- Collecting Cultural Magazines’ Retrospectives
Although I must own well over ten thousand books, I have only recently set out to collect books within a certain category. Most of my books were obtained for a particular project: sometimes a work currently in progress, sometimes for a past project in which I maintain an active interest, but more often for those that I am planning to do in the future. In the course of my professional life, I have accumulated substantial amounts of contemporary American literature; criticism of contemporary literature; avant-garde literature; book-art books; criticism of avant-garde art and literature; various editions of books by favorite authors (such as Henry Miller, John Barth); and books by my friends. In no case are any of these accumlations complete, and I doubt that they ever will be.
My first publication was in a university quarterly that did not pay its authors; and although writing has been my principal source of income for over three decades, I continue to contribute to such eleemosynary journals, thinking that the abundance of them is a true index of cultural opportunity in America and thus that my continuing contributions to them constitute my principal charity. (Not all their alumni are so nostalgic, needless to say.) While my library includes shelf upon shelf of such cultural journals, more significant, I think, is the collection I have made of what I call self-retrospectives: the books in which such magazines select the best work to appear in their pages. Examples include The American Scholar Reader (1960), the Evergreen Review Reader (1968), and The Stiffest of the Corpse: An Exquisite Corpse Reader (1989). Although such books customarily appear in modest editions designed initially for the magazines’ loyal subscribers or as special issues celebrating decade(s)-long anniversaries, they ideally give their editors an opportunity to show, better than a single issue, how they want to be regarded by posterity.
The advantages of collecting cultural journals’ self-retrospectives are that no one else known to me is concentrating on them and that there cannot be many of them. I own a few hundred. The category is so unfamiliar that I customarily must explain it at least twice, even to a bookseller eager to unload his inventory. The category of cultural magazines necessarily [End Page 113] excludes commercial magazines. While the New Yorker clearly belongs to the latter category, if only because commercial publishers have long been eager to publish collections of anything from its pages, other slick-papered periodicals are more problematic. Apologetically, I will admit to having some (although not all) volumes culled from Esquire, Sports Illustrated, Rolling Stone, Playboy, and Vogue, among others. Extending my taste for irony into book-collecting, I also own retrospectives from American Boy, The American Golfer, Streetwise: The Journal of Portfolio Management, and even from Weightwatchers and Zymurgy: America’s #1 Home Brewing Magazine.
Some retrospectives appear long after the magazine has died. I have A Dial Miscellany (1963), Civil Liberties and the Arts: Selections from Twice A Year 1938–1948 (1964), Writers in Revolt: The Anvil Anthology 1933–1940 (1973), and The Smart Set: A History and Anthology (1966), all of them selected by people other than the original editors. Some of these books appear as a magazine is dying and perhaps dies once the retrospective appears, such as Between C and D (1988) and Edmund Carpenter’s and Marshall McLuhan’s Explorations in Communication (1960).
Other self-retrospectives are paperback expansions of books initially appearing in hardback, so that Hightlights of One Hundred Twenty-Five Years of the Atlantic (1983) adds several selections to One Hundred Nineteen Years of the Atlantic (1977) without even mentioning the predecessor. My collection includes retrospective volumes from art magazines, such as Umbrella and Artforum, the pioneering architectural magazine Archigram, and such music magazines as Perspecives of New Music and High Fidelity. I have selections from political magazines, such as the Socialist Voices of Dissent (1958) and Twenty-Five Years of Dissent (1979), the pacifist Seeds of Liberation (1964), and the conservative Modern Age: The First Thirty-Five Years, a Selection (1988), in addition to Echoes of Revolt: The Masses 1911–1917 (1966...