Shaping History with Dialogues: Feng Youlan's Reconstruction of the Pre-Qin Philosopher Yang Zhu

The writing of histories of Chinese philosophy in the first half of the twentieth century was pivotal in sustaining Chinese philosophy as a sub-discipline under philosophy. Feng Youlan's 馮友蘭 (1895–1990) two-volume The History of Chinese Philosophy stands as a milestone contribution in the field of Chinese philosophy. However, the combined publication of the two volumes in 1934 overshadowed the publication of the first volume in 1931. The 1931 edition thus remains largely overlooked in the field of Chinese philosophy. In this article, I take Feng's discussion of the pre-Qin Yang Zhu as my focal point to examine the differences between the 1931 and 1934 editions, demonstrating how Feng's narration of Chinese philosophy was shaped by his engagement in the discourse on Chinese philosophy of his time and how his revised interpretation became definitive for the contemporary understanding of Yang Zhu.