Early Music

Early Music
Volume 33, Number 4, November 2005


    Rowland-Jones, Anthony.
  • Iconography in the history of the recorder up to c.1430--Part 1
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Recorder (Musical instrument) -- History -- To 1500.
      The first part of this article suggests--on the evidence from archeological finds, iconographic, literary and other documentary sources, and by reference to other instruments--that the development of the eight-holed recorder from the six-holed duct-flute during the 14th century was by evolution and experimentation. The process was haphazard, but seems to have been widespread across western Europe. The demand for a fully chromatic wind instrument that could imitate vocal expression, including playing upper-register notes softly, was stimulated by musical changes brought about by the adoption of Ars Nova notation and the prevalence of three-voice polyphony, including untexted vocalized parts, and by the complexities of late 14thcentury Ars Subtilior. Seven-holed duct-flutes--some tuned as shawms, others as bagpipe chanters, and some with thumb-holes--played a part in this evolution, thereby confusing the identification of recorders unambiguously represented in works of art. The new instruments were used more by singers, especially in cultivated aristocratic circles, than by minstrels not attached to great households; the status of players should therefore be taken into account in iconographic interpretation. These factors discount all but a few of the three-dimensional representations discussed in the article from being securely identified as recorders.
      recorder; duct-flute; music iconography; Ars Nova notation; Ars Subtilior; Catalan altarpieces
    Cummings, Graham.
  • Handel and the confus’d shepherdess: a case study of stylistic eclecticism
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Handel, George Frideric, 1685-1759. Poro. Son confusa pastorella [music]
    • Metastasio, Pietro, 1698-1782. Alessandro nell'Indie.
    • Vinci, Leonardo, d. 1730.
    • Telemann, Georg Philipp, 1681-1767.
      The aria 'Son confusa pastorella' was possibly the most popular number from Handel's operatic success of 1731, Poro, Rè dell'Indie, whose libretto was an altered version of Alessandro nell'Indie by the distinguished Italian poet, Metastasio. Through the text of this aria the poet presents the perhaps confusing image of an Indian princess 'playing at pastoral'. To convey this complex picture to his London audience, Handel composed a beguiling set-piece with strong French connections, through his use of the musette and allusions to the fêtes galantes, combined with borrowings from Telemann. Handel's multi-layered response will be examined and contrasted with that of Metastasio's chosen composer, Leonardo Vinci.
      Handel; opera; pastoral; Telemann; Leonardo Vinci; Metastasio; pastoral
    Rawson, Robert.
  • Gottfried Finger's Christmas pastorellas
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Finger, Godfrey, ca. 1660-1730 -- Criticism and interpretation.
    • Christmas music -- History and criticism.
      The Moravian composer and viola da gamba virtuoso Gottfried Finger (c.1655-1730) is known primarily to musicians for his contributions to musical life in London at the end of the 17th century and a few recorder pieces written for the amateur market. Evidence of his early music and career, however, has so far eluded scholars. While much important work has been done on the genre of the Christmas pastorella in the Czech lands by scholars such as Jiří Berkovec, Geoffrey Chew and Mark Germer, evidence from the 17th century for some common pastor-ella melodies has been scarce. By the first half of the 18th century the basic characteristics of the genre seem to have been in place: the evocation of shepherds' piping or horn calls, the cuckoo, and the quotation of common Christmas tunes, usually lullabies to the Christ-child. Detailed source studies show that Finger was at the court of Bishop Liechtenstein-Castelcorno at Olomouc and Kroměříž in Moravia, falling under the influence of local masters such as Vejvanovský, Biber and Schmelzer. Finger's early contributions to the pastorella genre (for viols and recorders) reveal previously unknown sources of Christmas melodies that would become more commonplace in the following centuries. Some of these melodies were probably intended to evoke the texts of earlier vocal models. The identification of certain melodies in his pastorellas reveals that this tendency was already present in instrumental works of the 1670s and 80s. The discovery and analysis of these pieces sheds new light on an often obscure genre and a little-known composer.
      Gottfried Finger; pastorella; Christmas music; Bishop Liechtenstein-Castelcorno; Olomouc; Kroměříž; Vejvanovský; Biber; Schmelzer; Moravia
    Atlas, Allan W.
  • A 41-cent emendation: a textual problem in Wheatstone’s publication of Giulio Regondi’s Serenade for English concertina and piano
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Regondi, Giulio, 1822-1872. Serenade pour la concertina avec accompagniment de piano forte [music]
    • Concertina music -- History and criticism.
      A wrong (or at least highly suspect) note in the C. Wheatstone & Co. publication of Giulio Regondi's Serenade for English concertina and piano (1859) should probably be emended with the mean-tone temperament of the instrument in mind. Until the late 1850s/early 1860s--and though published in 1859, the Serenade was probably composed in the 1840s--concertina manufacturers used a mean-tone temperament in which they divided the octave into 14 notes, differentiating between--and providing separate buttons for--E♭/D♯, on the one hand, and A♭/ G♯, on the other, with the flat note of each pair being tuned 41 cents higher than the sharp note. The emended reading of the suspect passage suggests that the composer wished to exploit this microtonal resource. This may well be the only instance in which the likely emendation of a wrong or suspect note is dictated entirely by the particular temperament of the instrument for which the piece was written. Finally, attention is called to other instances of such mean-tone-inspired chromaticism in works by George Alexander Macfarren and Joseph Warren.
      English concertina; Giulio Regondi; temperament; chromaticism; George Alexander Macfarren; Joseph Warren
    Ruiz Jiménez, Juan.
  • Infunde amorem cordibus: an early 16th-century polyphonic hymn cycle from Seville
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Iglesia Catedral de Tarazona (Tarazona de Aragón, Spain). Manuscript 2-3.
    • Hymns, Latin (Medieval and modern) -- Spain -- History and criticism.
    • Catholic Church -- Spain -- Hymns -- History and criticism.
      The article studies the characteristics of the polyphonic hymn cycle contained in Tarazona Cathedral, Ms. 2-3 within the context of the transitional period in the liturgy of the Iberian Peninsula in the 15th and 16th centuries. New information on the biographical profile of the composers of these hymns, as well as the analysis of breviaries and other chant sources, some of them previously unknown, from the places with which the Tarazona anthology has been associated, establishes a Sevillian origin for the cycle and by extension for the rest of the repertory in the manuscript. The conclusions reached in the article permit the identification of the chant melodies, from a Sevillian hymnary, that would be most appropriate for alternatim performance of the polyphony in this most important source from the time of the Catholic Monarchs.
      Seville; Tarazona; early Spanish music; hymn cycle; hymnary; Catholic Monarchs; Francisco de Peñalosa; Pedro de Escobar; Alonso Pérez de Alba
    Drake, Joshua F.
  • The partbooks of a Florentine ex-patriate: new light on Florence, Biblioteca Nazionale Centrale Ms. Magl. XIX 164–7
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Biblioteca nazionale centrale di Firenze. Manuscript. Magl. XIX, 164-167.
    • Part songs, Italian -- Italy -- Florence -- 16th century.
      The seminal collection of early 16th-century polyphony, Florence, Biblioteca Nazionale Centrale Ms. Magl.XIX 164­7, has often been cited for its usefulness, both in terms of chronology and content. The enigmatic emblems found in the bassus partbook, however, have not yet been identified. The article explores some of the reasons why the emblems might rightly be associated with the Buonaparte family and, perhaps, with Clement VII's long-standing friend and advisor, Jacopo Buonaparte. To make such an association would begin to explain the geographical dispute surrounding these partbooks, which consist of a Roman binding, Florentine script and Florentine paper.
      Florence; Rome; Clement VII; Jacopo Buonaparte; emblem
    Rice, Stephen.
  • Reconstructing Tallis’s Latin Magnificat and Nunc dimittis
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Tallis, Thomas, 1505 (ca.)-1585. Magnificat, voices (5) [music]
    • Tallis, Thomas, 1505 (ca.)-1585. Nunc dimittis, voices (5) [music]
    • Church music -- Church of England.
    • Church music -- England -- 16th century.
      Tallis's five-part setting of the Magnificat and Nuncdimittis, preserved uniquely in Christ Church, Oxford, Mss. Mus. 979-83, is less well known than most of his sacred music. In part this is probably due to its incomplete survival: the tenor partbook is lost. This article surveys the possible liturgical contexts for the work in the light of the changing confessional circumstances of mid-16th-century England, before examining in depth several questions of editorial policy encountered in reconstructing the tenor part. The tonality of the canticles is firmly G Mixolydian with emphasis on pitch-class C, suggesting a Salisbury chant in mode 8as the most likely material to be interpolated between the polyphonically-set even verses. Within this tonality Tallis's use of sequential writing is unlike that found elsewhere in his output, producing rapid motion between distantly related sonorities on several occasions. The implications of editorial choices at these points are discussed. Whereas imitation is for the most part clearly handled, one verse is exceptional in this respect, and the problems of reconstruction and tonality presented by this verse are examined.
      Tallis; Magnificat; Nunc dimittis; Reformation liturgy


    Bowers, Roger.
  • More on the Lambeth Choirbook
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Skinner, David. Further thoughts on the Lambeth Choirbook and Jena 9.
    • Service books (Music) -- England -- London.

Performing Matters

    Muller, Frans.
    Muller, Julie.
  • Completing the picture: the importance of reconstructing early opera
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Purcell, Henry, 1659-1695. Fairy queen [music]
    • Opera -- Production and direction -- England -- London -- History -- 17th century.
      The article discusses the scenic reconstruction of late 17th-century English opera, and shows that the lack of attention paid to the non-musical aspects of the original performances can often result in serious misunderstandings of the relationship between the various components. The authors have reconstructed the stage of Dorset Garden theatre, where all the Purcell operas except Dido and Aeneas were first performed, including the scenery, the costumes and the movements, using materials from many disciplines including architecture, design, art, theatre, music and general history, biography, literature, and also common sense. Their example is the Act 5 masque in Purcell's The Fairy Queen (1692), adapted by an unknown librettist from Shakespeare's A Midsummer Night's Dream. They show that, far from being a generic song-and-dance scene unrelated to the plot, as is often stated by both theatre and music historians, this masque is a highly specific tribute to William and Mary on the occasion of their 15th wedding anniversary, and was performed a few months before the public celebrations of that event. The numerous illustrations are mainly taken from contemporary paintings and books many of which were owned by the manager of Dorset Garden, the actor Thomas Betterton, who was responsible for putting on the operas and wrote the libretto for at least one of them. The article is also accompanied by a 10-minute animation of the scene, see http://www.em.oupjournals.org.
      The Fairy Queen, Dorset Garden theatre; William and Mary; Thomas Betterton; Shakespeare; A Midsummer Night's Dream; staging; theatre design

Review Article

    Day, Timothy.
  • Tallis in performance
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Tallis, Thomas, 1505 (ca.)-1585 -- Discography.

Book Reviews

    Meconi, Honey.
  • After the party: Hildegard since 1998
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Stühlmeyer, Barbara. Gesänge der Hildegard von Bingen: eine musikologische, theologische und kulturhistorische Untersuchung.
    • Hildegard, Saint, 1098-1179 -- Criticism and interpretation.
    O'Regan, Noel.
  • A guide to Willaert
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Kidger, David. Adrian Willaert: a guide to research.
    • Willaert, Adrian, 1490?-1562 -- Bibliography.
    Carter, Tim, 1954-
  • The power of song?
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Gordon, Bonnie, 1968- Monteverdi's unruly women: the power of song in early modern Italy.
    • Feminism and music.
    Rose, Stephen.
  • The bear growls
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Beer, Johann, 1655-1700. Musikalische Schriften: Ursus murmurat, Ursus vulpinatur, Bellum musicum, Musicalische Discurse.
    • Ingen, Ferdinand van, ed.
    • Roloff, Hans-Gert, ed.
    • Beer, Johann, 1655-1700. Musikalische Schriften: Schola phonologica.
    • Heinemann, Michael, 1959-, ed.
    • Ingen, Ferdinand van, ed. Johann Beer: Schriftsteller, Komponist und Hofbeamter, 1655-1700.
    • Roloff, Hans-Gert, ed.
    • Wels, Ulrike, ed.
    • Music.
    • Beer, Johann, 1655-1700 -- Congresses.
    Thorp, Jennifer.
  • Eloquent bodies: humanist and grotesque dance
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Nevile, Jennifer. Eloquent body: dance and humanist culture in fifteenth-century Italy.
    • Harris-Warrick, Rebecca, ed. Grotesque dancer on the eighteenth-century stage: Gennaro Magri and his world.
    • Brown, Bruce Alan, ed.
    • Dance -- Social aspects -- Italy -- History -- 15th century.
    • Magri, Gennaro, fl. 1779.
    Yelloly, Margaret.
  • Disclosing women's voices
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • LaMay, Thomasin K., ed. Musical voices of early modern women: many-headed melodies.
    • Women musicians -- Europe.

Music Reviews

    Colton, Lisa.
  • The earliest songbook in England
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Stevens, John E., 1921-, ed. Later Cambridge songs.
    • Songs, Latin -- England -- 500-1400.
    Yudkin, Jeremy.
  • Riches of organum
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Roesner, Edward H., ed. Magnus liber organi de Notre-Dame de Paris [music]
    • Everist, Mark, ed. Organa à deux voix pour l'office du manuscrit de Florence, Biblioteca Medicea-Laurenziana, plut. 29.1 [music]
    • Everist, Mark, ed. Organa à deux voix pour la messe (de Noël à la Fête de Saints Pierre et Paul) du manuscrit de Florence, Biblioteca Medicea-Laurenziana, plut. 29.1 [music]
    • Everist, Mark, ed. Organa à deux voix pour la messe (de l'Assumption au commun des saints) du manuscrit de Florence, Biblioteca Medicea-Laurenziana, plut. 29.1 [music]
    • Organa -- Scores.
    • Organa -- 500-1400 -- Scores.
    Rastall, Richard.
  • On editing Byrd
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Byrd, William, 1542 or 3-1623. Songs of sundrie natures (1589) [music]
    • Mateer, David, ed.
    • Part songs, English.
    Hollick, Douglas.
  • The 'famous organist' Vincent Lübeck
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Lübeck, Vincent, 1654?-1740. Neue Ausgabe sämtlicher Orgel- und Clavierwerke [music]
    • Rampe, Siegbert, ed.
    • Organ music.
    Rosow, Lois.
  • Rameau's galante orgy
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Rameau, Jean Philippe, 1683-1764. Anacréon: ballet héroïque en un acte [music]
    • Williams, Jonathan Huw, ed.
    • Operas -- Scores.

Recording Reviews

    Williamson, Magnus, 1967-
  • Renaissance polyphony
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Dufay, Guillaume, d. 1474. Mass for St Anthony Abbot [sound recording]
    • Binchois, Gilles, 1400 (ca.)-1460.
    • Binchois Consort.
    • Kirkman, Andrew, 1961-
    • Browne, John, fl. ca. 1490. Music from the Eton choirbook [sound recording]
    • Tallis Scholars.
    • Phillips, Peter, 1953-
    • Brumel, Antoine, ca. 1460-ca. 1515. Missa 'Et ecce terrae motus' [sound recording]
    • Ensemble Clément Janequin.
    • Saqueboutiers de Toulouse.
    • Visse, Dominique.
    • Peerson, Martin, 1571?-1651. Latin motets [sound recording]
    • Ex Cathedra Consort.
    • Skidmore, Jeffrey, 1951-
    • Masses, Unaccompanied.
    • Mary, Blessed Virgin, Saint -- Songs and music.
    Milsom, John, 1953-
  • A century of English song
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Byrd, William, 1542 or 3-1623. Consort songs [sound recording]
    • Kirkby, Emma.
    • Fretwork (Musical group)
    • Van Evera, Emily. My Lady Rich: her teares and joy [sound recording]
    • Morrongiello, Christopher.
    • Hargis, Ellen. Power of love: 17th-century English songs of passion [sound recording]
    • Viol ensembles.
    • Rich, Penelope, Lady, 1562?-1607.
    Talbot, Michael.
  • Italian vocal music
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Carissimi, Giacomo, 1605-1674. Oratorios [sound recording]
    • Capella Ducale.
    • Musica fiata (Musical group)
    • Wilson, Roland.
    • Carissimi, Giacomo, 1605-1674. Oratorios [sound recording]
    • Consortium Carissimi.
    • Zanon, Vittorio.
    • Cavalli, Pier Francesco, 1602-1676. Arias and duets [sound recording]
    • Mediterraneo Concento (Musical group)
    • Vartolo, Sergio.
    • Scarlatti, Alessandro, 1660-1725. Disperato amore [sound recording]
    • Voix baroques (Musical group)
    • White, Matthew, 1973-
    • Tafelmusik. Italian oratorios [sound recording]
    • White, Matthew, 1973-
    • Lamon, Jeanne.
    • Oratorios.
    • Operas -- Excerpts.
    Holman, Peter, 1946-
  • Varieties of Vivaldi
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Vivaldi, Antonio, 1678-1741. Concerti per vari strumenti [sound recording]
    • Orchestra Barocca Zefiro.
    • Bernardini, Alfredo, 1961-
    • Vivaldi, Antonio, 1678-1741. Music for the chapel of the Pieta [sound recording]
    • Serenissima.
    • Chandler, Adrian, violinist.
    • Lawson, Mhairi.
    • Vivaldi, Antonio, 1678-1741. Violin concertos [sound recording]
    • Giardino armonico (Musical group)
    • Antonini, Giovanni, 1965-
    • Vivaldi, Antonio, 1678-1741. Concertos [sound recording]
    • Arco Baleno (Musical group)
    • Vivaldi, Antonio, 1678-1741. Giorno e notte: concerti per flauto [sound recording]
    • Steinmann, Conrad, 1951-
    • Bianchini, Chiara.
    • Concertos.
    • Sacred vocal music.
    Chung, David, 1968-
  • French harpsichord music
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Anglebert, J. Henry d' (Jean Henry), 1628-1691. Pièces de clavecin [sound recording]
    • Knox, Hank.
    • Rameau, Jean Philippe, 1683-1764. Cyclopes, pièces de clavecin [sound recording]
    • Pinnock, Trevor.
    • Dandrieu, Jean François, 1682-1738. Pièces pour clavecin [sound recording]
    • Bruylants, Betty.
    • Couperin, François, 1668-1733. Paix du parnasse [sound recording]
    • Carolan, Lucy.
    • Kitchen, John.
    • Pollock, David. French harpsichord [sound recording]
    • Meyerson, Mitzi. Plaisir du clavecin [sound recording]
    • Harpsichord music.
    Lehman, Bradley.
  • Death and the Mayerin: Germanic harpsichord music
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Froberger, Johann Jacob, 1616-1667. Toccatas and Partitas [sound recording]
    • Vartolo, Sergio.
    • Froberger, Johann Jacob, 1616-1667. Memento mori Froberger [sound recording]
    • Karttunen, Assi.
    • Buxtehude, Dietrich, 1637-1707. Harpsichord works [sound recording]
    • Wilson, Glen, 1952-
    • Bach, Johann Sebastian, 1685-1750. Bach & Silbermann [sound recording]
    • Bach, Wilhelm Friedemann, 1710-1784.
    • Bach, Carl Philipp Emanuel, 1714-1788.
    • Hambitzer, Gerald.
    • Suites (Harpsichord)
    • Harpsichord music.
    Baker, Geoffrey.
  • 18th-century Peru
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Baroni, Diana. Son de los diablos: tonadas afro-hispanas del Perú [sound recording]
    • Sapukái.
    • Blacks -- Peru -- Music.
    Branscombe, Peter.
  • Recent recordings from the Classical period
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Mozart, Wolfgang Amadeus, 1756-1791. Nozze di Figaro [sound recording]
    • Collegium vocale (Ghent, Belgium)
    • Concerto Köln (Musical group)
    • Jacobs, René.
    • Haydn, Joseph, 1732-1809. Jahreszeiten [sound recording]
    • RIAS-Kammerchor.
    • Freiburger Barockorchester.
    • Jacobs, René.
    • Haydn, Joseph, 1732-1809. Schöpfung [sound recording]
    • VokalEnsemble Köln.
    • Capella Augustina.
    • Spering, Andreas, 1966-
    • Haydn, Joseph, 1732-1809. Symphonies 91 and 92 [sound recording]
    • Freiburger Barockorchester.
    • Jacobs, René.
    • Haydn, Michael, 1737-1806. Requiem pro defuncto Archiepiscopo Sigismundo; Missa in honorem Sanctae Ursulae [sound recording]
    • King's Consort.
    • King's Consort. Choir.
    • King, Robert, 1960-
    • Binder, Christlieb Siegmund, 1723-1789. Concerto per due cembali [sound recording]
    • Cyclopes (Musical group)
    • Giordani, Tommaso, 1733 (ca.)-1806. Harpsichord concertos [sound recording]
    • Accademia dei Solinghi.
    • Comberti, Sebastian. Mozartiana [sound recording]
    • Cole, Maggie.
    • Operas.
    • Oratorios.
    Adlam, Derek.
  • The fortepiano from Silbermann to Pleyel
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Norris, David Owen. World's first piano concertos [sound recording]
    • Sonnerie (Musical group)
    • Bach, Carl Philipp Emanuel, 1714-1788. Solo keyboard music, vol. 11: sonatas from 1746-47 [sound recording]
    • Spányi, Miklós.
    • Blasco de Nebra, Manuel, ca. 1750-1784. Sonatas and pastorelas [sound recording]
    • Cerasi, Carole.
    • Cramer, J. B. (Johann Baptist), 1771-1858. Seven late sonatas [sound recording]
    • Khouri, John, 1944-
    • Chopin, Frédéric, 1810-1849. 27 études [sound recording]
    • Khouri, John, 1944-
    • Chopin, Frédéric, 1810-1849. Mazurkas, valses & autres danses [sound recording]
    • Schoonderwoerd, Arthur, 1966-
    • Quartets (Piano, violins (2), violoncello)
    • Sonatas (Piano)



    Cienniwa, Paul.
  • Boris at Boston
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Boston Early Music Festival & Exhibition (2005)
    • Mattheson, Johann, 1681-1764. Boris Goudenow [performance]
    Tasso, Giovanni.
  • Baroque music in Faenza
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Music festivals -- Italy -- Faenza.
    Domínguez, José María.
  • Italians in Spain
    [Access article in PDF]
    Subject Headings:
    • Music -- Spain -- Italian influences.


Annual Index

Advertisers' Index


[Project MUSE] [Search Page] [Journals] [Journal Directory] [Top]