-
Chapter 9: The Indefatigable James Mitchell
- University of Missouri Press
- Chapter
- Additional Information
96 Despite his budgetary setbacks James Mitchell continued to press for the British emigration scheme’s revival in the United States. On November 24, 1864, he submitted his promised supplement to the report sought by the Senate in June, hoping that Congress would act to restore his funding in the approaching winter session. He asked Congress to directly appropriate the $5,000 “credit” requested by the African Civilization Society and expressed hope of resuming work on the British Honduras and Guiana projects, noting both colonies still desired labor.1 Mitchell enclosed a supplement, wherein he lashed out at the Chiriquí and Île à Vache contracts. These ventures ignored “the true interests of the emigrant” in pursuit of the “personal emolument of the parties” involved. Though he avoided naming Usher directly, he attributed the failure of both schemes to the actions of “sundry parties not responsible” for the Emigration Office’s work and beyond its jurisdiction. Should Congress resume colonization , he urged that it be placed in the hands of “reliable agencies” such as the British colonies or handled through direct dealings with the governments of Haiti and Liberia.2 The intervening months since Congress had repealed the colonization fund had done little to alleviate the raging animosity between Mitchell and Usher. On the contrary, Congress’s action had introduced new legal ambiguities. Mitchell asserted on a reasonably strong legal basis that even though his budget was repealed, he retained a commission to his office from Lincoln. This authorized him to make the supplemental report, which several senators had expected the previous June even as they voted to abolish the colonization fund.3 Usher’s retroactive suspension of Mitchell’s salary to January 1864 only further complicated the issue by tapping into an authorized portion of the fund, and it set the stage for a protracted legal battle. Mitchell traveled west to visit his family during the summer’s congressional recess, briefly pausing to write Lincoln about his political troubles. Chapter 9 The Indefatigable James Mitchell The Indefatigable James Mitchell 97 The journey likely reignited his flair for Hoosier politics, which may have also been the original source of his bitterness with Usher. Both men were veterans of a tumultuous political battle in the 1850s over the future of free blacks in Indiana, one of the most “negrophobic” northern states, and may have crossed paths as part of rival Republican and Democratic factions.4 The emigration commissioner attributed Usher’s “foolish war on me” to “the instigation of the Arch-traytor [sic] Elwood Fisher years ago, and continued by the direction of an equally pure cliant [sic] A. W. Thompson,” the recipient of the original Chiriquí contract. Wrote Mitchell, “I respectfully and earnestly urge a change in the Department of the Interior” after the fall election, and he suggested that his own replacement come from the Midwest.5 Unbeknownst to the president, Mitchell was simultaneously plotting to oust Usher through the influence of his old friend Bishop Matthew Simpson. Even without Mitchell’s schemes, Usher’s job was imperiled by the arrival of Hugh McCulloch as the new treasury secretary at the outset of Lincoln’s second term. This appointment left Indiana overrepresented on the cabinet, and Simpson sensed a chance to push for a Methodist nominee. A few days before the November election Mitchell wrote Simpson about their strategy to replace Usher. He advised the bishop to avoid pressing Lincoln on any other political appointments. “It will take all the power we can muster to force our member of Cabinet on the Govt. and if you and others reserve their strength we will likely succeed.”6 Simpson, Mitchell, and Lincoln each had multiple reasons to favor the intended replacement, Iowa Senator James Harlan. He was a personal friend of Lincoln’s (his daughter would later marry the president’s son Robert). Simpson had also known the Harlan family for years through their membership in his church, and the Methodist connection similarly appealed to Mitchell. More important, Harlan was sympathetic to Mitchell’s recent difficulties in the Interior Department. By November 1864 Usher’s replacement was a forgone conclusion due to the elevation of McCulloch in Treasury. Lincoln named Harlan to the Interior post, owing in part to Simpson’s lobbying.7 The changeover would prove a slow and painful one, illustrating Usher’s coldness toward his successor. Though Lincoln secured Usher’s resignation almost immediately after the November election, the new appointment would not take effect until after Inauguration Day the...