Pennsylvania Hall, Philadelphia, May 16 and 17, 1838
In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content:

Twelfth Street Meeting, Philadelphia, 1818 “As all our efforts to resist temptation, and overcome the world prove fruitless unless aided by Thy Holy Spirit, enable us to approach Thy Throne, and ask of Thee the blessing of Thy preservation from all evil, that we may be wholly devoted to Thee and Thy glorious cause.” Lucretia Mott. 1879. 5/101 ADS Mott Manuscripts, FHL 1. Although the date on the document indicates “5/10,” a note accompanying it states that the holograph copy was presented to LM on May 12, 1879, “with the information that they were the first words she had expressed in public” (Mott Manuscripts, FHL; Hallowell, 62; Faulkner, 41). Pennsylvania Hall, Philadelphia, May 16 and 17, 1838 [May 16, Evening Session] A FEW remarks were then made by LUCRETIA MOTT, of Philadelphia, stating that the present was not a meeting of the Anti-Slavery Convention of American Women, as was supposed by some, and explaining the reason why their meetings were confined to females—to wit, that many of the members of that Convention considered it improper for women to address promiscuous assemblies .1 She expressed the “hope that such false notions of delicacy and propriety would not long obtain in this enlightened country.” * * * * 4 New England Non-Resistance Society, 1839 [May 17, Morning Session] Lucretia Mott made some impressive remarks respecting the riot of the preceding evening, and exhorted the members of the Convention to be steadfast and solemn in the prosecution of the business for which they were assembled.2 PD History of Pennsylvania Hall, that was Destroyed by a Mob, on the 17th of May, 1838 (Philadelphia: Merrihew and Gunn, 1838), 127, 130 1. The opening celebrations for the hall, which had been built by abolitionists, began on May 14 and featured a variety of antislavery speakers and organizations. For background on the construction of and controversy surrounding Pennsylvania Hall, see Faulkner, 75–78. LM addressed the concern of some female abolitionists about the presence of both men and women in the audience (History of Pennsylvania Hall, 6, 117, 127). 2. The second Anti-Slavery Convention of American Women, a national gathering that first met in New York City the previous year, had opened on May 15, with LM serving as vice-president. Protests outside Pennsylvania Hall continued, and after convention delegates left on May 17, a mob set it on fire. For LM’s reaction, see Palmer, 42–43, 46–47; Faulkner, 78–79; also, Pennsylvania Freeman, May 24, 1838; Liberator, May 25, 1838. New England Non-Resistance Society, Chardon Street Chapel, Boston, September 25–27, 1839 [September 25 Session] Lucretia Mott of Philadelphia, thought the resolution1 referred not to opinions , but to the right of opinion. The right we cannot deny, and ought to respect, though the opinion may be such as we disapprove. * * * * Lucretia Mott hoped this resolution would be well and thoroughly considered before its passage, as it seemed to her to strike at the root of the religious opinions entertained by some of us. Once let it be laid down that an opinion is necessary to salvation, and toleration becomes inconsistent. But I dislike the word toleration. It does not convey the right idea. Is it not yielded in the most orthodox sects, that the members may adopt various opinions as to the mode of being, in a future state of existence? So it might be with regard to other differences of opinion; and it is a most important thing that it should be so in our present association. This resolution, if heartily adopted, will bring good out of all our discussions. It will, like the philosopher’s stone, transmute base metal into gold. * * * * Lucretia Mott said, I think my brother2 again confuses opinion with the right of opinion. The ninety-nine hundredths can adopt such resolutions as they choose, in this spirit of love and freedom. But it forbids them to require of the one in the minority to adopt them, under penalty of disgrace. * * * * Lucretia Mott. This resolution3 opens a broad field for discussion; and while it would be well that nothing should be done to foreclose it, I would offer a caution ...


pdf