-
A Response to My "Critics"
- Hypatia
- Indiana University Press
- Volume 16, Number 2, Spring 2001
- pp. 86-90
- 10.1353/hyp.2001.0026
- Article
- Additional Information
This essay is a response to comments made by Shane Phelan, Cheshire Calhoun, and Naomi Scheman on my book The Play of Reason: From the Modern to the Postmodern (1999). I reiterate my belief that we best approach the issue of consensus and dissension in second-order justifications of social and political claims not philosophically but sociologically, politically, historically. I suggest similar approaches for dealing with the question of meaning. This move signals an endorsement not of indifference but rather of commitment and humility.