Born This Way dir. by Shaun Kadlec and Debb Tullmann (review)

Before sodomy laws were introduced by colonialists, nonheterosexual practices certainly existed in Africa—among the Nilotico Langa men in Uganda, for instance, in the Azande community of northern Congo, and among the Dan Daudis in northern Nigeria. Of course, single-sex relationships still exist, and as Christian and Muslim fundamentalists promote homophobia on the continent, the members of the LGBT community in Africa are fighting for their survival. The documentary Born This Way, directed and produced by Shaun Kadlec and Debb Tullmann (www.bornthiswaydocumentary.com), captures the resilience and activism of such individuals by tracing the lives of four gay Cameroonians: Cedric, Gertrude, Pascaline, and Esther. All are defendants in a legal action in which they are being represented by Alice Nkom, a famous Cameroonian gay rights attorney.

The film is impressive in many ways, not the least of which is its portrayal of the “hustle” of gay life in a Cameroonian city against the general bustle of the urban scene. But it also is successful in portraying the challenges of these four individual lives, inspiring a respect and compassion for them that indeed is sometimes experienced by those around them. In one scene, for instance, Pascaline has an interesting conversation with the male taxi driver who is transporting her to a temporary safe space provided by Alice Nkom. The driver asks why she prefers not to have sex with men, and her response—that she does not like being dominated—interests and amazes him, rather than infuriating him. Because Pascaline has made the effort to educate him, the man seems to experience an actual moment of epiphany. In another scene Gertrude visits the convent where she was raised after being abandoned by her abusive father at age six. During this visit she struggles to reveal that she is a lesbian, and the mother superior who had raised her as her own child reacts calmly. The sister talks about the need to respect all people’s lives, even if some people do not accept all forms of sexuality. Gertrude and the nun tour the convent and Gertrude stumbles upon a gun, which at first startles her. But the sister explains that it is just an air gun for scaring away the crows. It is striking here that the lives of these nuisance creatures are respected and spared, whereas homosexuals face violence and even death.

Other scenes are equally powerful. In the flickering candlelight of a romantic encounter, Gertrude tells her lover about her experience of rape. Leaving church one day, Gertrude and three friends were approached by several men, who called out to them and then, when they were ignored, taunted them as lesbians. The women were then attacked and raped, and though Gertrude woke up in the hospital five days later, her friends did not survive. The shadowy background lighting of the scene captures not just the intensity of the narration, but also the shadowy lives of LGBT Africans: both the gloom that surrounds them, and the ignorance and darkness that stalk them. In another scene we follow Cedric as he walks toward home through a series of narrow paths, perhaps symbolic of the tight route that gays must navigate in Cameroon. At a night club he meets Gertrude, his co-worker at a nongovernmental LGBT organization called Alternatives Cameroun. He recounts a number of harrowing experiences to her: how a group of homophobic men slit his stomach and left him for dead, and how he has received a threatening note calling him “dirty faggot” and instructing him to leave the neighborhood. Later he goes to visit his mother and shudders at the possibility of coming out to her. In his words, “family is everything.”

Nevertheless, there are moments of joy in the film. In one scene Pascaline and Esther are delighted to learn about the existence of Alternatives Cameroun, which functions as a haven where they can breathe...