In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content:

  • Beckon Us From HomeEnlisting in a Patriotic Education
  • Sarah Blesener (bio) and Rebecca Onion (bio)

Click for larger view
View full resolution

JROTC students from Fern Creek High School (Louisville, KY) practice for the National Drill Team Championships, which takes place in Daytona Beach, FL. Fern Creek’s Lady Leathernecks hold the all-time record for championship titles. JROTC is one of the largest youth programs in the world, with over 310,000 American high-school students enrolled.

[End Page 159]

In America, in 2018, the word “patriotism” has taken on a particular meaning. “Patriotic” equals militaristic, patriarchal, obedient, maybe xenophobic; it evokes guns, red meat, the NFL, and the Republican National Convention. No matter how hard Democrats and liberals try to reclaim the word—to make the point that you can be “patriotic” while also believing that there are problems with the country—they haven’t been able to do it.

“Patriotic education” sounds, to liberal ears, like right-wing indoctrination. But it wasn’t always this way. Plenty of twentieth-century progressive educators saw the inculcation of a civic-minded, community-oriented flavor of patriotism as part of their duties. But after Vietnam-era protests against militarism, and the work of the civil rights movements in the sixties and seventies, the ideal of “patriotic education” fell out of fashion in American public schools. Today, national youth groups, like the Boy Scouts and Girl Scouts, invoke patriotism in specialized ways, but don’t center it in their curricula. The onetime monoculture of mainstream childhood patriotism is largely gone.

When photographer Sarah Blesener went looking for groups of kids who were undergoing contemporary patriotic education, she found that this rightward shift in the word’s meaning made it easy for her to identify the kinds of groups she’d like to photograph. If the adults associated with a program used the word “patriotism” (or, say, “Americanism”) in a conversation or a mission statement, the group was of interest. Recording kids’ experiences at patriotic education camps and programs, she thought, [End Page 160] would let her see how the political trickles down and becomes personal.


Click for larger view
View full resolution

Kayla Wayman (center) is in charge of ensuring that all of the cadet students are in their seats and at attention before driving to the South Dakota Air and Space Museum, at Ellsworth Air Force Base, Rapid City, SD. Students from five states around the Midwest spend a week at the Civil Air Patrol Joint Dakota Cadet Encampment.

Blesener found access to some of these groups to be difficult—the adults in charge distrusted the media. And the leaders’ concern is legitimate. People outside of the kinds of circles who might send a child to a patriotism camp, who hear of Blesener’s project, expect to see a certain kind of image: a line of uniformed children, their rounded kid faces and gangly bodies forming a striking contrast to the militarism of their attitudes. Blesener started this work on patriotic education inspired by old propaganda photos of children in formation, but soon found the depiction of these militaristic moments to be limiting and glib. In her work, you do see plenty of uniforms, but there are also many pictures of kids dancing, swimming, or goofing around—kids in the process of growing up. “Youth,” Blesener said, “really destroy the binary we have between left and right, good and bad, right and wrong.”

The photographs of the Border Patrol Explorers, who are almost all Mexican American, go a long way to challenge that binary. These kids practice apprehending “immigrants,” learn to navigate the terrain around the border, and enter virtual-reality environments for training purposes, just like adult Border Patrol agents. Blesener’s understated images poke at our expectations about the kinds of children who might be interested in policing the border.

There are many weapons in these photographs—some replicas (like the ones used by the Border Patrol Explorers) and some real. Blesener tries not to over-rely on the shock value of these images, but the weapon photos inevitably fascinate. Last year, when she asked the kids why they had signed up, talk of illegal immigration...

pdf

Additional Information

ISSN
2154-6932
Print ISSN
0042-675X
Pages
pp. 158-179
Launched on MUSE
2019-01-18
Open Access
No
Back To Top

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Without cookies your experience may not be seamless.