“To Know Christ in the Father, Christ in the Flesh, and Christ in the Eucharist”: The Comprehensive Scope of Classical Christology in the Twelfth Century

219 The Thomist 78 (2014): 219-45 “TO KNOW CHRIST IN THE FATHER, CHRIST IN THE FLESH, AND CHRIST IN THE EUCHARIST”:1 THE COMPREHENSIVE SCOPE OF CLASSICAL CHRISTOLOGY IN THE TWELFTH CENTURY BOYD TAYLOR COOLMAN Boston College Chestnut Hill, Massachusetts CHOLARLY INTEREST in the theology of the “long twelfth century” shows no signs of abating.2 On the contrary , the ongoing conversation has reached the point where revisionist approaches now question earlier commonplaces .3 At the same time, despite agreement about the existence of this distinct era in the High Middle Ages, little consensus exists about how best to characterize its chief concerns, characteristics, and accomplishments. Indeed, a remarkable variety of “theological styles” coexists in a century that includes figures as diverse as Anselm of Canterbury, Peter Abelard, Hugh and Richard of St. Victor, Bernard of Clairvaux, William of St. Thierry, Hildegard of Bingen, Peter Lombard, and Peter Comestor—to name only the more well-known. In the mid-twentieth century, one historian characterized this period as “the most uncompromisingly christocentric period of 1 Baldwin of Ford, De sacramento altaris, ed. and French trans. J Morson, E de Solms, and J Leclercq, Sources chrétiennes 93-94 (Paris,1963). 2 “Long” reflects a consensus that a unity encompasses the forms of theological discourse that flourished in the period between (roughly) the Eucharistic debates in the 1050s and the Gregorian reforms of the 1070s, on the one hand, and, on the other hand, the formal incorporation of the universities (especially at Paris), the fuller assimilation of Aristotle, and the appearance of the Mendicant Orders in the first three decades of the 1200s. 3 Rachel Fulton Brown, “Three-in-One: Making God in Twelfth-Century Liturgy, Theology, and Devotion,” in European Transformations: The Long Twelfth Century (Notre Dame, Ind.: University of Notre Dame Press, 2012), 468-97. S 220 BOYD TAYLOR COOLMAN Western civilization.” 4 Since then, a cottage industry has focused on the twelfth-century “discovery” of and devotion to the humanity of Jesus.5 Yet, recently the Dominican scholar Gilles Emery has argued that “the Trinitarian question constitutes the great theme of twelfth-century theology,”6 which inaugurated the “golden age of Trinitarian reflection in the West.”7 Yet again, if one considers the Eucharistic debates between Lanfranc and Berengar in the 1050s and the pronouncements of Lateran IV in 1215, and then observes in between the avalanche of treatises with the words “body and blood” in their titles, one could also claim the twelfth as the century of the Eucharist. So—Christ, Trinity, Eucharist—which is it? Or is this a false question, created by problematic assumptions of modern historians? Recently, Rachael Fulton Brown, a leading religious historian of the twelfth century, has 4 Ernst H. Kantorowicz, The King’s Two Bodies: A Study of Medieval Political Theology (Princeton: Princeton University, 1957), 61. More precisely, Kantorowicz intends “roughly, the monastic period from 900 to A.D. 1100” (ibid.). That the scope of his observation deserves to be extended somewhat will be borne out below. 5 The literature on this theme is vast. In the middle of the twentieth century, R. W. Southern observed: “This power of St. Anselm and St. Bernard to give varied and coherent expression to the perceptions and aspirations which they shared with their contemporaries is most clearly seen in their treatment of the central theme of Christian thought: the life of Christ and the meaning of the Crucifixion. The theme of tenderness and compassion for the sufferings and helplessness of the Saviour of the world was one which had a new birth in the monasteries of the eleventh century, and every century since then has paid tribute to the monastic inspiration of this century by some new development of this theme” (R. W. Southern, The Making of the Middle Ages [New Haven: Yale University, 1953] 231). See also Rachel Fulton, From Judgment to Passion: Devotion to Christ and the Virgin Mary, 800–1200 (New York: Columbia University, 2002). For later developments, see Ellen M. Ross, The Grief of God: Images of the Suffering Jesus in Late Medieval England (New York: Oxford University, 1997); and Paul Gondreau, The Passions of Christ's Soul in the...