We cannot verify your location
Browse Book and Journal Content on Project MUSE

Closed Minds?

Politics and Ideology in American Universities

Bruce L.R. Smith, Jeremy D. Mayer, and A. Lee Fritschler

Publication Year: 2008

Contrary to popular belief, the problem with U.S. higher education is not too much politics but too little. Far from being bastions of liberal bias, American universities have largely withdrawn from the world of politics. So conclude Bruce L. R. Smith, Jeremy Mayer, and Lee Fritschler in this illuminating book. C losed Minds? d draws on data from interviews, focus groups, and a new national survey by the authors, as well as their decades of experience in higher education to paint the most comprehensive picture to date of campus political attitudes. It finds that while liberals outnumber conservatives within faculty ranks, even most conservatives believe that ideology has little impact on hiring and promotion. Today's students are somewhat more conservative than their professors, but few complain of political bias in the classroom. Similarly, a Pennsylvania legislative inquiry, which the authors explore as a case study of conservative activism in higher education, found that political bias was "rare" in the state's public colleges and universities. Yet this ideological peace on campus has been purchased at a high price. American universities are rarely hospitable to lively discussions of issues of public importance. They largely shun serious political debate, all but ignore what used to be called civics, and take little interest in educating students to be effective citizens. Smith, Mayer, and Fritschler contrast the current climate of disengagement with the original civic mission of American colleges and universities. In concluding, they suggest how universities can reclaim and strengthen their place in the nation's political and civic life.

Published by: Brookings Institution Press

Table of Contents

pdf iconDownload PDF (28.9 KB)
pp. vii-viii

read more


pdf iconDownload PDF (31.9 KB)
pp. ix-x

We gratefully acknowledge the assistance of the Lounsbery Foundation of Washington,D.C., in supporting our work. Jesse Ausubel of Rockefeller University, a member of the Lounsbery Foundation’s board, originally suggested the idea for the study.We thank him and David Abshire, president of the foundation, and Maxmillian Angerholzer III, its executive director, for their ...

read more

1. Introduction

pdf iconDownload PDF (50.3 KB)
pp. 1-7

Our aim in this study is to examine whether there is political or ideological bias in American higher education.We want to evaluate the criticisms of universities for being too left or liberal and to undertake the task in a systematic, fair-minded, and nonpartisan fashion. We know that we cannot fully answer all of the questions surrounding this topic, but we hope at least to ...

read more

2. Higher Education and the "Culture Wars"

pdf iconDownload PDF (87.0 KB)
pp. 8-23

Have America’s universities shifted pervasively to the political (or to the cultural) left and become captive to a narrow ideology? In the past thirty years, critics, many of them conservatives, have thought so. The assertion is that the typical American university has been dominated by ideologues outside the mainstream or at any rate hostile to traditional values, with the corollary ...

read more

3. Emergence of the U.S. Research University

pdf iconDownload PDF (103.0 KB)
pp. 24-43

In this chapter we look at how the universities were created in the country, their missions at the start and how those missions evolved, and how some of the past complexities foreshadow themes that we discuss in later chapters. This history is necessary because the past is always prologue and because we cannot understand the present ambivalence in the universities toward political ...

read more

4. Transformations of Academic Culture after World War II

pdf iconDownload PDF (132.7 KB)
pp. 44-70

The period after World War II, from 1945 to the student disturbances of 1968–72, has been called the golden age of higher education in the United States.1 Not since the Civil War, after which the sixty-seven land grant colleges were created, and the last decades of the nineteenth century, when the American research university fully emerged, could one point to changes of ...

read more

5. Political Attitudes of American Professors: Results of a 2007 National Survey

pdf iconDownload PDF (134.4 KB)
pp. 71-91

Just how dominant are liberals and Democrats on American campuses today? Does the current tilt to the left among college professors affect the classroom experience of students and the tenure chances of conservative faculty members? The assumption among many conservative pundits in America today is that college professors as a class are dangerous radicals and left-wing ...

read more

6. The Politics of Politics in the Classroom

pdf iconDownload PDF (122.4 KB)
pp. 92-116

In the preceding chapters we discuss the modest shift in faculty political attitudes that occurred in the 1980s. The traditional vocabulary of liberalism-conservatism has limitations when we seek to understand contemporary political reality.1 So we do not rely on our survey findings alone, and in this chapter we broaden our focus to account for the political motives behind ...

read more

7. Conservative Activism in Higher Education: The Pennsylvania Hearings on Academic Freedom

pdf iconDownload PDF (104.9 KB)
pp. 117-137

Conservative activism on higher education issues has grown since the 1990s. Notable changes have occurred and some battles have been won, such as in the area of affirmative action in university admissions. California, Florida, and Texas curbed admissions policies relying on affirmative action in their public university systems. The California action came as a result of a referendum ...

read more

8. Much Ado about Little: Student Perspectives on Classroom Bias

pdf iconDownload PDF (138.7 KB)
pp. 138-162

In previous chapters,we discuss the political attitudes of professors and see how activists, education associations, and political figures view the issue of political bias in the universities.Now we shift the focus to what, in fact, is going on in the classrooms and on campuses across the country, looking in this chapter at how students view the issues we have been discussing. Although professors tend ...

read more

9. Do Universities Discriminate in Hiring?

pdf iconDownload PDF (162.4 KB)
pp. 163-197

This chapter addresses the persistent criticism that universities discriminate against conservatives in hiring, promotion, and tenure decisions. Universities are most often said to discriminate in the humanities and social sciences (few contend that the sciences discriminate against conservatives, but conservatives are said to be hurt by affirmative action hiring requirements) ...

read more

10. Conclusions

pdf iconDownload PDF (82.2 KB)
pp. 198-212

This book has set out to explore political bias in the nation’s universities. We have reached conclusions that are in some ways reassuringly familiar and in other ways quite surprising to us. To use social science terms, we have confirmed some hypotheses but disconfirmed others, including some of the ideas that started us on the inquiry in the first place ...

Appendix A

pdf iconDownload PDF (51.3 KB)
pp. 213-223

Appendix B

pdf iconDownload PDF (58.6 KB)
pp. 224-233

Appendix C

pdf iconDownload PDF (31.2 KB)
pp. 234-235

Appendix D

pdf iconDownload PDF (33.0 KB)
pp. 236-238

Appendix E

pdf iconDownload PDF (35.6 KB)
pp. 239-241


pdf iconDownload PDF (151.6 KB)
pp. 243-268


pdf iconDownload PDF (68.7 KB)
pp. 269-278

E-ISBN-13: 9780815701866
E-ISBN-10: 0815701861

Page Count: 278
Publication Year: 2008