We are unable to display your institutional affiliation without JavaScript turned on.
Browse Book and Journal Content on Project MUSE

Find using OpenURL

Showdown in the Sonoran Desert by Amanda Rose (review)

From: American Catholic Studies
Volume 124, Number 2, Summer 2013
pp. 98-99 | 10.1353/acs.2013.0019

In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content:

Amanda Rose's Showdown in the Sonoran Desert begins and ends in inhospitable land between Arizona and the Mexican state of Sonora where at least 2,000 migrants have died trying to make it to the promised land. The "showdown" is the face-off between two apparently irreconcilable visions, one of migrants as human beings of worth and dignity, the other of fearsome strangers who have broken the law.

Many books on unauthorized Latino immigration to the United States are either dry academic treatises on one hand, or impassioned polemics on the other. Rose's short book is neither; it is both beautifully written and even-handed. She is a published poet and journalist, and it shows. At times her sympathy for the migrants does show through, but she presents both sides fairly. Since she recently received her doctorate, she could be forgiven the usual academic "objectivity," but we see none of that distancing in her book. The people whose stories she tells are people, not research "subjects." Their stories illustrate and illuminate the intertwined economic, social, and theological threads of a very complex issue.

She devotes the first half of her book, "God in the Desert: Migrant Deaths and the Rise of Border Ministries," to an examination of the point of view of faith-based activists who see the issue as moral, their guiding principle the biblical tradition of unconditional hospitality. She tells stories of organizations such as Humane Borders and No More Deaths who blame the deaths in the desert on U.S. immigration policy and are working both to prevent more deaths and to bring about immigration reform. She summarizes the overall viewpoint of Part One as follows: "This is the general stance of the Catholic Church and many Protestant coalitions along the border: not only is it not illegal (italics in original) to migrate according to need; it is a 'God-given' right" (43).

Part Two, "Law in the Desert: Security, Sovereignty, and the Natural Rights of the State" presents the other vision. Yes, most of those who come illegally are hard-working people looking to improve their lot in life, but some are terrorists, drug smugglers, rapists and murderers. Yes, the deaths are tragedies, but a nation has the right to control its borders. She tells the stories of ranchers who live in fear, Border Patrol officers who treat the migrants with compassion, and Minutemen who see themselves as protecting honest citizens from migrants whose first act in their new country is to break its laws.

No matter which side of this issue you are on, and most of us are on one side or the other, the author's even-handedness and skillful writing ensures that you will learn something about the other side of the issue. What more could you ask?

Copyright © 2013 American Catholic Historical Society
Project MUSE® - View Citation
Dawn McCarty. "Showdown in the Sonoran Desert by Amanda Rose (review)." American Catholic Studies 124.2 (2013): 98-99. Project MUSE. Web. 29 Jul. 2013. <http://muse.jhu.edu/>.
McCarty, D.(2013). Showdown in the Sonoran Desert by Amanda Rose (review). American Catholic Studies 124(2), 98-99. American Catholic Historical Society. Retrieved July 29, 2013, from Project MUSE database.
Dawn McCarty. "Showdown in the Sonoran Desert by Amanda Rose (review)." American Catholic Studies 124, no. 2 (2013): 98-99. http://muse.jhu.edu/ (accessed July 29, 2013).
T1 - Showdown in the Sonoran Desert by Amanda Rose (review)
A1 - Dawn McCarty
JF - American Catholic Studies
VL - 124
IS - 2
SP - 98
EP - 99
PY - 2013
PB - American Catholic Historical Society
SN - 2161-8534
UR - http://muse.jhu.edu/journals/american_catholic_studies/v124/124.2.mccarty.html
N1 - Volume 124, Number 2, Summer 2013
ER -


You must be logged in through an institution that subscribes to this journal or book to access the full text.


Shibboleth authentication is only available to registered institutions.

Project MUSE

For subscribing associations only.