Books Received

BOOK REVIEWS 311 lectures, previously published, and are supplemented by several critical reviews, among which is a comprehensive critique of the philosophical thought of Carabellese. The chief theme of Bagolini's analysis is the attempt to promote useful "dialogue" or communication by avoiding the extremes of positivism, historicism, and formalism in the interpretation of politics, political theory, law, and personal responsibility. The criticisms of Kelsen, Croce, Sartre, Popper, Levi-Strauss, Hart, Christensen, and Ferreira Da Silva are especially noteworthy. --H. W. S. Intentionality, Minds and Perception: Discussions on Contemporary Philosophy. Ed. Hector-Neri Castafieda. (Detroit: Wayne State UniversiW Press, 1967. Pp. 402. $7.95) This volume is essentially the proceedings of a noteworthy symposium held at Wayne State University in 1962. The personnel and range of the symposium is best indicated by the table of contents: (I) "On Some Psychological Concepts and the 'Logic' of Intentionality" by Roderick M. Chisholm with comments by Robert C. Sleigh; (II) "The Concept of a Person" by A. J. Ayer with comments by Edmund L. Gettier III; (III) "Consciousness and Behavior: Their Basic Connections" by Hector-Neri Castafieda with comments by Leonard Linsky; (IV) "The Mental Life of Some Machines" by Hilary Putnam with comments by Alvin Plantinga; (V) "Phenomenalism" by Wilfrid Sellars with comments by Bruce Aune; (VI) "Wants, Actions, and Causal Explanation" by William Alston, with comments by Keith Lehrer; (VII) "The Men Themselves; or the Role of Causation in Our Concept of Seeing by Roderick Firth, with comments by Charles E. Caton. Each commentary is followed by a rejoinder by the author of the paper. --H. W. S. Art, Mind, and Religion. Eds. W. H. Capitan and D. D. Merrill. Sixth Oberlin College Colloquium , 1965. (Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press, 1967. Pp. 158. $5) In the sixth Oberlin Colloquium in Philosophy Nowell-Smith criticizes Austin's notion of illocutionary acts, Nakhnildan shows that four formulations of the ontological arguments contain false premises, Putnam discusses the question whether pain is a brain state or a functional state (with comments by Aune and Place), Cavell wonders why fraudulence is such a significant question in modern art (he is answered rather crisply by Margolis and Beardsley), and Ninian Smart argues that all descriptions of mystical experience invoke theological concepts (rejoinders by Nelson Pike and Paul Sclimidt). In short, the book is a mixed bag like the accidental collocation of pieces in a journal issue, but at a higher price and without the fringe benefits of book notes and publishers' advertisements. --A. R. L. BOOKS ~ECEIVED First Editions Adler, Mortimer J. The Di]]erence o] Man and the Dif]erenee It Makes. New York: Holt, Rinehart, and Winston, 1967.Pp. [xvi] + 395. $7.95. Anderson, James F. Reflections on the Analogy o] Being. The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff, 1967. Pp. [v] + 88. Paper, Gld 11.70. Animal Faith and Spiritual Li]e. Ed. John Lachs. Century Philosophy Sourcebooks. New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts, 1967.Pp. ix + 470. Paper, ~.95. This contains previously unpublished and uncollected writings by George Santayana and critical essays on his thought. Bergman, Samuel Hugo. The Philosophy o] Solomon Maimon. Jerusalem: Magues Press, 1967.Pp. xvii + 326, $7.50. Bird, Otto A. The Idea o] Justice. Foreword: Mortimer J. Adler. Institute for Philosophical Research, Concepts in Western Thought Series. New York: Frederick A. Praeger, 1967. Pp. xvi + 192.$5.95. BIaha, Ottokar. Die Ontologie Kants: Ihr Grundri~ in der Transzendentalphilosophie. Salzburger Studien zur Philosophie. Salzburg: Anton Pustet, 1967. Pp. 244. Paper, DM 33. Blank, Sheldon H. Prophetic Faith in Isaiah. Detroit: Wayne State University Press, 1967. x + [i] + 241. Paper, $2.50. Bushell, T. L. The Sage o] Salisbury: Thomas Chubb (1697-1747). New York: Philosophical Library, 1967.Pp. [vii] + 159.$5. Calogero, Guido. Storia della Loglca Antica, Vol. I: L'Et~ Arcaica. Bari, Italy: Editori Laterza, 1967.Pp. xi + 470 + [i]. L 5000. 312 HISTORY OF PHILOSOPHY Casserley, J. V. Langmead. In the Service o] Man: Technology and the Future o] Human Values. Chicago: Henry Regnery Co., 1967. Pp. ix -5 204. $4.95. Cole, Thomas. Democritus and the Sources o] Greek Anthropology. American Philological Association Monograph 25. Cleveland: The Press of Case Western Reserve University, 1967. Pp. xii -F 225. $6...