publisher colophon
Reviewed by:
Finding the Great Western Trail. By Sylvia Gann Mahoney. (Lubbock: Texas Tech University Press, 2015. Pp. 300. Illustrations, maps, notes, bibliography, index.)

In Finding the Great Western Trail, Sylvia Gann Mahoney observes, “myths survive even when confronted by truth” (27). Indeed, this is certainly true in Texas, where popular fiction frequently trumps historical fact, most notably in regard to the state’s legendary cattle trails. Mahoney’s seven-year quest to document one major route, the Western Cattle Trail, encountered a number of myth-busting challenges. Foremost among these is the considerable confusion that exists in Texas regarding the correct names of cattle trails throughout the state.

Mahoney’s introduction provides a standard overview of Texas’s major trails, including the Goodnight-Loving Trail and the Chisholm Trail. Many people (including Mahoney) mistakenly believe that in 1866, Charles Goodnight and Oliver Loving laid out the route to Fort Sumner, New Mexico, that now bears their names. In fact, as this reviewer has documented, this trail was blazed during the Civil War by cowboys working for John Chisum, driving illicit herds from Confederate West Texas to sell to the Union Army in New Mexico.

Mahoney then turns to the Chisholm Trail, a contested topic. Taking a traditionally accepted view, Mahoney states that this legendary route originated in South Texas. However, since the 1930s, a number of cattle drive experts have disputed this claim. They contend that the Chisholm, named after freighter Jesse Chisholm, did not run south of the Red River. Instead they argue that the trail in Texas that connected with the Chisholm at the Red River was known as the Eastern Trail. (This debate continues today, hence it is referenced as both the Chisolm and the Eastern Trail.)

Moving on to the Western Trail, Mahoney notes that over the years some people have also conflated what they understood to be the Chisholm with the Western. In an attempt to clarify matters, she explains that the Western and the Chisholm/Eastern were two parallel trails that ran 90 to 150 miles apart. Both originated in South Texas and ran northward along the western edge of the Great Plains. In Texas, the Western passed through Kerrville, Coleman, Albany, and Vernon, while the Chisholm/ Eastern went through Austin, Waco, and Fort Worth.

Citing research by Western Trail historians Jimmy Skaggs and Gary and Margaret Kraisinger, Mahoney says that cowboys began using the Western extensively during the 1870s, after “Kansas legislators closed . . . the Chisholm Trail . . . to herds from Texas” and “trail bosses moved their herds west.” The Western Trail “filled the void left by the Chisholm Trail” (13). Although acknowledging the importance of the Chisholm, Mahoney’s work restores the Western Trail to its well-deserved place in history. [End Page 264]

To that end, in 2004, Mahoney and members of the Vernon, Texas, chapter of Rotary International, led a Rotary project to place markers along the Western Trail from Mexico to Canada. Finding the Great Western Trail documents this seven-year effort. Mahoney includes engaging and informative historical snapshots of the communities located along the Western as well as pictures and stories of marker dedications by local Rotary clubs.

Mahoney, a former teacher and rodeo coach, founded the Western Heritage Center in Lovington, New Mexico. In Finding the Great Western Trail, she has crafted an inspiring story of communities across Texas and North America banding together to help preserve their shared history. The fact that this major undertaking to commemorate and preserve the Western Trail was such a success is a testament to Mahoney and her fellow Rotarians.

Glen Sample Ely
Fort Worth, Texas

Additional Information

Print ISSN
Launched on MUSE
Open Access
Back To Top

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Without cookies your experience may not be seamless.