In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content:

The Catholic Historical Review 92.4 (2006) 686-687

Reviewed by
John Jay Hughes
Archdiocese of St. Louis
Vom Seelenhirten zum Wegführer. Sondierungen zum bischöflichen Selbstverständnis im 19. und 20. Jahrhundert. Die Antrittshirtenbriefe der Germanikerbischöfe (1837-1962). By Martin Leitgöb. [Römische Quartalscrhift für christliche Altertumskunde und Kirchengeschichte, 56. Supplementband.] (Freiburg: Herder. 2004. Pp. 319. €78.00.)

Asked some years ago what was his heaviest burden, a Mexican archbishop answered sadly: "The poor." Many bishops in today's Third World would say the same. It was not always thus. Asked the same question, the earlier bishops in this study might have spoken about the challenge of saving souls and preserving the faith in a world hostile to faith. A century later their successors might have mentioned the difficulty of persuading the faithful that they were not merely passive recipients of the Church's pastoral care and faith, but responsible themselves for passing on that faith to others and extending God's kingdom in the world around them.

In this book the Austrian Redemptorist Martin Leitgöb analyzes the inaugural pastoral letters written by forty-three bishops trained in the German College at Rome. They presided over dioceses not only in Germany and Austria, but also in Luxembourg, Switzerland, Brixen (in South Tyrol), Trent, and Prague. The bishops themselves range from such well-known figures as Senestréy of Regensburg (an ally of the English Cardinal Manning at Vatican Council I) to Cardinals Döpfner, Höffner, and König a century later. Excluded, because they did not receive their formation in Rome, are others of equal importance: Ketteler and Hefele in the nineteenth century, and Faulhaber, von Galen, and Frings in the twentieth. [End Page 686]

All of these bishops issued pastoral letters upon assuming office. Many of them also wrote separate letters to their clergy. In the earlier period these were often in Latin—testimony to the educational level of clergy in that day. Leitgöb places these episcopal statements under his scholarly microscope, scrutinizing, dissecting, parsing, and analyzing them with a thoroughness and attention to detail that might astonish their authors. The resulting study, a notable example of German Gründlichkeit, makes severe demands on the reader.

As one would expect of men who received their entire priestly formation in Rome, all the bishops emphasize the pope's central role in the Church. In 1847 Reisach told his flock in Munich that the pope was "the center, from whom all episcopal power derives." Over a century later the Austrian bishop Zauner of Linz called the pope "the chief pastor in every diocese." None of these bishops indulged, however, in the exaggerated personality cult that flourished during the pontificate of Pius IX (the pope as "incarnation of the Holy Spirit" and similar absurdities).

The earlier bishops saw themselves primarily as high priests, charged with responsibility for the eternal salvation of their flock. They emphasized the duty of obedience in a fortress church battling the hostile winds still blowing from the French Revolution. The post-World War II bishops begin to emphasize themes taken up by Vatican II, telling the laity that they too are Church, charged, like their pastors, with responsibility for others. "Believers have a responsibility for seekers," Joseph Höffner told his people in Münster in 1962. "We Christians must never become emigrants in this world." Absent from all episcopal statements, however, is any reference to the bishop's responsibility for the whole Church, or to the universal Church as a communion of local churches.

The overall impression is of men more aware of the burdens of their office than of its honor, well educated and clear sighted, and willing to spend themselves freely in the service of their flocks. Worthy of special mention are some words of a man destined to become one of the great men of the Church in his day. Speaking in 1956...

pdf

Share