- Constructing Private Governance: The Rise and Evolution of Forest, Coffee, and Fisheries Certification by Graeme Auld
See that fair-trade sticker on your coffee? That dolphin-safe emblem on your tuna can? The certificate of sustainability that comes with your new wooden furniture? Plenty of consumers have, too, and in recent years, the environmentally and socially conscious shopper has become a fixture of retail in North America and Europe. Many of us seek out ethical and environmentally sustainable products, and are willing to pay a premium for such products. But where do those labels come from? What drives their creation and evolution? And who decides the scope of certification?
Graeme Auld’s book, Constructing Private Governance, works toward a more complete understanding of private certification and its place in contemporary discussions of global governance. Situated within the emerging literature on private governance and environmental politics, Auld impressively explains why some certification programs have organized faster than others and accounts for variation in certification schemes across industries. By uncovering the contested political histories of private certifications, Auld begins building a theory of private governance that explains why and how certain types of certification emerge. He traces the histories of certification across three industries—forestry, coffee, and fisheries—and tests ten hypotheses about market and political structures and the design and reproduction of certification programs.
Auld’s hypotheses are built upon a brief but accessible review of path dependence literatures in both economics and political science. Conventional approaches in both fields are found to be ill-equipped to deepen our understanding of the new challenges of private governance: “Certification programs occupy the middle ground between political authority and market exchange; they give more options for exit than the former and more options for voice than the latter” (p. 221). Indeed, though many scholars of political science have shifted to analyzing private governance as a global phenomenon, understanding the actions and decisions of private firms and NGOs requires a broader understanding of both market and political structures and the options available to various actors.
Auld thus begins his analysis of each industry from an understanding of its respective market and political structures, specifying how barriers to entry [End Page 106] and market concentration might favor either local or global certification. From there, he maps the initiation of certification programs and how early preferences can dictate later consolidation or fragmentation. Each study provides an in-depth history of private certification experiences in the industry. Auld convincingly demonstrates the effects of market demand for certification, its policy scope, and the degree of inclusiveness in certification programs. Indeed, he succeeds in showing how initial conditions and early decisions are important, as are the “mechanisms of reproduction and change” (pp. 51–52) that follow.
The book has many strengths. It makes a significant contribution to the literature on private governance, illustrating the many elements shaping the emergence of these certifications and the various actors and interests involved. Auld’s review of the path dependence literature is also clear and insightful. Indeed, a strong case is made for political scientists and economists to be in closer conversation with each other. Auld adroitly notes how important it is to look at several factors in relation to the broader structures and dynamics at work, and demonstrates the limits of trying to isolate any single element to explain the complex nature of private governance. In addition, the treatment of each industry and its certification programs is comprehensive. Each industry is analyzed over the course of two chapters, providing empirical depth that scholars of private governance and environmental politics will find useful.
The weaknesses of the book are mostly matters of style. At times, the histories of certification are a bit cumbersome. Though the complicated story of coffee certification effectively contrasts with more streamlined certifications, such as in the forestry sector, it may be worthy of a book of its own. And while the exercise of testing hypotheses highlights the complexity of the issues at hand and ties the analysis back to the book’s...