Publication Year: 2013
Seymour Hersh has been the most important, famous, and controversial journalist in the United States for the last forty years. From his exposé of the My Lai massacre in 1969 to his revelations about torture at Abu Ghraib prison in 2004, Hersh has consistently captured the public imagination, spurred policymakers to reform, and drawn the ire of presidents.
From the streets of Chicago to the newsrooms of the most powerful newspapers and magazines in the United States, Seymour Hersh tells the story of this Pulitzer Prize–winning journalist and author. Robert Miraldi scrutinizes the scandals and national figures that have drawn Hersh’s attention, from My Lai to Watergate, from John F. Kennedy to Henry Kissinger.
This first-ever biography captures a stunningly successful career of important exposés and outstanding accomplishments from a man whose unpredictable and quirky personality has turned him into an icon of American life and the unrivaled “scoop artist” of American journalism.
Published by: University of Nebraska Press
Download PDF (130.7 KB)
Title Page, Copyright, Dedication
Download PDF (89.9 KB)
Download PDF (48.4 KB)
List of Illustrations
Download PDF (54.6 KB)
Prologue: Chasing Sy Hersh
Download PDF (77.1 KB)
I have been chasing Sy Hersh, America’s quintessential investigative reporter, for twenty-five years. He did not know it, however, until five I first met Seymour Myron Hersh in the fall of 1985 when he was forty-eight years old. I had invited him to speak at my university, a small state college seventy-five miles from New York City near the Hudson River, ...
Download PDF (56.8 KB)
Many people helped make this book possible. I am particularly grateful to Kelsey VanNorman, Robert M. Miraldi, and Mary Beth Pfeiffer. Various assistants aided me, including Ally Brisbin, Anthony Heim, James Audlin, Nina Schutzman, Alyssa Jung, and Marcy Velte. Marguerite Stein and Janet Graham Gottlieb helped me understand the Hersh family ancestry. ...
1. The Story No One Wanted
Download PDF (99.4 KB)
Geoffrey Cowan was a twenty-seven-year-old Yale Law School graduate working in Washington DC in the fall of 1969. He had just helped start a public interest legal foundation that became an important force in rep-resenting civil rights groups, women’s organizations, and labor unions. But Cowan was also following family tradition working part-time as a ...
2. The Scoop Heard ’Round the World
Download PDF (112.4 KB)
...“It must have been a beautiful area, before the war,” wrote Seymour Hersh about Quang Ngai Province. Beautiful, but also, he added, one of the most “dangerous regions in all of Vietnam.” Fertile farmlands and green rice paddies were set in the foothills of the Annamese Mountains with the white sandy beaches of the South China Sea in the distance. But it was ...
3. Hersh Becomes a Target
Download PDF (123.2 KB)
Sy Hersh and David Obst were flying high in late November. On Novem-ber 25, the president announced that America would stop producing and stockpiling chemical and biological weapons. Although not widely known, it was a direct response to Hersh’s 1968 book. Meanwhile, newspapers across the country were carrying Hersh’s My Lai stories — with two more ...
4. “Front Page” Lessons in Chicago
Download PDF (90.2 KB)
The Chicago native stayed close to home when time came for college in 1954. Money was tight. His father, Isador, a two-pack-a-day cigarette smoker, diagnosed with lung cancer in 1952, died just as Hersh and twin brother Alan were getting ready for college. Sy chose a public university, the Chicago campus of the University of Illinois. Because many parents ...
5. Selling, Publishing, Failing
Download PDF (73.7 KB)
Fort Leavenworth, Kansas, is known more for its federal penitentiary than for the fact that it has the oldest active U.S. Army base west of the Mis-sissippi. Occupying 5,600 acres and 7 million square feet in a thousand buildings, the base is sometimes known as the “intellectual center of the Army.” But for Sy Hersh, Leavenworth was just a very hot place where he ...
6. From the “Front Page” to the Pentagon
Download PDF (73.0 KB)
Seymour Hersh entered a comfort zone when he returned to Chicago. Just to be in the same building where he had worked at City News must have put him at ease. And he was back covering the Chicago streets he knew so well from growing up on the South Side. But, on the other hand, working for the Associated Press was not the Front Page, and being in ...
7. At War with the Pentagon
Download PDF (85.3 KB)
Sy Hersh arrived in Washington with wife Elizabeth in the summer of 1965. Hersh was part of a remarkable group of young reporters who had joined the AP — James Polk, who won a Pulitzer Prize in 1974; Gaylord Shaw, a Pulitzer winner in 1978; Carl Leubsdorf, who became one of the nation’s best known political writers; and Barry Schweid, who covered ...
8. Fighting His Editors
Download PDF (97.7 KB)
The Pentagon was the world’s biggest military machine, but it also had the largest war public relations apparatus. The government spent more than $20 million a year in 1966 just to promote its activities — including the war in Southeast Asia — with three thousand people assigned to the Department of Defense PR staff. Many of the reporters who worked out ...
9. Finding America’s Hidden Arsenal
Download PDF (88.9 KB)
The- top-of-the-page banner headline was ominous: “U.S. Could Deliver Deadly Gases, Germs.” Although pushed back to page four of the April 14, 1967, edition of Stars and Stripes, the independent newspaper that covers the military, the headline seemed to warn of ghastly American weapons with a searing exposé to follow. The byline was Seymour H. ...
10. Speaking for Gene McCarthy
Download PDF (125.2 KB)
Lyndon Johnson easily defeated Barry Goldwater in 1964 in one of Amer-ica’s largest landslides. Emboldened, the tall Texan pushed ahead on his Great Society reforms as Medicaid, Medicare, and civil rights legislation sailed through Congress. These were legacies and carryovers of John Ken-nedy’s presidency, Johnson insisted, but so too was the gnawing war in ...
11. Stunning Triumph over Germs
Download PDF (85.3 KB)
Leaving the McCarthy presidential campaign was not easy for Seymour Hersh. “I can hate him and I can love him,” Hersh said about the senator, but, mostly, “I love him.” Hersh had grown used to dealing with elected officials who left much of the policymaking to staff members. But McCarthy was different; he was smart, and Hersh felt strongly about him, declaring, ...
12. Scoop Artist Meets the Viet Cong
Download PDF (78.7 KB)
Winning the Pulitzer Prize changes a reporter’s life. Legendary columnist Mike Royko, who worked briefly for Sy Hersh when he ran a suburban Chicago newspaper, won his Pulitzer in 1972. When a colleague earned the prize, Royko summed up what it meant: “Congratulations, you’ve just written the first line of your obituary.” No matter what else he did ...
13. The Times Calls
Download PDF (113.1 KB)
The New York Times is the most well known and highly respected news-paper in the world. As the Bible of the intelligentsia, a must-read for everyone in government, finance, and academe, its foreign news and diplomatic coverage is as closely watched as is the State Department or the United Nations. Former Times reporter Gay Talese described it as “a ...
14. Digging into Watergate
Download PDF (107.4 KB)
In August 1972 Robert M. Smith, a thirty-two-year-old reporter in the Washington bureau of the New York Times, took the acting director of the Federal Bureau of Investigation, L. Patrick Gray, out to lunch at a fancy French restaurant. Smith had written three page-one stories about Gray, who succeeded J. Edgar Hoover; Gray had taken a liking to the ...
15. Cambodia, Bombs, and Impeachment
Download PDF (100.4 KB)
When Sy Hersh, Carl Bernstein, and Bob Woodward met for dinner in April 1973, Woodward refused to toke on the marijuana they passed around. He knew the White House was looking to cut the credibility of the Post report-ers. “These Goddamn cannibals,” Nixon said in an April 27 meeting with press secretary Ronald Ziegler. “Hell, they’re not after [Bob] Haldeman or ...
16. Hunting the Coup Plotters
Download PDF (117.3 KB)
By the fall of 1974 Sy Hersh was the Golden Boy of the New York Times, but he had his share of flubs and missed stories. As he pursued Watergate and wider corruption in the White House in late 1973, one source filled Hersh’s ears with sketchy details about some sort of taping system in the Oval Office. Something about the president bugging his own conversations. ...
17. Skeletons Tumble from the CIA Closet
Download PDF (102.2 KB)
Daniel Schorr was one of America’s most famous broadcasters back when the television networks — CBS, NBC, ABC — ruled the airwaves. Rumpled, gray-haired Schorr, the recipient of three Emmy awards, was part of CBS’s Old Guard who learned at the feet of legendary Edward R. Murrow. His reporting earned him a place on Richard Nixon’s enemies ...
18. The Submarine Caper
Download PDF (110.3 KB)
As the CIA story splashed across America’s front pages, Sy Hersh became the darling of the national media. He had experienced this before after My Lai. Now it happened again as the press corps caught up with him. “I’m sort of cast in the mold of Cracker Jack reporter, the Clark Kent hero,” he observed, and the ego-driven Hersh did not shy away. In fact, his high ...
19. Going after “The Godfather”
Download PDF (106.7 KB)
How did the director of Central Intelligence get the entire press corps to cooperate? William Colby called it “the weirdest conspiracy in town . . .an American conspiracy.” He viewed the silence of the press as “a great tribute to our journalists.” But for others it was a mockery of the adver-sarial role envisioned by the First Amendment. In 1977 Times columnist ...
20. The Big Apple Turns Sour
Download PDF (93.9 KB)
Sy Hersh never aspired to be an editor. He was too restless to be desk bound or the comma police, but he had ideas how a newspaper should be run. He told Rosenthal, “The paper must always have a least one or two special projects in the works, some story or series of stories that make us different, that provide an edge that helps make the paper what it is. ...
21. Scoop Artist versus Dr. Kissinger
Download PDF (104.9 KB)
Sy Hersh was at the pinnacle of success at the New York Times. But just as he had worn out his welcome at the City News Bureau, at the Associated Press, and with Eugene McCarthy, by 1979 he was finished at the Times.His abrasive personality, feuds with editor Abe Rosenthal, publisher Sulz-berger’s increasing unease — all led to the inevitable. Rosenthal admitted ...
22. The Summer’s Literary Furor
Download PDF (97.8 KB)
As 1982 ended, Henry Kissinger’s consulting business was snaring big-name, big-paying clients. Appearing regularly on ABC’s late-evening talk show Nightline, Kissinger was, as James Reston noted in the New York Times, “a one-man university . . . on the tube explaining in his amiable growl” how foreign policy and the world should work. But a time bomb ...
23. Who Shot Down the Korean Airliner?
Download PDF (105.4 KB)
Henry Kissinger was furious at Seymour Hersh. But as angry as he was, he did not sue. He knew that as a public man, his options were limited. “No public official has a right to demand immunity from criticism, even from a measure of unfair criticism,” he wrote. Moreover, he said, “the last thing I desire is a regurgitation of Hersh’s charges.” He did not get ...
24. Reporting the Worst-Kept Secret in the World
Download PDF (104.9 KB)
On December 20, 1989, the United States launched an invasion of Panama that was promptly and roundly condemned by the United Nations. The goal was to seize Manuel Noriega. Twenty-four American soldiers were killed, but on January 3, 1990, the Bush administration captured the dictator and brought him back to America. Sy Hersh, who always collected more facts ...
25. Sex, Lies, and Fraud
Download PDF (112.5 KB)
Sy Hersh was a twenty-seven-year-old novice in 1963, working the night shift for the Associated Press, earning twelve dollars a week and living in a rented room in Chicago. A roommate woke him early in the afternoon on November 22 to tell him that President Kennedy had been assassinated. “I sat there, glum, like everybody else,” Hersh recalled. And then he cried. ...
26. Going after Sy Hersh
Download PDF (83.4 KB)
The controversy over the forged John Kennedy–Marilyn Monroe papers was both a nightmare and godsend for Sy Hersh. Everyone now knew he had a big new book on the way. “The bottom line,” he declared, is that if it hadn’t been for the forgery scandal, “the buzz on the book would have been much less.” On the other hand the lambasting of Sy Hersh ...
27. The New Yorker Years
Download PDF (100.1 KB)
Pulitzer Prize–winning war correspondents Seymour Hersh and David Halberstam sat on a panel together soon after the Gulf War in 1991. Hal-berstam won his award because when he reported from Vietnam for the New York Times he often contradicted the Kennedy administration, which wanted him fired. Hersh, on the other hand, never left the country and ...
28. An Alternative View of the Mideast
Download PDF (96.2 KB)
The Barry McCaffrey episode both energized and demoralized Sy Hersh. He won no awards. General McCaffrey observed, “Hersh was and still is outraged that there was no career fatality.” And he was disappointed that no publisher asked for a book.1 Hersh was probably still too hot to handle, or, possibly, even publishers did not want to diminish the glorious Gulf ...
29. Back on Top
Download PDF (96.8 KB)
Sy Hersh, sixty-seven years old, and Secretary of Defense Donald Rums-feld, seventy-two, had been dealing with each other for thirty years. Hersh called him “funny and attractive and witty, seriously good company. You call him, he calls you back. You have a lot of fun. You laugh. He laughs.” And that was despite the fact that in 1975 Rumsfeld, President Ford’s chief ...
Epilogue: A Muckraker’s Unfinished Business
Download PDF (77.0 KB)
Sy Hersh was buried in research and writing. Hersh’s housekeeper-babysitter was at his Washington DC home when the phone rang. Hersh’s number had always been listed publicly. In a thick accent the anonymous caller told the housekeeper exactly where her three children were at that moment. And then he told her where Hersh’s three children were. Sy and ...
Selected Works of Seymour Hersh
Download PDF (66.8 KB)
A complete bibliography of Seymour Hersh’s work would take dozens of pages. He wrote hundreds of articles for the Associated Press alone from 1963 to 1967; then, from 1972 to 1979, hundreds more for the New York Times. From 1999 to the present he has written dozens of articles for the New Yorker. The bibli-ography that follows represents a small sliver of his most important articles ...
Seymour Hersh Timeline
Download PDF (55.1 KB)
...1958 Receives a degree in history from the University of Chicago.1961 Publishes a weekly newspaper in Evergreen, Illinois, a Chicago 1962–63 UPI correspondent in Pierre, South Dakota, the state capital.1964 In May he marries Elizabeth Sarah Klein; they will have three chil-1964–65 Works as general assignment reporter for the Associated Press in ...
Download PDF (383.3 KB)
Download PDF (937.6 KB)
Download PDF (681.0 KB)
FIG. 1. Seymour Hersh, top right, and his twin brother, Alan, are pictured in the 1954 yearbook of Hyde Park High School in Chicago. (Courtesy of Hyde Park High School)FIG. 2. Bodies of men, women and children are piled in a ditch in the village of My Lai where American soldiers massacred hundreds of unarmed Vietnamese civilians in 1968. (Ron Haeberle / TIME & LIFE Images / Getty Images)...
Publication Year: 2013