In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content:

  • Intertextual Absences"Turner" and Turner
  • Hillary Gravendyk

The Guyaneseborn British poet David Dabydeen regularly uses his work to interrogate the linguistic and psychic problems associated with imperialism, diaspora, and dislocation. One of Dabydeen's primary cultural projects is to reveal what he calls the "pornography of empire" (Döring 193), and with his long poem "Turner" he takes up this project once more, this time by forging a complicated intertextual relationship between his poem and J.M.W. Turner's famous painting Slavers Throwing Over the Dead and Dying, Typhoon Coming, hereafter referred to by its common name, Slave Ship. The painting depicts a slave ship imperiled in a storm-tossed sea, which has jettisoned its human cargo.1 In the foreground of the image, hands, a shackled foot, and a partially submerged head are visible above the waves. In what critics have called a "writing back" or "counter-discourse" to the painting,2 Dabydeen constructs "a body, a biography, and… an imagined landscape" (Dabydeen 7) for the obscured figure in Turner's painting, a figure that, as Dabydeen puts it in the preface to his poem, "has been drowned in Turner's (and other artists') sea for centuries" (7). Indeed, the drowning figure who speaks in "Turner" literally rewrites the world in that he has the prelapsarian agency to name the objects of his world, giving "fresh names to birds and fish / And humankind all things living but unknown, / Dimly recalled, or dead" (9). Among these is a stillborn child that floats past, which the figure renames "Turner," as if in retribution against the artist who created in oils the figure's death. It is, however, an ambivalent retribution, for as the figure proceeds to describe a childhood on the African coast, he alternately focalizes himself and the child he has just renamed "Turner," thus identifying with the child and through it, with J. M. W. Turner himself. The stillborn child is therefore less a child than a site where a set of invented and converging histories may unfold: "what was deemed mere food for sharks will become / my fable" (9) crows Dabydeen's speaker, and it is a fable rather than a subject that the poem delivers. Indeed, Dabydeen's poem does not attempt to retrieve a coherent, or even a split, subjectivity for the drowned victim of Slave Ship; instead, the poet slips between fictive and historical figures (the dead child named Turner, the painter J. M. W. Turner, the poem's drowning speaker) as potential sites for palimpsestic histories that supersede any notion of subjecthood. Further, the multiple histories of Turner's Slave [End Page 161] Ship point to the ways in which such layered histories can supersede even the subjective experience of the visual. Dabydeen's poem and Turner's painting both communicate between and among these histories; taken together they communicate the way in which history proliferates in the interstices of subjectivity and the manner in which history is poised to overwhelm the subject.


Click for larger view
View full resolution
Figure 1.

Slave Ship (Slavers Throwing Overboard the Dead and Dying, Typhoon Coming On), Joseph Mallord William Turner, 99.22, Museum of Fine Arts, Boston.

To invent a new history, however, is not necessarily to disavow the historical. As Walter Benjamin has argued "to articulate the past historically does not mean to recognize it 'the way it really was'…. It means to seize hold of a memory as it flashes up at a moment of danger" (255). And indeed, Dabydeen's poetic articulation of an invented past manages to be "historical" without being factual. The histories are given as childhood memories, and those memories are shot through with the primal "moment of danger"—the arrival of the slavers. In "Turner," Dabydeen's speaker posits a series of plausible pasts in an effort to fill the historical void that an act of "creative amnesia" entails. And while some critics have characterized these narratives as "utopian"3—even Dabydeen calls them a fantasy of an "idyllic past"—these moments of fantasy are haunted by the history they seek to forget. The childhood that is recounted, replete with its remembered wounds, portends how history, home, and...

pdf