Acts of Conscience
World War II, Mental Institutions, and Religious Objectors
Publication Year: 2009
Published by: Syracuse University Press
Title Page, Copyright Page
Download PDF (57.5 KB)
Download PDF (56.3 KB)
Download PDF (60.5 KB)
This book was made possible through a research sabbatical granted by Syracuse University in the spring of 2007. Thanks to Dean Doug Biklen for supporting my sabbatical and to Cyndy Colavita, Rachael Zubal-Ruggieri, Pam Walker, Arlene Kanter, Beth Ferri, Perri Harris, Sari Biklen, and Bob Ciota for filling in for me while I was on leave. Rachael and Cyndy also gave me invaluable assistance...
Download PDF (42.5 KB)
Download PDF (70.9 KB)
In the mid- to late 1940s, a group of young men rattled the psychiatric establishment by beaming a public spotlight on the squalid conditions and brutality in our nation’s mental hospitals and training schools for people with psychiatric and intellectual disabilities. They brought about exposés reported in newspapers...
Part One. “We Won’t Murder”
1. “Work of National Importance under Civilian Direction”
Download PDF (144.8 KB)
It was January 1940, and war was on the horizon. In Europe, Germany had invaded Poland the previous September, leading Great Britain and France to declare war against the Nazi regime. Sensing that Nazis and fascists in Europe would only “respect force and force alone,” President Franklin Delano Roosevelt had begun...
2. “Religious Training and Belief”
Download PDF (165.2 KB)
In World War II, 10,110,104 men were drafted into the armed forces.1 At least 37,000 draft-age men were exempted from combatant or military service as conscientious objectors, or COs, under the Selective Training and Service Act. At least 25,000 men served in noncombatant roles in the military under an “I-A-O” draft classification....
3. “An Experiment in Democracy”
Download PDF (170.8 KB)
From the time of his appointment as director of the Selective Service in 1941 until the end of the draft, then brigadier general Lewis Blaine Hershey was a staunch supporter of the Civilian Public Service. The CPS represented a reasonable solution to the “problem” of the CO. On the one hand, the CPS would spare the...
4. “A Significant Epoch in Your Life”
Download PDF (364.5 KB)
Around the time COs received the order to report to the Civilian Public Service from the Selective Service, they received a letter welcoming them from the religious service committee sponsoring the camp to which they had been assigned. COs assigned to Brethren Service Committee camps received a letter from W....
5. “Detached Units”
Download PDF (402.2 KB)
When leaders of the peace churches first contemplated alternative public service, humanitarian projects were high on their list of priorities. The alleviation of human suffering was central to the missions of the Mennonites, Friends, and Brethren....
6. “A Working Compromise Between Church and State”
Download PDF (232.4 KB)
“The B.S.C. recognizes C.P.S. as a limited instrument that is inadequate for the achievement of all ends sought by pacifists,” read the statement on the Civilian Public Service by the Brethren Service Committee. The statement continued: “We consider C.P.S. further as a working compromise between church and state—the...
Part Two: “A Lasting Contribution in the Field”
7. “Out of Sight, Out of Mind”
Download PDF (116.9 KB)
In her popular “My Day” column published in newspapers across the country on July 22, 1947, Eleanor Roosevelt, wife of deceased president Franklin Delano Roosevelt, gave a glowing endorsement of a recent book: “A book that everyone should read is ‘Out of Sight, Out of Mind,’ by Frank L. Wright, Jr.” The book, which described conditions...
8. “A Mind That Found Itself”
Download PDF (171.8 KB)
Throughout its brief history, the National Mental Health Foundation, which had been founded by young COs, had an ambivalent relationship with the well-established and respectable National Committee for Mental Hygiene. On the one hand, the COs’ Mental Hygiene Program of the Civilian Public Service, the predecessor...
9. “They Asked for a Hard Job”
Download PDF (481.2 KB)
Frank Olmstead was fieldwork director of the War Resisters League and a frequent critic of the Civilian Public Service, the National Service Board for Religious Objectors, and the church committees administering camps and units. He had visited many CPS work camps and written a critical report in November 1942...
10. “Bughousers” and “Conchies”
Download PDF (284.8 KB)
Mental hospitals and training schools had been short-staffed on the wards prior to the war, but faced critical staff shortages once the war started. Many young men working as attendants were drafted into the military. Of those men who were not drafted, many, both men and women, took higher-paying jobs in industry and...
11. “The Exposé as a Progressive Tool”
Download PDF (247.1 KB)
The origins of Out of Sight, Out of Mind can be traced to the beginning of special service units at mental hospitals and training schools. Many COs were shocked by institutional conditions and dismayed by the treatment of patients. They told others about what they had observed at the institutions. Some went public with...
12. “They Were Fighting Everybody”
Download PDF (273.8 KB)
Four Byberry COs created a national movement to reform state mental hospitals and training schools and forced established organizations, including the National Committee for Mental Hygiene and the American Psychiatric Association, to take actions to address the plight of people languishing at America’s institutions.1 Len...
13. “Mental Hospitals Are Again under Fire”
Download PDF (167.4 KB)
The mid- to late 1940s was a difficult time for state institutions. They were barraged by a series of exposés and attacks. COs, literally outsiders to mental hygiene and psychiatry, brought public attention to conditions at individual institutions and eventually to the entire institutional system. The Life magazine and...
14. “Another Growing Pain”
Download PDF (301.2 KB)
The spring of 1946 should have been an exciting, even heady time for the founders of the National Mental Health Foundation. What had started as an off-duty project by a small handful of Byberry COs had evolved into a formidable national reform movement. Life magazine and PM newspaper had featured stories based...
15. “Scandal Results in Real Reforms”
Download PDF (313.2 KB)
The November 12, 1951, issue of Life magazine published another article by Albert Q. Maisel on state mental hospitals. This time the news was positive: “Scandal Results in Real Reforms.” Maisel reviewed the exposés of the mid-1940s and argued that they had made a concrete difference: “Five years ago shock and revulsion...
Download PDF (126.0 KB)
All history is told from a point of view. As Laurel Richardson argued, any form of knowledge is “partial and situated.” What we know about the world necessarily reflects the information we have at our disposal as well as our own social situations and past experiences. Richardson wrote, “There is no view from ‘nowhere,’...
Download PDF (69.8 KB)
Download PDF (287.6 KB)
Download PDF (133.1 KB)
Download PDF (80.3 KB)
Download PDF (101.1 KB)
Page Count: 504
Illustrations: 50 black and white illustrations
Publication Year: 2009