Ensuring Quality or Restricting Competition?
Publication Year: 2006
Published by: W.E. Upjohn Institute
Title Page, Copyright
Download PDF (213.1 KB)
Download PDF (176.6 KB)
In writing this book I have benefited from the contributions of many individuals to whom I am most grateful. For most valuable assistance with the research I thank Irma Arteaga, Alexandra Broat, Joan Gieseke, Adrienne Howard, Alexander Lefter, John Linder, Claire Matese, Clint Pecenka, Keith Vargo, Yingying Wang, ...
Download PDF (178.4 KB)
The licensing of occupations has a long and varied history. Among the oldest evidence of rules governing occupations is the existence of the Babylonian Code of Hammurabi, dating to around 1780 BCE. This body of codes stipulated both the fees patients were to pay for medical services and the punishments practitioners ...
1. Introduction and Overview
Download PDF (360.5 KB)
Dentists, doctors, lawyers, fortune tellers, and frog farmers are now licensed occupations in either all or some U.S. states.1 During the early 1950s, only about 4.5 percent of the labor force was covered by licensing laws at the state level. That number had grown to almost 18 percent of the U.S. workforce ...
2. Development of Occupational Licensing as a Labor Market Institution
Download PDF (503.7 KB)
As these two statements suggest, there are often conflicting views of the goals and outcomes achieved by occupational licensing. This chapter aims to provide the institutional setting for the theoretical and empirical analysis that follows, building a background for the development of this labor market institution. ...
3. Quality and the Demand for Occupational Licensing
Download PDF (465.2 KB)
Although licensing is intended to increase quality of services and reduce the availability of substitutes, the newspaper story above illustrates an unintended consequence of the licensing of dental services, namely using do-it-yourself remedies. The individual highlighted in this newspaper column ...
4. Licensing, Labor Supply, and Earnings
Download PDF (705.3 KB)
As this analysis suggests, advocates of “teacher professionalization” seek to not only increase the quality of education, but also to raise the earnings of the members of the occupation through tougher regulations. The task of licensing is generally placed with state licensing boards, which usually consist of individuals ...
5. State Regulatory Policies and the Economy-wide Impacts of Licensing
Download PDF (502.4 KB)
This newspaper report shows the potential clash of state licensing policies and religious practices. As more occupations seek to become licensed or to increase statutory requirements and job control, confrontations are likely to occur between groups seeking nonlicensed services and laws restricting those services. ...
6. Comparing Licensing in the United States and the European Union
Download PDF (430.5 KB)
As the above quote suggests, the regulation of occupations is perceived to be a major factor in the lack of efficiency in the labor market and a contributor to lagging productivity and high unemployment in Europe. Is this the case, and do the European methods of regulating occupations have different outcomes ...
7. The Emerging Labor Market Institution of Occupational Licensing
Download PDF (433.1 KB)
As the above exchange illustrates, the potential conflict between enhancing quality and restricting competition has been at the core of the debate on the efficacy of occupational licensing during the post–World War II era. The goal of this concluding chapter is to provide a further rationale for the existence, ...
Appendix A: Criteria for Regulating Occupations for Legislators and a Questionnaire for Occupations Seeking Regulation in Minnesota
Download PDF (194.4 KB)
Appendix B: Data Sources
Download PDF (272.3 KB)
Appendix C: Occupations Analyzed in the United States Using Multivariate Techniques
Download PDF (120.4 KB)
Download PDF (351.3 KB)
Download PDF (120.7 KB)
Morris M. Kleiner is a professor at the Humphrey Institute of Public Affairs and the Industrial Relations Center at the University of Minnesota–Twin Cities. He is a research associate in Labor Studies at the National Bureau of Economic Research and a visiting scholar in the economic research department ...
Download PDF (356.0 KB)
About the Institute
Download PDF (289.6 KB)
The W.E. Upjohn Institute for Employment Research is a nonprofit research organization devoted to finding and promoting solutions to employment- related problems at the national, state, and local levels. It is an activity of the W.E. Upjohn Unemployment Trustee Corporation, which was established in 1932 ...
Page Count: 195
Publication Year: 2006