Liberty, Equality, Fraternity

Comparative Table of Subjects in James Fitzjames Stephen's Liberty, Equality, Fraternity and John Stuart Mill's On Liberty

COMPARATIVE TABLE OF SUBJECTS IN JAMES FITZJAMES STEPHEN'S LIBERTY, EQUALITY, FRATERNITY AND JOHN STUART MILL'S ON LIBERTY We offer this table of subjects comparing Stephen's Liberty, Equality, Fraternity with Mill's On Liberty so readers can more easily examine the alternative understandings of liberty and other related moral and political matters found in these two works. Such an examination may also provide a vehicle for reassessing Stephen's place in the history of nineteenth century political thought and the history of liberty. On some subjects, for example, utilitarianism and marriage, the reader will find more extensive discussions in Mill's Utilitarianism and The Sub;ection ofWomen; however, we have limited our comparison to On Liberty. Nor does this table include other subject-themes that are important to Liberty, Equality, Fraternity, such as "the Religion of Humanity," when they are not central to On Liberty. We have tended to choose Mill's idiom rather than Stephen's for the names of the subjects. Insofar as an examination of liberty is ubiquitous throughout the two works, especially On Liberty, we did not think it necessary to have a separate entry for "liberty." The page references to On Liberty cite two different editions: On Liberty with The Sub;ection of Women and Chapters on Socialism, ed. Stefan Collini, Cambridge Texts in the History of Political Thought (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1989); and Collected Works ofJohn Stuart Mill, ed. J. M. Robson, 33 vols. (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1963-1991), vol. 18, Essays on Politics and Society. Liberty_251-274.indd 18 8/28/08 1:39:21 PM COMPARATIVE TABLE OF SUBJECTS Liberty, Equality, Fraternity On Liberty On Liberty Subiect Liberty Fund Edition Cambridge Edition Toronto Edition Calvinism 29-32 62 265 Character 11,95-96 15,23,28-29, 226,232,236, 41-43,52,53-63 247,248,256, 258-66 Coercion 6,8,10,11-17,18-20,21, 13,15,56-57, 223,225,260, 31,36-51,76-78,82, 75-78,80,83,98, 276-78,280, 86-87,111-12,128,230 102-5, 108 283,295, 299-301,304 Democracy 120-21, 155-62 7-8,48-49,66 219,253-54, 269 Diversity (variety) 32-34,45,91,95 3,45,47,49,52, 215,250,252, 57-58,68,72,74, 254,257,260, 106,110 261,270,274, 275,302,306 Education 37-38,49,103-4,137, 46,51,57,72-73, 251,255,261, 151, 152-53 76, 102, 105-8 273,274,277, 299,301,302, 304 Equality 4, 120, 124-63 48,89 254,287 Family 82-83,92,108,138 61,81,105,108 264,281,301, 304-5 Fraternity 3-4, 120, 132, 164-203 Freedom of the will 5,233-34 5 217 Human nature 10,31,114,240 17,60-63,69, 227,263-66, 69n, 77 271n,272,278 Individuality 7,24,29-31,33-34 8,49,57-61, 220,254, 63-67,69,71, 261-64, 73-77,81,106, 266-69,271, 110 273,275-78, 281,302,306 268 Liberty_251-274.indd 19 8/28/08 1:39:21 PM COMPARATIVE TABLE OF SUBJECTS Liberty, Equality, Fraternity On Liberty On Liberty Sub;ect Liberty Fund Edition Cambridge Edition Toronto Edition Justice 87, 122, 125-33, 136, 14,28,63,70,83 224,236,266, 141-42,153,174-75 272,282 Law 40,46,49,97-108, 9-12,13-14,16, 220-23, 224, 109-10,248,250 19,26,31,34,46, 226,228,234, 54,61,75,81-82, 239,241,252, 87-88,90,97, 258,264,276, 105,106,114 281-82,286-87, 289,295,301, 303,309 Liberalism 67 7 218-19 Liberty of thought 7,19-20,21-22,24-29, 15,17,19-55 225,227, 37-51,54-57,57-69,82, 228-59 91 Marriage 139-143,145,148-50, 91-92, 103, 108 290,300,304 153-54 Morality 8-10,11,13-15,52-53, 9-11,14-17,26, 220-22, 56-60,63,75,83-110, 41,49-51,56,59, 224-27,234, 127-28, 145, 166-71, 69,78,81-82, 247,254-56, 174-82,186-87,191-203, 83-84,87,95, 260, 262, 271, 215-27 98-102, 104, 108, 279,281-82, 114...