In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content:

22 Book of Gomorrah Certainly the reality of events is not verified on the basis of historians ' statements. However, their interpretation often is, and the question here is the trustworthiness of Damian's statement that homosexuality had grown up among the clergy of his region. The scholars just cited have been adduced simply to indicate the absence of any serious caveat among respectable historians in taking Damian's claim at its face value. Given the general decline of sexual morality among the clergy at the time, the specific situations dealt with by Damian, and the fact that the Pope saw fit to respond to the Book of Gomorrah, it would seem reasonable to accept Damian's assertion. The specific situations dealt with by Peter Damian tell against Kiihn's view that Damian had overgeneralized from a few individualcases, a view further developed by Bailey.66 Conclusion To the extent that Peter Damian received a reply from the Pope to his questions in regard to the ecclesiastical censure of clerics engaged in homosexual practices, the Book of Gomorrah could be said to have been a success. However, it did not succeed in convincing the Pope to follow through on Damian's call for the indiscriminate deposition of such clerics. Whether or not the work succeeded in reversing the spread of homosexual practices in the areas which were of concern to Damian is unknown. All that can be said is that he never returned to an extended discussion of the theme again. I know of no use of the work by subsequent authors, but an excerpt from Leo's reply is contained in a later collection of canon law.67 The Translation The challenge for a translator is to be faithful to the original while being as idiomatic aspossible in the translation. I will not resurrect the 66 See L. Kiihn, Petrus Damiani und seine Anschauungen uber Staat und Kirche (Karlsruhe, 1913), 3; Bailey, Homosexuality, 115: "His onslaught was probably provoked less by an outbreak of vice than by his revulsion from the conduct of a few licentious individuals which had come to his notice, and which served to sharpen the edge of his indignation." 67 The Polycarpus, Paris, Bibl. nat. lat. 3881, fol. 134r, quotes an excerpt from Leo's reply to Damian. ...

Share