In this Book

summary
Are judges supposed to be objective? Citizens, scholars, and legal professionals commonly assume that subjectivity and objectivity are opposites, with the corollary that subjectivity is a vice and objectivity is a virtue. These assumptions underlie passionate debates over adherence to original intent and judicial activism.

In Common Law Judging, Douglas Edlin challenges these widely held assumptions by reorienting the entire discussion. Rather than analyze judging in terms of objectivity and truth, he argues that we should instead approach the role of a judge’s individual perspective in terms of intersubjectivity and validity. Drawing upon Kantian aesthetic theory as well as case law, legal theory, and constitutional theory, Edlin develops a new conceptual framework for the respective roles of the individual judge and of the judiciary as an institution, as well as the relationship between them, as integral parts of the broader legal and political community. Specifically, Edlin situates a judge’s subjective responses within a form of legal reasoning and reflective judgment that must be communicated to different audiences.

Edlin concludes that the individual values and perspectives of judges are indispensable both to their judgments in specific cases and to the independence of the courts. According to the common law tradition, judicial subjectivity is a virtue, not a vice.

Table of Contents

  1. Cover
  2. open access
    • Download PDF Download
    contents
  1. Title Page, Copyright, Synopsis
  2. pp. iii-viii
  3. open access
    • Download PDF Download
    contents
  1. Contents
  2. pp. ix-x
  3. open access
    • Download PDF Download
    contents
  1. Acknowledgments
  2. pp. xi-xiv
  3. open access
    • Download PDF Download
    contents
  1. 1. Introduction
  2. pp. 1-19
  3. open access
    • Download PDF Download
    contents
  1. 2. Subjectivity, Objectivity, Impartiality
  2. pp. 20-51
  3. open access
    • Download PDF Download
    contents
  1. 3. Subjectivity and Intersubjectivity
  2. pp. 52-76
  3. open access
    • Download PDF Download
    contents
  1. 4. Making Law
  2. pp. 77-89
  3. open access
    • Download PDF Download
    contents
  1. 5. Judicial Individualism and Judicial Independence
  2. pp. 90-109
  3. open access
    • Download PDF Download
    contents
  1. 6. Conclusion
  2. pp. 110-125
  3. open access
    • Download PDF Download
    contents
  1. Table of Authorities
  2. pp. 127-132
  3. open access
    • Download PDF Download
    contents
  1. Notes
  2. pp. 133-228
  3. open access
    • Download PDF Download
    contents
  1. References
  2. pp. 229-244
  3. open access
    • Download PDF Download
    contents
  1. Index of Subjects
  2. pp. 245-256
  3. open access
    • Download PDF Download
    contents
  1. Index of Names
  2. pp. 257-266
  3. open access
    • Download PDF Download
    contents

Additional Information

ISBN
9780472122158
Related ISBN
9780472130023
MARC Record
OCLC
956541684
Pages
312
Launched on MUSE
2016-08-15
Language
English
Open Access
Yes
Back To Top

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Without cookies your experience may not be seamless.