Women Writing of the Divinest Things
Rhetoric and the Poetry of Pembroke, Wroth, and Lanyer
Publication Year: 2004
Published by: Duquesne University Press
Download PDF (58.0 KB)
Download PDF (79.6 KB)
Scholars have only lately begun to consider women’s place in the history of rhetoric. Recent volumes such as Reclaiming Rhetorica, Listening to Their Voices and The Changing Tradition draw attention to the role women from antiquity to present day have played in rhetorical history.1 Important as it is, though, much of the work so far done on the topic of women and rhetoric is the ...
Download PDF (57.8 KB)
No book is the product of a single author, and this one is no exception. My research was aided immeasurably by the support of the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada and the Izaak Walton Killam Trust. Though inspired by many, I owe special thanks to John Baxter, Christina Luckyj and Ronald ...
INTRODUCTION: Women Writing of Divinest Things
Download PDF (172.8 KB)
“Historians,” Sara Mendelson and Patricia Crawford confirm, “have tended to assume that women were culturally impoverished because of their exclusion from élite literate culture.”1 Seldom explicitly asserted, the exclusion of women from “élite literate culture” is further implied by a critical reluctance to consider the role their poetry might have played in rhetorical history. ...
PART ONE: RHETORIC AND DEVOTION IN PEMBROKE’S PSALMES
Download PDF (80.9 KB)
Mary Sidney Herbert was for a long time best known as the sister of Sir Philip Sidney. But the Countess of Pembroke has recently emerged from her brother’s shadow and is now recognized as an accomplished poet in her own right, largely because of her work on the Psalmes. “Mary Sidney Herbert and her contemporaries,” Noel J. Kinnamon notes, “believed that her metrical paraphrase of the Psalms was her most significant ...
1. The Politics of Prayer
Download PDF (109.2 KB)
I begin with one of the more overtly political psalms. Psalm 72 is one of a group biblical scholar Robert Alter loosely categorizes as the “monarchic psalms,” and one that can be easily read as petitioning both a heavenly and an earthly monarch. Pembroke’s psalm opens with an appeal to God to “Teach the kings sonne” (1), and ...
2. Private Rhetoric and Public Oratory
Download PDF (145.8 KB)
We may, of course, be tempted to ask if Pembroke ranks as either a true poet or a serious rhetor; her Psalmes are, after all, translations (or paraphrases or metaphrases) of extant works.1 Puttenham, who makes a sharp distinction between translation and “original” work, might argue that she is neither: “the very Poet,” he maintains, “makes and contriues out of his owne braine both the verse and ...
3. Bringing God Before Our Eyes
Download PDF (130.5 KB)
Though the strengths of Pembroke’s Psalmes are many, poetry and rhetoric’s compatibility is most clearly evinced in the depth of their invention and in the energeia that results. One of the finest examples of the psalter’s singular mimetic energy is found in Psalm 139. The poem begins on an energetic note with an assertion of God’s active omniscience: “O lord in me," ...
4. Devotional Decorum
Download PDF (134.7 KB)
Though many of Pembroke’s readers have remarked on her considerable poetic skill, they seldom acknowledge that she would not have been so skillful a poet if she had not also been an accomplished rhetor. Indeed, the degree of her expertise in poetry and rhetoric may go a long way toward explaining why her Psalmes begin with a declaration that makes the expressive process seem easy. ...
PART TWO: SACRED AND SECULAR IN WROTH’S “A CROWNE OF SONNETS”
Download PDF (87.6 KB)
Far from exemplifying what her uncle Philip Sidney might call a “divine poem,” Lady Mary Wroth’s Pamphilia to Amphilanthus is a notable example of English Petrarchism—or, as some would have it, anti-Petrarchism—and it is also the first complete Petrarchan sequence written and published by an English woman.1 ...
5. The Rhetorical Sonnet
Download PDF (119.9 KB)
Rather than failing to meet the criteria of a standard already set, Lady Mary Wroth’s sonnet sequence reworks even while drawing on the conventions of an established genre; though it may present many contraries of the Petrarchan kind, Pamphilia to Amphilanthus refuses to maintain polar opposition. This is especially true of ...
6. Reading in Circles
Download PDF (103.3 KB)
Wroth’s readers often note the many ways Pamphilia to Amphilanthus situates itself in opposition to other, male-authored sonnet sequences. Critics seem especially eager, however, in discussions of her crown sonnets to define her speaker as constant, present, private and feminine. I would like to present an antithetical view, and argue that it is in the corona especially that ...
7. Figuring the Sacred and the Secular
Download PDF (152.1 KB)
The interinanimation of the sacred and the secular in Pamphilia to Amphilanthus is most salient in “A crowne of Sonetts dedicated to Love.” That Donne coins the term in “The Ecstasy” makes interinanimation especially appropriate in a discussion of Wroth’s crown sonnets, which perplexes in a similar way. ...
8. Crowns of Devotion
Download PDF (119.4 KB)
Throughout my discussions of Pembroke’s Psalmes and Wroth’s Pamphilia to Amphilanthus, I have aimed to show how rhetoric plays a crucial role in devotional expression, whether that devotion centers on “erotic attachment or religious worship” or, as it sometimes does in Wroth’s sonnets, “both at once.”1 ...
PART THREE: PERSUASION AND PRAISE IN LANYER’S SALVE DEUS REX JUDAEORUM
Download PDF (117.7 KB)
Printed in London in 1611, Aemilia Lanyer’s poetic retelling of Christ’s Passion, Salve Deus Rex Judaeorum, appeared a dozen years after the scribal publication of the Countess of Pembroke’s Psalmes.1 Like Pembroke’s “translations,” Lanyer’s central poem reinterprets and rewrites some familiar biblical texts and, although the Salve may be more daring in its revisionism, ....
9. Proving Woman’s Worth
Download PDF (142.1 KB)
I begin my discussion of Lanyer’s volume in medias res for several reasons. First, “Eves Apologie” is not only a notable exception to Lanyer’s “biblical literalism,” it is also the place where her persuasive intent is most clear.1 As an apology in the early modern sense, “Eves Apologie” is a defense of women; as an apologia in the rhetorical sense, ...
10. Disciplines and Species
Download PDF (118.3 KB)
In its reliance on reasoned argument and its comparatively unornamented style, “Eves Apologie” may have as much in common with logic as it does with rhetoric, indicating once again that the two great disciplines were not entirely separable in the early modern mind. Wilson certainly believed in their compatibility: ...
11. Decorum and Persuasion
Download PDF (142.1 KB)
In demonstrating its author’s subtle understanding of the principles of decorum, Salve Deus Rex Judaeorum attests to Lanyer’s rhetorical expertise. Decorum was, in fact, so central a rhetorical concept that it functioned in early modern poetry as, says Rosemond Tuve, “the basic criterion in terms of which all the others were understood.” ...
12. The Art That Denies Art
Download PDF (136.3 KB)
It is in their similar denial of poetic art and their necessary practice of it that Lanyer’s correspondence with the poet who is perhaps also her nearest male counterpart, George Herbert, is most clear.1 Mueller certainly points to this possibility as well as to the importance of decorum in devotional verse when she notes that ...
Download PDF (114.6 KB)
Early modern writers of all kinds give voice to the belief that rhetoric is the most powerful tool for articulating the highest kinds of truth; it is through “rare inuentions & pleasant deuises,” as Peacham says, that “the deepe vnderstanding, the secret counselles, & politicke considerations of wisedome are most effectually expressed.”1 ...
Download PDF (314.1 KB)
Download PDF (1.2 MB)
Page Count: 342
Publication Year: 2004
Series Title: Medieval & Renaissance Literary Studies
Series Editor Byline: Albert C. Labriola