In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content:

Reviewed by:
  • The Cloister and the World: Early Modern Convent Voices
  • F. Ellen Weaver-Laporte
The Cloister and the World: Early Modern Convent Voices. Edited by Thomas M. Carr, Jr. [EMF: Studies in Early Modern France, Vol. 2.] (Charlottesville, VA: Rookwood Press, Inc. 2007. Pp. x, 267. $49.95 paperback. ISBN 978-1-886-36564-3.)

This remarkable collection of articles on writing by French nuns in early-modern France should be a basic reference book for graduate students preparing a thesis or professors preparing a course on the subject. Thomas Carr points out in the introduction that “while in Hispanic studies, writing by nuns has now been established as an academic discipline, convent writing by French nuns awaits similar recognition” (p. 2). Carr continues with an insightful summary of the contents of the articles, commenting that the texts discussed illustrate some of the contexts in which nuns wrote and published.

What comes to mind as the first level of recovery of writing by nuns is the collection, copying, and even publication of the letters of the nun, usually the abbess, who founded the congregation or reformed it. But we learn through the articles in this collection, contributed by acknowledged experts in convent studies, that the epistolary was not the only convent contribution to the literature of early-modern France. Many of the standard genres of convent writing appear here—chronicles, poetry, hymns, death notices, and constitutions—but less well-known forms, such as legal briefs or marriage manuals are also introduced.

Texts of an institutional nature often reveal the interplay between the convent and the outside world. For example, the article by Elisabeth M. Wengler, “‘That in future times they will know our suffering for the love of God’: Jeanne de Jusise’s Petite Chronique and the creation of convent identity”(pp. 27–43), recounts details about the nuns’ experience of the Reformation between 1526 and 1535, and reveals much about the culture, identity, and ideals of early-modern nuns. The Petite Chronique explains how the sisters of Saint Clare, whose convent was located in Geneva, withstood the real and threatened violence of the Protestant reformers and managed to continue their religious practices and ultimately to preserve their community. The chronicle served to redefine the community when it was resettled in Annecy by portraying the nuns as active opponents of the Reformation rather than as its victims. This is a striking example of how nuns’ writing can serve a political as well as a literary purpose. In the next century the same thing can be said of the writings of the nuns of Port-Royal.

That nuns were educated, capable of writing poetry, commentaries on liturgical texts, even translations from Latin into French, is the theme of Gary Ferguson’s article, “Rules for Writing: the ‘Dames de Poissy’” (pp. 44–58). Ferguson describes the contacts of the Dominican nuns with the outside world when the priory hosted the Colloquy of Poissy and notes that while this openness to the world might deviate from the spirit of their monastic rule, it was favorable to the pursuit of literary projects. [End Page 364]

Other articles cover a wide range of unusual subjects. What could be further from the ordinary, often prejudiced, view of nuns’ activities than their involvement in legal conflicts? Leslie Tuttle’s “Factum or Fiction? Convent Scandal, Cloister, and Publicity in the Era of Louis XIVe” (pp. 130–54), is an informative response to this question.

Another departure from the usual is the curious story of Louyse Capeau, the Ursuline nun, who, while possessed by a demon, delivered sermons on Catholic doctrine. Katherine Dauge-Roth, in “Nuns, Demons, and Exorcists: Ventriloquism and the Voice of Authority in Provence (1609–1611)” (pp. 75–132), applies a bold hypothesis, “ventriloquized bodies,” to explain this and other similar cases.

In her article “‘Un trésor enfoui, une lampe sous un boisseau’: Seventeenth-Century Visitandines Describe Their Vocation” (pp. 155–66), Elizabeth Rapley turns to an unusual source. Death notices of seventeenth-century Visitandines are analyzed. Rapley describes the manner in which circulation of such death notices eulogizing deceased members of the community was a means of fostering uniformity and unity in...

pdf

Share