In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content:

Reviewed by:
  • A Year without Autumn
  • Kate Quealy-Gainer
Kessler, Liz . A Year without Autumn. Candlewick, 2011. [304p]. Trade ed. ISBN 978-0-7636-5595-2 $15.99 E-book ed. 978-0-7636-5608-9 $15.99 Reviewed from galleys Ad Gr. 4-6.

The daughter of a therapist and a teacher, Jenni is shy, conservative, and never-ever brave, while Autumn is the outgoing, friendly, and über-cool offspring of two artists. Despite their differences, the two have been besties since birth, and their families are about to spend an entire week together at their vacation homes right before the girls start seventh grade. Several days into their trip, however, when Jenni goes to Autumn's condo for a visit, she finds an old lady claiming not to know an Autumn, and later when she does find her friend, Autumn is a completely different person—sad, lost, and utterly un-Autumn-like. Somehow, Jenni has gotten herself transported a year in the future, where she discovers that Autumn's little brother lingers in a coma after a horrific accident and both families are falling apart. Once she discovers that the condo's elevator jumps the space-time continuum, Jenni plans to use this to save Autumn's brother and get both her friend and her family back. The time-travel ploy is an interesting device to explore the curious paths of "what-if," but because it seems fairly inevitable that Jenni will indeed find a way to prevent the accident, the ongoing events lack necessary urgency. Most of the scenes are driven primarily by dialogue, placing the focus squarely on the relationship between the two girls, but their interactions become increasingly unbelievable, as the girls begin to sound like each other's therapists instead of middle-school friends. Frances O'Roark Dowell offers a more nuanced portrayal of girl friendships at a precipice, but this offering of vicarious tragedy may still find an audience among the readers whose imagination take them to the more dramatic what-if scenarios. [End Page 210]

...

pdf

Share