Everyday Life in Russian History: Quotidian Studies in Honor of Daniel Kaiser

Appreciating The Growth of Law in Medieval Russia

Everyday Life in Russian History: Quotidian Studies in Honor of Daniel Kaiser. Gary Marker, Joan Neuberger, Marshall Poe, and Susan Rupp, eds. Bloomington, IN: Slavica Publishers, 2010, 377–90. A A A Appreciating The Growth of Law in Medieval Russia David M. Goldfrank
A)A!A AA%&'A*A&A%&!$ A A! A !A&)!A)*%6AA A!!A&A&A%A%% &*A A$&A !$7A%!& A&&A%A)!$&A%&'* A A&%A!) A $&A  A  A A !"$A )&A "$(!'%A  A %'%#' &A !' &%6A $7A A  A %&'*A A )A !A %A A $&! 7A  A !'&$!)&7A !A ($!'%A %&!$A ( &%6A A %! A "!%%&*A %A 'A !$A&?! %' A A&%A!A$&$A$$!$7A '&A&A%A%!A'A!$A &$%& A A$)$?  A'%AA%&' &A!AA!$A)A !A (? &*A'%&A A&&A%A!&A!A%&'*A$$!$%A&A )!A "!&7A %!7A  A ! !A (!'&! A  A%&$'&'$A!AA"$&'$A%&!$A$6A '%A! %A&A$$*A)A$%$A A&!'&A!'&A66A%? %$&&! A!A!'$A&A$ 7A&$7A A!'A$A7A )A%&%A &A%&A!$A*A)A! &%A! A&A%  A!A&A)!$A!A%A66A %&' &A A %$A! A$*A'%% A)6A!$AA!A !&A& A&&A&A)!'A A$?&A&!A$'A&&A %$7A A%A!) A)*A A!$A%A($*A$ &A  #'$*7A""AA966A%%67A ($%&*A!A !7A-521:7A-6A . A A6A %$7A=A$ %!$&! A!A A&! %A A A'%A966A%%67A ($%&*A!A!7A-533:6A / A A6A %$7A 
       9$ &! 7A 8A$ &! A  ($%&*A $%%7A -54,:6A A &A "$!'$A !$A ""* A !$A &A ! A !%A $!) A $+A!$A&A%&A$%&A!!A*AA !$&A
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
$$ '#"G#G'G( G$%"$ &G#"'"G"G'G#&8G ' G" ,&&G#G'G")( G$%#)&#"&G"G'%!&G#G'G#&9G*G #'"G#!$",G$( '#"&G"G'%"& '#"&9G"G"#%!G &%G"G#("'D &&G*,&9G#"&''('G'G'%G&'%"8G
G"G+!$ G#G'&G&G8G8G%#)A&G !&&)G#+ " 84 +G#(%'G#!$%&&
#("'%,D&G"G#!$%D ')G" ,&&G#G'G) #$!"'G#G *G"G!) G&'%"G"G"'% G(D %#$9G&(G&G# #G"G ' "A&G &&G#"G" "85 G&G#!$%&#"&G  #*G &%G'#G$"$#"'G&$G" #&9G!#"G'!G'G %,A&G%# G"G '&'!"'&G"G'G("'#""G#G#% G,G%#"86 G
"G'G'G&'%"G#"D &&'&G#GG& *G#G&'(&G#G(&'#!%,G('#"9G$%)'G *9G& D $9G"G &#G #%'F*'G *G !#%"&G  G B$%!')G *8CG &G #G &(G *#%&G $%D !''G &%G"G&G"' 9G"'%#('#%,G$'%G'#G#"'+'( -G&G&('G"G G'#%#( ,G#%" G!""%9G&G* G&G'#G"',G"#'%G&'G#G" #&8G
"G+ "'G+!$ 9G*G &G'#G!"G&#!G$%"$ &G#G'G+$"G %)G "G %#& )A&G ''('G "G (%&G &G G  %G '%"&'#"G !#!"'G D GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG /7619G'&G&+'G,%G"G+&'"9G&G'G&G'#,9G'"G &%GG'#G&(!'G'%G#$&G#G 'G##G"G'%G%)*&G'%G,%&G'%G'G##A&G$( '#"G'#GG$%-G#!!'D '9G $%&(! ,G #G '%G "G $$#"'G ,G 'G ) G
!,G #G
!%9G 'G %&'G &(G # G )"G "G *%G "G /757G #%G G /753G ##:G http://www. medievalacademy.org/grants/gradstudent_brown_subinstr.htm /760?:G101E02=8G 3 G  G"!"&9G+ )+++#+" +
#GIA#BI>I*'I#$I*#I$I$&#I(I($I(I'$"I%&G $#*I"$!I&I&"$*I&$"I"*!I)''#I&!(':12 I#I#I'I ('I&$&I#I,(&(-I#I '&D'I,(&($#I$I"(&!I&$"I(I+'(I%$'G '!I*&(-I$I'$)&'I#I#!-''I($I!)(I')I"((&'I'I(I#()&I$I #I'(#($#I(+#I(I-+(#''I?#@I#I"$&I#&!;I$"")#(-I +(#''I? "@:13 I #;I(I&*+&'I+&I*&()!!-I)##"$)'I#I%&'I !$#I(I!#'I((I('I+$& I+'I,(#'*!-I&'&;I##$*(*;I#I*!G )!;I#I'*&!I$%#I((I(I+$)!I#)I'%!'('I($I&(# I(I!'(I )''D'I &!-I !!I '($&-;I I #$(I $(&I '')'I 'I +!!:14 I
#I '%(I '$"I &('"';I+I I'!!I,"#I!(&;I(I!#I'(I$I('I&*+'I+'I $*&+!"#!-I*$&!:I IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 9 I '&;I$!;I193I#:I32:
10 I)!I)' $*(;I&*+I$I '&;I$!;,#I " , !%,9I G )%+I *I +0I '')>I $"*I +$I &+I #&&"I -)0I &&I *I &$'#$%+)0I ##I *+&) %*I&I')G$&)%I,** =I) %I %I&$%I .I+I+I% -)G * +0I &I )*.I &)I I $ )+I +&I # ,$I %I +I 4I 1+#I .*I &+I $+ ,#&,*I %I /+)$#0I )*'+,#I &I #)%I ')**&)*=I *I+.&I)+I*)- *I %I+I&$ %I&I)#0I,** %I#.I.)I  *I/'# +I+)%*#+ &%*I %+&I)%IA*&$I&I+$I&$'#+ %I+I.&)"I&I  *I $%+&)I
#/%)I "B>48 I %I I *) *I &I )+ #*>I #$&*+I $ % G$&%&G )'*>I&%I *)+I **,*I %I+ )I-#&'$%+#I&%+/+=49III)+ %#0III *%*I &I )&.+I %I %I . + %I #.I %I &,#I #&+I *'  I -#&'G $%+*I %I + )I&%)+I *+&) #I* +,+ &%*=I I"%&.I)&$I &,)I&%-)*+ &%*I .%I I.*I*+ ##II),+I*+,%+I++II $I %I *I*+,0I&I+I*++,*I&I &) %I $)%+*I %I ,*&-0I %&+I &%#0I +&I &-)I + *I +&' I )&%&#& ##0>I ,+I#*&I+&I&)% 1I+I'))'*I*&I*I+&I&##&.I+*I+))*I)&$I+I+ $I &I+ )I)) -#I %I,** I+)&,I+ )I')+,)I)&$I+I)#$=II 1+#D*I +)%*#+ &%*I %**) #0I &-)I +&&I $%0I +$*I +&I I #I +&I  -II+I++%+ &%I++I  *)I >I*'  ##0I+&I*%+ &%*>I- %>I%I !,  #I')*&%%#I %I$!=I...