The Shaman and the Heresiarch
A New Interpretation of the Li sao
Publication Year: 2012
Published by: State University of New York Press
Title Page, Copyright, Dedication
Download PDF (41.9 KB)
Download PDF (54.8 KB)
Now that I have been a teacher of Asian literature for well over a decade, I look back in gratitude, and sometimes wonder, to those who taught me. My first teacher, one of the very best, was Mrs. Yuan Ming-ch’iu, who had the good fortune to teach me when I was still a decent student. At Yale University, for various personal reasons, I became...
Download PDF (815.5 KB)
There is a word in Chinese that sums up all that we know about the origins of ancient Chinese poetry—feng sao 風騷. Read literally it means “wind sorrow.” It in fact refers to the main sections of the two most ancient anthologies of Chinese poetry: the Shi jing 詩經, or the Book of Songs, and the Chu ci 楚辭 or the Songs of Chu1...
Chapter One: Wang Yi and Han Dynasty Classical Commentary
Download PDF (689.4 KB)
David Hawkes in his The Songs of the South wrote, “The Later Han was an age of great scholars and exegetes, but Wang Yi was emphatically not of their number.” Hawkes was not alone in his judgment.1 The philosopher Zhu Xi began challenging Wang Yi’s work as early as the Song dynasty. By the Ming and Qing dynasties, the Chinese words for “strained”, “...
Chapter Two: Wang Yi and the Woman Who Commissioned the Chu ci zhangju
Download PDF (516.2 KB)
The official history of the Later Han dynasty (Hou Han shu 後漢書) records precious few details about the life and career of Wang Yi.1 He was from Yicheng 宜城 in Nanjun 南郡 (or South Commandery, modern Jiangling in Hubei), site of one of the old Chu capitals and the reputed home of the Chu poet Song Yu 宋玉. Sometime during the Yuanchu...
Chapter Three: The Intergendered Shaman of the Li sao
Download PDF (697.7 KB)
What does the removal of the roadblock posed by Wang Yi’s interpretation of the word jiang allow us to see in the Li sao? Does it reveal a “logical pattern of events,” what many modern scholars tell us the poem lacks?1 And are those events amenable to allegorical interpretation? Once we recognize that the beginning of...
Chapter Four: The Realm of Shaman Peng-Floral Imagery in the Li sao
Download PDF (793.2 KB)
Despite its extensive use in the poem, no one has ever convincingly explained the floral imagery of the Li sao. Traditional commentators, in the train of Wang Yi, reasonably assume that the fragrant plants stand for virtue, and the malodorous ones...
Chapter Five: The Philosophy of the Li sao, Part 1
Download PDF (719.6 KB)
It is a great irony that the man who first pointed out one of the most important keys to understanding the Li sao should have never used it himself. In fact, he began a two-thousand-year tradition of ignoring that key. I am speaking of course of Wang Yi, who in his Chu ci commentary...
Chapter Six: The Philosophy of the Li sao, Part 2
Download PDF (735.9 KB)
The philosophers disagreed as to the exact nature of the sage kings’ statecraft and self-cultivation. Yet most of them used the term Dao, the Way, to describe both. And all agreed that this Dao was somehow connected to Heaven, understood either as a governing benevolent force or impersonal natural order. The Way appears in the Li sao as well—in road and travel...
Chapter Seven: Shaman Xian’s Domain: The First and Second Journeys
Download PDF (742.2 KB)
One of the greatest roadblocks to a coherent reading of the Li sao is the “first journey” (lines 181‒256), where Zhengze Ling Jun while presenting her case in the masculine voice of the spirit Zhengze in front of the tomb of Shun 舜 (Chonghua 重華), suddenly finds him/...
Chapter Eight: Conclusion
Download PDF (521.7 KB)
I once presented a paper to the Columbia Seminar on Traditional China to get some feedback on some of the ideas developed in this book, especially the idea that the fourth line of the poem gives the date of the descent of a spirit rather than the birth of Qu Yuan. Afterward a member of the seminar, a scholar from China, asked...
Appendix 1: A Translation of the Li sao
Download PDF (84.4 KB)
Appendix 2: The Nine Songs
Download PDF (462.7 KB)
Download PDF (770.6 KB)
Selected Bibliography of Works in Chinese and Japanese
Download PDF (644.4 KB)
Selected Bibliography of Works in Western Languages
Download PDF (672.3 KB)
Download PDF (96.5 KB)
Download PDF (31.2 KB)
Page Count: 256
Publication Year: 2012