Reviewed by:
The British Atlantic World, 1500-1800. Edited by David Armitage and Michael J. Braddick. Pp. xx, 324. ISBN 0333963415. Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan. 2002. £49.50.

According to J.H. Elliot, the rise of the new Atlantic history is 'one of the most important new historiographical developments of recent years'. Along with the new British history, it is forcing scholars of early modern England, Scotland, Ireland and North America out of the comfort zone of their national histories. It 'pushes historians towards methodological pluralism and expanded horizons' (p. 27), and challenges us to 'trace connections' and 'draw comparisons' (p. 236).

David Armitage and Michael Braddick have edited an outstanding primer that will be warmly welcomed by first-time sailors and experienced navigators of this oceanic field. The collection is topped and tailed by two of the doyens of the new Atlantic history, Bernard Bailyn (who writes the Preface) and John Elliot (who provides the Afterword). Armitage himself contributes the introductory essay, a sophisticated theoretical analysis of the new subject. But the heart of the book lies in ten thematic essays arranged into three categories. The first category, 'Connections', contains pieces on migration (Alison Games), the economy (Nuala Zahedieh) and religion (Carla Pestana); the second, 'Identities', covers civility and authority (Braddick), gender (Sarah Pearsall), class (Keith Wrightson) and race (Joyce Chaplin); and the third, 'Politics', tackles empire and state (Elizabeth Mancke), revolution and counter-revolution (Eliga Gould) and slavery (Christopher Brown).

The topics covered indicate the diversity and ambition of the new Atlantic history. If the emergence of the new British history was largely driven by the questions of political historians (especially concerning the origins of the English Civil War), Atlantic history is more wide-ranging in its origins and scope--both thematically and geographically. The essays assembled in this unusually coherent collection provide wonderfully compressed overviews of their topics. Inevitably, some subjects lend themselves to the Atlantic approach more than others--as Elliot observes, migration and slavery are particularly well suited to this kind of treatment, and it is no surprise that the essays by Games and Brown are among the most satisfying. But the quality of the collection as a whole is very high, and each piece is packed with striking detail and provocative generalisation. Elliot even offers a speculative piece of 'counter-factual Atlantic history' in which Christopher Columbus enters the service of Henry VII of England and an expedition of five hundred West Countrymen conquers the Aztecs, with world-historical consequences (pp. 241-43).

There are also, however, some questionable statements. Gould suggests that 'Few historians would dispute the interconnectedness of what they now describe as the "three British revolutions" of 1641, 1688, and 1776' (p. 196). In fact, few scholars apart from John Pocock (to whom Gould refers) show the slightest interest in the connections between 1641 and 1776, and many historians of the English Civil War would insist that if a 'revolution' took place at all it did not do so until 1648-49. On another matter, historians of the Covenanter Parliaments will be surprised at the claim that the Glorious Revolution 'opened the way for the first truly independent parliaments in Scottish history' (p. 203). In other essays, the vastness of the subject inspires grandiose phrases--'inter-hemispheric civilisation' (p. xiv) will presumably appeal to sci-ence-fiction fans. The new subject is even generating new jargon. We read of 'circum-Atlantic history', 'Trans-Atlantic history', 'Cis-Atlantic history', the 'white' Atlantic, the 'black' Atlantic, the 'red' Atlantic, the 'multicoloured' [End Page 155] Atlantic and even the 'green' Atlantic (a reference to the Irish, not to ecology). One can only be grateful that there is as yet no sign of a 'tartan Atlantic'.

Scotland, in fact, does not loom particularly large. It receives reasonable coverage in the essays on migration and revolution, but in several others the Scots make only a token appearance. The index contains more references to Ireland, not least because it was such an important trial-ground for English colonialism. Scotland's relatively low profile reflects the fact that for much of the period from 1500 to 1800 the majority of Scots were facing East rather than West. As Games suggests, 'In their Atlantic orientation the English were distinct from the Scots, who were precociously European in orientation' (p. 37). Of course, the Scots made up for lost time in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, though the authors of this volume were unable to benefit from the latest studies of Scottish overseas migration, such as Tom Devine's Scotland's Empire, 1600-1815 (2003) and Marjory Harper's Adventurers and Exiles: The Great Scottish Exodus (2003).

Despite this, historians of Scotland will find this to be a very stimulating collection. It provides a broader framework for national histories, and succeeds admirably in its task of pushing historians towards expanded horizons.

John Coffey
University Of Leicester

Additional Information

ISSN
1750-0222
Print ISSN
0036-9241
Launched on MUSE
2006-07-06
Open Access
No
Archive Status
Archived 2009
Back To Top

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Without cookies your experience may not be seamless.