Peril in the Ponds
Deformed Frogs, Politics, and a Biologist's Quest
Publication Year: 2012
Published by: University of Massachusetts Press
Title Page, Copyright
Download PDF (59.7 KB)
Download PDF (57.6 KB)
So many people have helped along the way I can’t possibly name them all. First, I thank my comrades in wetlands and frogs, especially Mark Gernes, but also many people who worked with us at the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency: wetland field assistants Joel Chirhart, Cade Steffenson, and Kyle Thompson; ...
Download PDF (68.3 KB)
I knelt on the ground in my oversize rubber waders and peered into the metal pan. Its water danced with small creatures we’d just netted from the pristine-looking river below. A variety of immature insects swam about: armored dragonflies and pebble-cased caddis flies, dark-bodied beetles and bugs. ...
1. The Call
Download PDF (105.9 KB)
Her voice quavered over the phone as she described a hellish scene: frogs with stumps of legs; frogs missing a leg; frogs with twisted joints; some with extra legs that couldn’t move. A frog with one eye. “Half of these frogs have something wrong. They look really pathetic.” She paused. “We need help.” ...
2. The Frog Champion
Download PDF (86.2 KB)
In October of 1995, not long after the discovery of deformed frogs, eighty-four-year-old state representative Willard Munger organized a hearing about deformed frogs and wetlands issues. He invited the school students, their teacher, and me to speak to a mixed assemblage of legislators and citizens. ...
3. Learning Curves
Download PDF (116.8 KB)
One thing I knew: to find clues to what caused the deformities, we had to focus on the frogs themselves and the places where they spent their time throughout the year. The most likely scene of the crime lay within the ponds, where developing eggs would be exposed to pollutants or other agents in the water. ...
4. Wading in and Listening
Download PDF (75.6 KB)
Before coming to the MPCA, I observed first-hand the vulnerability of wetland organisms to damaging pollutants when I participated with EPA scientists in a research project. Their goal was to field-test the impact of organophosphorus insecticides on the biota of natural wetlands. ...
5. The Peril Widens
Download PDF (94.3 KB)
With renewed hope, Mark and I made plans for surveying frogs and sampling ponds. In 1995 we had logged hundreds of misshapen frogs in a few different locations in the state. But what if Granite Falls repeated itself and no deformed frogs appeared in 1996? ...
6. Science in the Public Eye
Download PDF (89.4 KB)
The Monday following the EPA’s meeting in late September 1996, we conducted a third survey of the frogs at the Ney Pond. This time a troubling 32 out of 70, or 47 percent of the frogs were deformed, much worse than earlier in September, when we logged 8 percent abnormal, or in July when only one frog out of 124 we collected had a small defect. ...
7. Government to the Rescue?
Download PDF (124.9 KB)
After taking a week off for our wedding in early November of 1996, I returned to work with unrealistic hopes that the swirl of media requests and other communications might have simmered down. Instead, I was greeted by a flood of nine hundred e-mails and phone messages. ...
8. The Quest
Download PDF (82.7 KB)
“Hey Judy, any chance your field crew could collect some fertilized frog eggs for us from one of your study sites?” asked EPA researcher Joe Tietge during a break at the amphibian meeting in Madison in the spring of 1997. He wanted to expose eggs to some chemicals and to ultraviolet light to see if deformities would develop, he explained. ...
9. Imperiled Frogs
Download PDF (110.5 KB)
Death and deformity again stalked Dave Hoppe’s intensive study site in north central Minnesota in the summer of 1997. Frogs were floating, listless, and dying. Dozens of small fish and a couple of painted turtles had died. Young frogs couldn’t swim or hop. Three-quarters of the mink frogs had severe and in some cases multiple deformities. ...
10. Bureaucratic Strangulation
Download PDF (95.6 KB)
After the reaction to September’s press conference and the media coverage cooled down, I hoped work would go more smoothly. But I’d had this thought before. Dorothy took a couple of months off to finish her master’s thesis, and, as we expected, she quit her job as fieldwork coordinator when she returned. ...
11. The Wrecking Ball
Download PDF (86.7 KB)
The MPCA’s new reorganization plan, optimistically called “Goal 21” for the new century, swung into action with a massive and work-stopping internal move in 1999. During this time, the agency received a bomb threat, preceded earlier that summer by an anonymous message from someone who had threatened to “start shooting employees one by one,” ...
Epilogue: How Are the Frogs? An Update
Download PDF (129.6 KB)
More than a decade has passed since the MPCA halted its research on the frogs in 2001 and after my retirement in 2002 to compose the next chapter of my life teaching, writing, and spending time with family. Since then, major environmental disasters, such as the catastrophic BP oil spill in the Gulf ...
Download PDF (101.4 KB)
Download PDF (272.6 KB)
Page Count: 272
Publication Year: 2012