In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content:

15 JEWISH SELF-IMAG E I N TH E POSTWAR WORL D AMBIVALENCE O F LIBERALIS M IN THEI R STRUGGL E fo r th e fullnes s o f emancipation , th e Jew s relied mos t heavil y o n th e hel p o f liberal s an d the y redefine d thei r identity i n term s o f individua l freedom . Th e ideal s an d th e tempe r o f liberalism wer e range d solidl y o n th e sid e o f Jewish people , a s the y struggled t o overcom e th e effect s o f religiou s prejudice s an d ethni c zealotry. Th e conservativ e mood , apar t fro m part y platforms , resente d any kin d o f change , an d esteeme d highl y th e wort h o f prejudice, a s a helpful brak e against the changin g an d disintegratin g forces tha t operat e in modern society . In th e cas e o f Zionism , however , liberalis m wa s ambivalent . Th e sympathies o f liberals were with th e Jews, but thei r ideal s called for th e solution o f Jewish homelessnes s throug h th e securin g o f th e right s o f individuals, whereve r the y happene d t o live . Alread y i n th e day s o f Herzl, the antisemites o f Russia, German y an d Franc e found i t easier t o sympathize wit h th e caus e o f a Jewish homelan d tha n th e liberals , th e old-time friends o f Jewis h people . England wa s a special case, since its imperial interests coincide d fro m time to time with its idealistic concern fo r th e fate o f Eastern Europea n Jewry. Th e "Jewis h homeland " wa s needed , i t woul d b e said , no t fo r the solution o f "the Jewish question" in England, but to provide for th e stream of refugees fro m th e East. Also, in England, th e biblical traditio n 3 H 315 Jewish Self-Image in the Postwar World was stron g an d th e Zionis t idea l awakene d echoe s o f ancien t romanti c visions. As J. L. Talmon put it : "For on e thing , n o Jewish historian , whateve r hi s evaluatio n o f th e various factor s involve d i n th e restoratio n o f Jewis h statehood , ca n ignore th e fact tha t Zionism woul d neve r have had a chance for succes s if centurie s o f Christia n teachin g an d worship , liturg y an d legen d ha d not conditione d th e Wester n nation s t o respon d almos t instinctivel y t o the word s 'Zion ' an d 'Israel, ' an d thu s t o se e i n th e Zionis t idea l no t a romantic chimer a o r a n imperialisti c desig n t o wres t a country fro m it s actual inhabitants , bu t th e consummatio n o f a n eterna l promis e an d hope." * Anglo-American liberal s wer e particularl y sensitiv e t o th e charg e o f injuring th e Palestinian Arabs, in the effort t o render justice to the caus e of world Jewry. After th e establishmen t o f the stat e o f Israel , th e caus e of th e Ara b refugee s clashe d i n th e America n conscienc e wit h tha t o f the Jews in Israel . A good illustratio n o f this conflict i s seen in th e hesitan t an d equivo cal posture of the Christian Century Magazine toward Zionism an d Israel. While thi s centra l orga n o f th e non-Fundamentalis t Protestant s wa s naturally sympathetic t o the plight o f Jewis h refugees , i t fought a persistent rear-guard actio n agains t the establishmen t o f the Jewish state . In hi s study , "America n Protestantis m an d a Jewish State, " Herz l...


Additional Information

Print ISBN
MARC Record
Launched on MUSE
Open Access
Back To Top

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Without cookies your experience may not be seamless.