History as Argument for Revision in Moral Theology: A Review Discussion

HISTORY AS ARGUMENT FOR REVISION IN MORAL THEOLOGY: A REVIEW DISCUSSION GERMAIN GRISEZ Mount Saint Mary's College; Emmitsburg, Maryland, JOHN MAHONEY, S.J., forme11ly a professor of moral theology at Heythrop College and now the Frederick Denison Maurice Pro£essor 0£ Moral and Social Theology at King's Col1ege, London, presented the Martin D'Arcy Memorial Lectures in Campion Hall, Oxford, in the spring of 1982. He now has expanded these lectures and published them, with extensive notes, in a book which is both erudite and readable.1 To save space, I shall not summarize Mahoney's book here,2 nor shaH I deal with various interesting ideas in it which deserve discussion among professional theologians. Rather, I shall evaluate the book from a single, rather narrow point of view: its appropriateness for use as a historical introduction to Catholic moral theology. I