Sami Pihlström
ASSISTANT REVIEW EDITOR
Henrik Rydenfeldt
CONSULTING EDITORS
Thomas Alexander
Mats Bergman
Richard J. Bernstein
Rosa M. Calcaterra
James Campbell
Vincent Colapietro
Gary A. Cook
Marilyn Fischer
Mathias Girel
Susan Haack
Larry A. Hickman
David Hildebrand
John Lachs
James Liszka
John J. McDermott
Erin McKenna
Robert G. Meyers
Cheryl Misak
Matthew Moore
Jaime Nubiola
Jose-Antonio Orosco
Gregory Fernando Pappas
Ahti-Veikko Pietarinen
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
John Ryder
John R. Shook
T. L. Short
Beth Singer
John J. Stuhr
Shannon Sullivan
Paul C. Taylor
Jennifer Welchman
CHARLES S. PEIRCE SOCIETY
President
Vice PresidentIvo A. Ibri
André De Tienne
Secretary-Treasurer
Shannon Dea
FELLOWS OF THE SOCIETY
Founder
Frederic Harold Young, (1905–2003)
Living Past Presidents
Robert Almeder
Douglas R. Anderson
Karl-Otto Apel
Richard J. Bernstein
Joseph Brent
Vincent Colapietro
Cornelius F. Delaney
Umberto Eco
Susan Haack
Carl R. Hausman
Risto Hilpinen
Jaakko Hintikka
Christopher J. Hookway
Nathan Houser
Kenneth L. Ketner
John Lachs
Larry Laudan
Isaac Levi
Cheryl Misak
Murray G. Murphey
Klaus Oehler
Jaime Nubiola
Hilary Putnam
Andrew J. Reck
Nicholas Rescher
B. Gresham Riley
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
Lucia Santaella
Israel Scheffler
Michael Shapiro
Thomas L. Short
Claudine Tiercelin
Volume 51, Number 1, Winter 2015
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
Cornelis de Waal
EDITORS
Robert Lane
Scott Pratt
BOOK REVIEW EDITOR
Sami Pihlström
ASSISTANT REVIEW EDITOR
Henrik Rydenfeldt
CONSULTING EDITORS
Thomas Alexander
Mats Bergman
Richard J. Bernstein
Rosa M. Calcaterra
James Campbell
Vincent Colapietro
Gary A. Cook
Marilyn Fischer
Mathias Girel
Susan Haack
Larry A. Hickman
David Hildebrand
John Lachs
James Liszka
John J. McDermott
Erin McKenna
Robert G. Meyers
Cheryl Misak
Matthew Moore
Jaime Nubiola
Jose-Antonio Orosco
Gregory Fernando Pappas
Ahti-Veikko Pietarinen
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
John Ryder
John R. Shook
T. L. Short
Beth Singer
John J. Stuhr
Shannon Sullivan
Paul C. Taylor
Jennifer Welchman
CHARLES S. PEIRCE SOCIETY
President
Vice PresidentDimitra Sfendoni-Mentzou
Ivo A. Ibri
Secretary-Treasurer
Shannon Dea
FELLOWS OF THE SOCIETY
Founder
Frederic Harold Young, (1905–2003)
Living Past Presidents
Robert Almeder
Douglas R. Anderson
Karl-Otto Apel
Richard J. Bernstein
Joseph Brent
Vincent Colapietro
Cornelius F. Delaney
Umberto Eco
Susan Haack
Carl R. Hausman
Risto Hilpinen
Jaakko Hintikka
Christopher J. Hookway
Nathan Houser
Kenneth L. Ketner
John Lachs
Larry Laudan
Isaac Levi
Cheryl Misak
Murray G. Murphey
Klaus Oehler
Jaime Nubiola
Hilary Putnam
Andrew J. Reck
Nicholas Rescher
B. Gresham Riley
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
Lucia Santaella
Israel Scheffler
Michael Shapiro
Thomas L. Short
Claudine Tiercelin
Volume 50, Number 4, Fall 2014
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
Cornelis de Waal
EDITORS
Robert Lane
Scott Pratt
BOOK REVIEW EDITOR
Sami Pihlström
ASSISTANT REVIEW EDITOR
Henrik Rydenfeldt
CONSULTING EDITORS
Thomas Alexander
Mats Bergman
Richard J. Bernstein
Rosa M. Calcaterra
James Campbell
Vincent Colapietro
Gary A. Cook
Marilyn Fischer
Mathias Girel
Susan Haack
Larry A. Hickman
David Hildebrand
John Lachs
James Liszka
John J. McDermott
Erin McKenna
Robert G. Meyers
Cheryl Misak
Matthew Moore
Jaime Nubiola
Jose-Antonio Orosco
Gregory Fernando Pappas
Ahti-Veikko Pietarinen
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
John Ryder
John R. Shook
T. L. Short
Beth Singer
John J. Stuhr
Shannon Sullivan
Paul C. Taylor
Jennifer Welchman
CHARLES S. PEIRCE SOCIETY
Dimitra Sfendoni-Mentzou, President
Ivo A. Ibri, Vice President
hannon Dea, Secretary-Treasurer
FELLOWS OF THE SOCIETY
Frederic Harold Young
(1905–2003), Founder
(Living Past Presidents)Robert Almeder
Douglas R. Anderson
Karl-Otto Apel
Richard J. Bernstein
Joseph Brent
Vincent Colapietro
Cornelius F. Delaney
Umberto Eco
Susan Haack
Carl R. Hausman
Risto Hilpinen
Jaakko Hintikka
Christopher J. Hookway
Nathan Houser
Kenneth L. Ketner
John Lachs
Larry Laudan
Isaac Levi
Cheryl Misak
Murray G. Murphey
Klaus Oehler
Jaime Nubiola
Hilary Putnam
Andrew J. Reck
Nicholas Rescher
B. Gresham Riley
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
Lucia Santaella
Israel Scheffler
Michael Shapiro
Thomas L. Short
Claudine Tiercelin
Volume 50, Number 3, Summer 2014
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
Cornelis de Waal
EDITORS
Robert Lane
Scott Pratt
BOOK REVIEW EDITOR
Sami Pihlström
ASSISTANT REVIEW EDITOR
Henrik Rydenfeldt
CONSULTING EDITORS
Thomas Alexander
Mats Bergman
Richard J. Bernstein
Rosa M. Calcaterra
James Campbell
Vincent Colapietro
Gary A. Cook
Marilyn Fischer
Mathias Girel
Susan Haack
Larry A. Hickman
David Hildebrand
John Lachs
James Liszka
John J. McDermott
Erin McKenna
Robert G. Meyers
Cheryl Misak
Matthew Moore
Jaime Nubiola
Jose-Antonio Orosco
Gregory Fernando Pappas
Ahti-Veikko Pietarinen
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
John Ryder
John R. Shook
T. L. Short
Beth Singer
John J. Stuhr
Shannon Sullivan
Paul C. Taylor
Jennifer Welchman
CHARLES S. PEIRCE SOCIETY
James Liszka, President
Dimitra Sfendoni-Mentzou,
Vice President
Shannon Dea, Secretary-Treasurer
FELLOWS OF THE SOCIETY
Frederic Harold Young
(1905–2003), Founder(Living Past Presidents)
Robert Almeder
Douglas R. Anderson
Karl-Otto Apel
Richard J. Bernstein
Joseph Brent
Vincent Colapietro
Cornelius F. Delaney
Umberto Eco
Susan Haack
Carl R. Hausman
Risto Hilpinen
Jaakko Hintikka
Christopher J. Hookway
Nathan Houser
Kenneth L. Ketner
John Lachs
Larry Laudan
Isaac Levi
Cheryl Misak
Murray G. Murphey
Klaus Oehler
Jaime Nubiola
Hilary Putnam
Andrew J. Reck
Nicholas Rescher
B. Gresham Riley
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
Lucia Santaella
Israel Scheffler
Michael Shapiro
Thomas L. Short
Claudine Tiercelin
Volume 50, Number 2, Spring 2014
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
Cornelis de Waal
EDITORS
Robert Lane
Scott Pratt
BOOK REVIEW EDITOR
Sami Pihlström
ASSISTANT REVIEW EDITOR
Henrik Rydenfeldt
CONSULTING EDITORS
Thomas Alexander
Mats Bergman
Richard J. Bernstein
Rosa M. Calcaterra
James Campbell
Vincent Colapietro
Gary A. Cook
Marilyn Fischer
Mathias Girel
Susan Haack
Larry A. Hickman
David Hildebrand
John Lachs
James Liszka
John J. McDermott
Erin McKenna
Robert G. Meyers
Cheryl Misak
Matthew Moore
Jaime Nubiola
Jose-Antonio Orosco
Gregory Fernando Pappas
Ahti-Veikko Pietarinen
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
John Ryder
John R. Shook
T. L. Short
Beth Singer
John J. Stuhr
Shannon Sullivan
Paul C. Taylor
Jennifer Welchman
CHARLES S. PEIRCE SOCIETY
James Liszka, President
Dimitra Sfendoni-Mentzou,
Vice President
Shannon Dea, Secretary-Treasurer
FELLOWS OF THE SOCIETY
Frederic Harold Young
(1905–2003), Founder
(Living Past Presidents)Robert Almeder
Douglas R. Anderson
Karl-Otto Apel
Richard J. Bernstein
Joseph Brent
Vincent Colapietro
Cornelius F. Delaney
Umberto Eco
Susan Haack
Carl R. Hausman
Risto Hilpinen
Jaakko Hintikka
Christopher J. Hookway
Nathan Houser
Kenneth L. Ketner
John Lachs
Larry Laudan
Isaac Levi
Cheryl Misak
Murray G. Murphey
Klaus Oehler
Jaime Nubiola
Hilary Putnam
Andrew J. Reck
Nicholas Rescher
B. Gresham Riley
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
Lucia Santaella
Israel Scheffler
Michael Shapiro
Thomas L. Short
Claudine Tiercelin
Volume 50, Number 1, Winter 2014
Editor-in Chief
Cornelis de Waal
Editors
Robert Lane
Scott Pratt
Book Review Editor
Sami Pihlström
Assistant Review Editor
Henrik Rydenfeldt
Consulting Editors
Thomas Alexander
Mats Bergman
Richard J. Bernstein
Rosa M. Calcaterra
James Campbell
Vincent Colapietro
Gary A. Cook
Marilyn Fischer
Mathias Girel
Susan Haack
Larry A. Hickman
David Hildebrand
John Lachs
James Liszka
John J. McDermott
Erin McKenna
Robert G. Meyers
Cheryl Misak
Matthew Moore
Jaime Nubiola
Jose-Antonio Orosco
Gregory Fernando Pappas
Ahti-Veikko Pietarinen
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
John Ryder
John R. Shook
T. L. Short
Beth Singer
John J. Stuhr
Shannon Sullivan
Paul C. Taylor
Jennifer Welchman
Charles S. Pierce Society
James Liszka, President
Dimitra Sfendoni-Mentzou, Vice President
Shannon Dea, Secretary-Treasurer
Fellows of the Society
Frederic Harold Young
(1905–2003), Founder
(Living Past Presidents)
Robert Almeder
Douglas R. Anderson
Karl-Otto Apel
Richard J. Bernstein
Joseph Brent
Vincent Colapietro
Cornelius F. Delaney
Umberto Eco
Susan Haack
Carl R. Hausman
Risto Hilpinen
Jaakko Hintikka
Christopher J. Hookway
Nathan Houser
Kenneth L. Ketner
John Lachs
Larry Laudan
Isaac Levi
Cheryl Misak
Murray G. Murphey
Klaus Oehler
Jaime Nubiola
Hilary Putnam
Andrew J. Reck
Nicholas Rescher
B. Gresham Riley
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
Lucia Santaella
Israel Scheffler
Michael Shapiro
Thomas L. Short
Caudine Tiercelin
Volume 49, Number 4, Fall 2013
Editor-in-Chief
Cornelis de Waal
Editors
Robert Lane
Scott Pratt
Book Review Editor
Sami Pihlström
Assistant Review Editor
Henrik Rydenfeldt
Consulting Editors
Thomas Alexander
Mats Bergman
Richard J. Bernstein
Rosa M. Calcaterra
James Campbell
Vincent Colapietro
Gary A. Cook
Marilyn Fischer
Mathias Girel
Susan Haack
Larry A. Hickman
David Hildebrand
John Lachs
James Liszka
John J. McDermott
Erin McKenna
Robert G. Meyers
Cheryl Misak
Matthew Moore
Jaime Nubiola
Jose-Antonio Orosco
Gregory Fernando Pappas
Ahti-Veikko Pietarinen
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
John Ryder
John R. Shook
T. L. Short
Beth Singer
John J. Stuhr
Shannon Sullivan
Paul C. Taylor
Jennifer Welchman
Volume 49, Number 3, Summer 2013
Editor-in-Chief
Cornelis de Waal
Editors
Robert Lane
Scott Pratt
Book Review Editor
Sami Pihlström
Assistant Review Editor
Henrik Rydenfeldt
Consulting Editors
Thomas Alexander
Mats Bergman
Richard J. Bernstein
Rosa M. Calcaterra
James Campbell
Vincent Colapietro
Gary A. Cook
Marilyn Fischer
Mathias Girel
Susan Haack
Larry A. Hickman
David Hildebrand
John Lachs
James Liszka
John J. McDermott
Erin McKenna
Robert G. Meyers
Cheryl Misak
Matthew Moore
Jaime Nubiola
Jose-Antonio Orosco
Gregory Fernando Pappas
Ahti-Veikko Pietarinen
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
John Ryder
John R. Shook
T. L. Short
Beth Singer
John J. Stuhr
Shannon Sullivan
Paul C. Taylor
Jennifer Welchman
Volume 49, Number 2, Spring 2013
Editor-in-Chief
Cornelis de Waal
Editors
Robert Lane
Scott Pratt
Book Review Editor
Sami Pihlström
Assistant Review Editor
Henrik Rydenfeldt
Consulting Editors
Thomas Alexander
Mats Bergman
Richard J. Bernstein
Rosa M. Calcaterra
James Campbell
Vincent Colapietro
Gary A. Cook
Marilyn Fischer
Mathias Girel
Susan Haack
Larry A. Hickman
David Hildebrand
John Lachs
James Liszka
John J. McDermott
Erin McKenna
Robert G. Meyers
Cheryl Misak
Matthew Moore
Jaime Nubiola
Jose-Antonio Orosco
Gregory Fernando Pappas
Ahti-Veikko Pietarinen
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
John Ryder
John R. Shook
T. L. Short
Beth Singer
John J. Stuhr
Shannon Sullivan
Paul C. Taylor
Jennifer Welchman
Volume 49, Number 1, Winter 2013
Editor-in-Chief
Cornelis de Waal
Editors
Robert Lane
Scott Pratt
Book Review Editor
Sami Pihlström
Assistant Review Editor
Sami Pihlström
Consulting Editors
Thomas Alexander
Mats Bergman
Richard J. Bernstein
Rosa M. Calcaterra
James Campbell
Vincent Colapietro
Gary A. Cook
Marilyn Fischer
Mathias Girel
Susan Haack
Larry A. Hickman
David Hildebrand
John Lachs
James Liszka
John J. McDermott
Erin McKenna
Robert G. Meyers
Cheryl Misak
Matthew Moore
Jaime Nubiola
Jose-Antonio Orosco
Gregory Fernando Pappas
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
John Ryder
John R. Shook
T. L. Short
Beth Singer
John J. Stuhr
Shannon Sullivan
Paul C. Taylor
Jennifer Welchman
Volume 48, Number 4, Fall 2012
Editor-in-Chief
Cornelis de Waal
Editors
Robert Lane
Scott Pratt
Book Review Editor
Sami Pihlström
Consulting Editors
Thomas Alexander
Mats Bergman
Richard J. Bernstein
Rosa M. Calcaterra
James Campbell
Vincent Colapietro
Gary A. Cook
Marilyn Fischer
Mathias Girel
Susan Haack
Larry A. Hickman
David Hildebrand
John Lachs
James Liszka
John J. McDermott
Erin McKenna
Robert G. Meyers
Cheryl Misak
Matthew Moore
Jaime Nubiola
Jose-Antonio Orosco
Gregory Fernando Pappas
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
John Ryder
John R. Shook
T. L. Short
Beth Singer
John J. Stuhr
Shannon Sullivan
Paul C. Taylor
Jennifer Welchman
Volume 48, Number 3, Summer 2012
Editor-in-Chief
Cornelis de Waal
Editors
Robert Lane
Scott Pratt
Book Review Editor
Sami Pihlström
Consulting Editors
Thomas Alexander
Mats Bergman
Richard J. Bernstein
Rosa M. Calcaterra
James Campbell
Vincent Colapietro
Gary A. Cook
Marilyn Fischer
Mathias Girel
Susan Haack
Larry A. Hickman
David Hildebrand
John Lachs
James Liszka
John J. McDermott
Erin McKenna
Robert G. Meyers
Cheryl Misak
Matthew Moore
Jaime Nubiola
Jose-Antonio Orosco
Gregory Fernando Pappas
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
John Ryder
John R. Shook
T. L. Short
Beth Singer
John J. Stuhr
Shannon Sullivan
Paul C. Taylor
Jennifer Welchman
Volume 48, Number 2, Spring 2012
Editor-in-Chief
Cornelis de Waal
Editors
Robert Lane
Scott Pratt
Book Review Editor
Sami Pihlström
Consulting Editors
Thomas Alexander
Mats Bergman
Richard J. Bernstein
Rosa M. Calcaterra
James Campbell
Vincent Colapietro
Gary A. Cook
Marilyn Fischer
Mathias Girel
Susan Haack
Larry A. Hickman
David Hildebrand
John Lachs
James Liszka
John J. McDermott
Erin McKenna
Robert G. Meyers
Cheryl Misak
Matthew Moore
Jaime Nubiola
Jose-Antonio Orosco
Gregory Fernando Pappas
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
John Ryder
John R. Shook
T. L. Short
Beth Singer
John J. Stuhr
Shannon Sullivan
Paul C. Taylor
Jennifer Welchman
Volume 48, Number 1, Winter 2012
Editor-in-Chief
Cornelis de Waal
Editors
Robert Lane
Scott Pratt
Book Review Editor
Sami Pihlström
Consulting Editors
Thomas Alexander
Mats Bergman
Richard J. Bernstein
Rosa M. Calcaterra
James Campbell
Vincent Colapietro
Gary A. Cook
Marilyn Fischer
Mathias Girel
Susan Haack
Larry A. Hickman
David Hildebrand
John Lachs
James Liszka
John J. McDermott
Erin McKenna
Robert G. Meyers
Cheryl Misak
Matthew Moore
Jaime Nubiola
Jose-Antonio Orosco
Gregory Fernando Pappas
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
John Ryder
John R. Shook
T. L. Short
Beth Singer
John J. Stuhr
Shannon Sullivan
Paul C. Taylor
Jennifer Welchman
Volume 47, Number 4, Fall 2011
Editor-in-Chief
Cornelis de Waal
Editors
Robert Lane
Scott Pratt
Book Review Editor
Sami Pihlström
Consulting Editors
Thomas Alexander
Mats Bergman
Richard J. Bernstein
Rosa M. Calcaterra
James Campbell
Vincent Colapietro
Gary A. Cook
Marilyn Fischer
Mathias Girel
Susan Haack
Larry A. Hickman
David Hildebrand
John Lachs
James Liszka
John J. McDermott
Erin McKenna
Robert G. Meyers
Cheryl Misak
Matthew Moore
Jaime Nubiola
Jose-Antonio Orosco
Gregory Fernando Pappas
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
John Ryder
John R. Shook
T. L. Short
Beth Singer
John J. Stuhr
Shannon Sullivan
Paul C. Taylor
Jennifer Welchman
Volume 47, Number 3, Summer 2011
Editor-in-Chief
Cornelis de Waal
Editors
Robert Lane
Scott Pratt
Book Review Editor
Sami Pihlström
Consulting Editors
Thomas Alexander
Mats Bergman
Richard J. Bernstein
Rosa M. Calcaterra
James Campbell
Vincent Colapietro
Gary A. Cook
Marilyn Fischer
Mathias Girel
Susan Haack
Larry A. Hickman
David Hildebrand
John Lachs
James Liszka
John J. McDermott
Erin McKenna
Robert G. Meyers
Cheryl Misak
Matthew Moore
Jaime Nubiola
Jose-Antonio Orosco
Gregory Fernando Pappas
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
John Ryder
John R. Shook
T. L. Short
Beth Singer
John J. Stuhr
Shannon Sullivan
Paul C. Taylor
Jennifer Welchman
Volume 47, Number 2, Spring 2011
Editor-in-Chief
Cornelis de Waal
Editors
Robert Lane
Scott Pratt
Book Review Editor
Sami Pihlström
Consulting Editors
Thomas Alexander
Mats Bergman
Richard J. Bernstein
Rosa M. Calcaterra
James Campbell
Vincent Colapietro
Gary A. Cook
Marilyn Fischer
Mathias Girel
Susan Haack
Larry A. Hickman
David Hildebrand
John Lachs
James Liszka
John J. McDermott
Erin McKenna
Robert G. Meyers
Cheryl Misak
Matthew Moore
Jaime Nubiola
Jose-Antonio Orosco
Gregory Fernando Pappas
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
John Ryder
John R. Shook
T. L. Short
Beth Singer
John J. Stuhr
Shannon Sullivan
Paul C. Taylor
Jennifer Welchman
Volume 47, Number 1, Winter 2011
Editor-in-Chief
Cornelis de Waal
Editors
Robert Lane
Scott Pratt
Book Review Editor
Sami Pihlström
Consulting Editors
Thomas Alexander
Mats Bergman
Richard J. Bernstein
Rosa M. Calcaterra
James Campbell
Vincent Colapietro
Gary A. Cook
Marilyn Fischer
Mathias Girel
Susan Haack
Larry A. Hickman
David Hildebrand
John Lachs
James Liszka
John J. McDermott
Erin McKenna
Robert G. Meyers
Cheryl Misak
Matthew Moore
Jaime Nubiola
Jose-Antonio Orosco
Gregory Fernando Pappas
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
John Ryder
John R. Shook
T. L. Short
Beth Singer
John J. Stuhr
Shannon Sullivan
Paul C. Taylor
Jennifer Welchman
Volume 46, Number 4, Fall 2010
Editor-in-Chief
Cornelis de Waal
Editors
Robert Lane
Scott Pratt
Book Review Editor
Sami Pihlström
Consulting Editors
Thomas Alexander
Mats Bergman
Richard J. Bernstein
Rosa M. Calcaterra
James Campbell
Vincent Colapietro
Gary A. Cook
Marilyn Fischer
Mathias Girel
Susan Haack
Larry A. Hickman
David Hildebrand
John Lachs
James Liszka
John J. McDermott
Erin McKenna
Robert G. Meyers
Cheryl Misak
Matthew Moore
Jaime Nubiola
Jose-Antonio Orosco
Gregory Fernando Pappas
Don D. Roberts
Sandra B. Rosenthal
John Ryder
John R. Shook
T. L. Short
Beth Singer
John J. Stuhr
Shannon Sullivan
Paul C. Taylor
Jennifer Welchman
