We cannot verify your location
Browse Book and Journal Content on Project MUSE

Northern Hospitality

Cooking by the Book in New England

Keith Stavely and Kathleen Fitzgerald

Publication Year: 2011

If you think traditional New England cooking is little more than baked beans and clam chowder, think again. In this enticing anthology of almost 400 historic New England recipes from the seventeenth to the early twentieth century, you will be treated to such dishes as wine-soaked bass served with oysters and cranberries, roast shoulder of lamb seasoned with sweet herbs, almond cheesecake infused with rosewater, robust Connecticut brown bread, zesty ginger nuts, and high-peaked White Mountain cake. Beginning with four chapters placing the region's best-known cookbook authors and their works in nuanced historical context, Keith Stavely and Kathleen Fitzgerald then proceed to offer a ten-chapter cornucopia of culinary temptation. Readers can sample regional offerings grouped into the categories of the liquid one-pot meal, fish, fowl, meat and game, pie, pudding, bread, and cake. Recipes are presented in their original textual forms and are accompanied by commentaries designed to make them more accessible to the modern reader. Each chapter, and each section within each chapter, is also prefaced by a brief introductory essay. From pottage to pie crust, from caudle to calf's head, historic methods and obscure meanings are thoroughly-sometimes humorously-explained. Going beyond reprints of single cookbooks and bland adaptations of historic recipes, this richly con-textualized critical anthology puts the New England cooking tradition on display in all its unexpected-and delicious-complexity. Northern Hospitality will equip readers with all the tools they need for both historical understanding and kitchen adventure.

Published by: University of Massachusetts Press


pdf iconDownload PDF (624.8 KB)
pp. i-ii

Title Page

pdf iconDownload PDF (27.4 KB)
pp. iii

Copyright Page

pdf iconDownload PDF (35.0 KB)
pp. iv

Table of Contents

pdf iconDownload PDF (63.8 KB)
pp. vii-viii

List of Illustrations

pdf iconDownload PDF (48.0 KB)
pp. ix

read more


pdf iconDownload PDF (52.1 KB)
pp. xi-xii

Where does a reader or cook turn to get a good taste of traditional New England cuisine? Up till now, those exploring the region’s culinary past have found mostly adaptations of historic recipes. Usually highlighted within this narrow repertoire are dishes that were developed during the colonial revival of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries.

read more


pdf iconDownload PDF (58.6 KB)
pp. xiii-xiv

In our study of New England food history we have relied on the work of many scholars, curators, and librarians. First among those to whom we are indebted is the staff of the Schlesinger Library, Radcliffe Institute, Harvard University, which has again guided us unerringly through the Library’s invaluable trove of collections and services. We have also drawn on the resources of...

read more


pdf iconDownload PDF (61.4 KB)
pp. 1-4

Cookbooks are big business. Titles in the America’s Test Kitchen series regularly show up on the best-seller lists, and The Joy of Cooking, a fixture in American middle-class households for two generations, could still become a best seller in its 2006, seventy-fifth-anniversary incarnation. Anyone who has ever worked in a public library,...

Part 1 - Cooks and Cookbooks

read more

Chapter One: Culinarily Colonized: Cookbooks in Colonial New England

pdf iconDownload PDF (308.2 KB)
pp. 7-33

During the colonial era, New England cooks in a position to make use of printed recipe sources had to rely on English cookbooks, since, as noted in the Introduction, the first American cookbook was not published until 1796. In the seventeenth century, the most popular of these was Gervase Markham’s The English Hus-wife, first published in 1615 and frequently reprinted until late in the century.

read more

Chapter Two: The Young Republic: Amelia Simmons, Lydia Maria Child, Mrs. Lee

pdf iconDownload PDF (291.2 KB)
pp. 34-64

Among the slimmest volumes on the bookshelf of early British and American cookbooks is American Cookery, published in Hartford in 1796, as noted the first cookbook written by an American author and the first with a distinct focus on American cooking. 1 American Cookery was an immediate commercial success, with a second edition appearing in Albany later the same year.

read more

Chapter Three: Cuisine and Culture at Midcentury: Sarah Josepha Hale and Catharine Beecher

pdf iconDownload PDF (365.0 KB)
pp. 65-92

Our next writer was what her century might have called a “true New Englander.” What they would have meant was that Sarah Josepha Hale was white, Protestant, middle class, and from a rural (in her case New Hampshire) farming family. It would only add to her pedigree that the patriarch of her family had fought in the American War for Independence.

read more

Chapter Four: The Civil War and After: Community Cookbooks, Colonial Revival, Domestic Science

pdf iconDownload PDF (308.9 KB)
pp. 93-110

By now we can see that industrialization and consolidation of resources, on the one hand, and nostalgia for a past that was imagined as disciplined, pastoral, and more humanly cohesive, on the other, were the warp and weft of the fabric of New England life in the nineteenth century and as such formed the social circumstances out of which the idea of a particular and noteworthy New England style of cooking emerged.

Part 2 - Recipes and Commentaries

read more

Chapter Five: Pottages, Chowders, Soups, and Stews

pdf iconDownload PDF (183.2 KB)
pp. 113-140

It could be said that New England history began when English met Indian, so we think it is fitting to begin this collection of recipes with a dish that, in its New England form, is a mixture of Indian and English influences. Most commonly known as pottage, it is the progenitor of the baked beans and chowders for which New England is still famous. At the outset, pottage was no more than a pot of boiled meat, fowl, or fish, grain, seasoning, and whatever vegetables were on hand.

read more

Chapter Six: Fish and Shellfish

pdf iconDownload PDF (208.2 KB)
pp. 141-174

In China, fish have always been highly esteemed, not only nutritionally and gastronomically but also culturally, thought to symbolize such desirable conditions as wealth, freedom, and marital harmony and such virtues as perseverance and courage. Mostly because of guilt by association—in Europe with Lenten deprivation, in North America with the scarcities of the earliest years of English settlement, as well as with Indian “savagery”—Anglo-American attitudes toward fish have been more wary, as indicated by the fact that the English word “fishy” means worthy of suspicion.

read more

Chapter Seven: Fowl, Wild and Tame

pdf iconDownload PDF (259.0 KB)
pp. 175-205

Fowl is fair in our time. While Americans still eat more beef than chicken, for reasons of both health and convenience the little bird is pecking out a larger market share each year—chicken consumption increased by 70 percent in the last quarter of the twentieth century, at the same time that annual beef consumption fell by twenty five pounds per capita. Yet the Anglo-American taste for fowl is much older than the current craze.

read more

Chapter Eight: Game and Meat

pdf iconDownload PDF (220.3 KB)
pp. 206-243

Touring England in the 1690s, Henri Misson was only one of many continental travelers who had “always heard that [the English] were great flesh-eaters” and who found that this was indeed true. While the people he observed would only “nibble a few crumbs” of bread, meat they would “chew . . . by whole mouthfuls. . . . Among the middling sort of people they have ten or twelve sorts of common meats which infallibly take their turns at their tables.”

read more

Chapter Nine: Pie Crusts

pdf iconDownload PDF (134.3 KB)
pp. 244-254

Pie crust’s continental antecedents can be found in medieval courtly kitchens, but our story begins more recently and among lower, if aspiring, social groups—the English gentry and middle class—where forms of aristocratic display such as elaborate paste sculptures decorating the tops and sides of pies were simplified and reserved for special occasions. Nevertheless, English pies could be large, requiring many pounds of flour and butter or lard.

read more

Chapter Ten: Pies—Mixed, Meat, Mince

pdf iconDownload PDF (181.4 KB)
pp. 255-281

Savory foods baked in crusts, such as steak and kidney pie, pork pie, and Cornish pasties, have a long and continuous history as British favorites but are virtually unknown to the average American. We may occasionally pop a frozen, manufactured beef or chicken pot pie into the oven for dinner, but those soupy repasts crowned with industrial-strength pie dough hold little resemblance to the rich, substantial, handmade pies of old England.

read more

Chapter Eleven: Pies—Fowl, Fish

pdf iconDownload PDF (142.6 KB)
pp. 282-298

From the seventeenth to the nineteenth centuries in both England and New England, pies were built around domestic fowl and game birds, most notably chickens, geese, ducks, and pigeons but also turkeys, partridges, peacocks (although these were abandoned in the seventeenth century as too tough), and quail. More exotic fare such as swans and bustards were particularly fashionable in the 1690s but fell out of favor thereafter. Diners were as apt to encounter fowls baked into pies as they were to meet them roasted or fricasseed.

read more

Chapter Twelve: Pies—Vegetable, Fruit, Custard

pdf iconDownload PDF (178.7 KB)
pp. 299-324

We begin a sequence of three chapters filled primarily with sweet dishes by recalling that, as noted in Chapter 1, in early modern England such dishes constituted a separate department of food preparation, “confectionery,” which was more prestigious than “cookery,” the making of all other types of food. The ladies of the aristocracy and gentlewomen of the gentry participated directly in confectionery activities, while leaving cookery for the most part to their servants.

read more

Chapter Thirteen: Puddings

pdf iconDownload PDF (165.8 KB)
pp. 325-347

Many of us, we suspect, grew up as we did with the idea that when cake, pie, or ice cream was not to be had for dessert, pudding was the ho-hum fallback offering for that part of the menu. All those little dishes filled with chocolate-, vanilla-, or tapioca-flavored glop that were always lying in wait at the end of the school lunch line. The only thing worse—even more boring in taste and creepy in consistency—was Jell-O.

read more

Chapter Fourteen: Breads and Cakes

pdf iconDownload PDF (232.9 KB)
pp. 348-388

Caroline Howard King, reminiscing about the foods of her Salem, Massachusetts, childhood in the 1820s and ’30s, recounts that “pancakes also were great favorites, made of batter, sometimes raised with new-fallen snow, and eaten with sugar and wine or lemon. Then for tea, we had flapjacks, which were large griddle cakes often made with rice, which were cut in four quarters and eaten with powdered sugar and cinnamon. And pandowdy, a dark brown mixture of baked bread and apples, rich with spices, and sweetened with molasses.

Notes to Part 1

pdf iconDownload PDF (269.0 KB)
pp. 389-408

Sources for Part 2

pdf iconDownload PDF (242.9 KB)
pp. 409-431


pdf iconDownload PDF (155.1 KB)
pp. 433-449

Art Credits for Part 2

pdf iconDownload PDF (60.0 KB)
pp. 451-452


pdf iconDownload PDF (989.2 KB)
pp. 453-469

Back Cover

pdf iconDownload PDF (693.7 KB)

E-ISBN-13: 9781613760475
E-ISBN-10: 1613760477
Print-ISBN-13: 9781558498600
Print-ISBN-10: 1558498605

Page Count: 488
Publication Year: 2011