We cannot verify your location
Browse Book and Journal Content on Project MUSE

Whose Revolution Was it?

Historians Interpret the Founding

Alfred Young, Gregory Nobles, 0

Publication Year: 2011

Published by: NYU Press

Title Page, Copyright Page

pdf iconDownload PDF (59.0 KB)

read more


pdf iconDownload PDF (80.9 KB)
pp. 1-12

Whose American Revolution Was It? speaks to the different ways Americans at the time of the Revolution might have answered this question and to the different ways historians in the twentieth and twenty-first centuries have interpreted the Revolution for our own time. On one level, the answer to the question in either era might seem...

read more

American Historians Confront “The Transforming Hand of Revolution”

pdf iconDownload PDF (59.1 KB)
pp. 13-16

In August 1926 Charles A. Beard published an enthusiastic review of John Franklin Jameson’s book The American Revolution Considered as a Social Movement in the New Republic. Jameson sent him a warm letter of appreciation and clarifi cation, and Beard responded with even more lavish praise...

read more

I. J. Franklin Jameson

pdf iconDownload PDF (118.0 KB)
pp. 16-35

The Jameson thesis is disarming in its simplicity, as is the form of the book: four short lectures, no more than thirty thousand words, the equivalent today of a hefty journal article, without footnotes, without a bibliographic essay, and with only hints within the text as to the evidence he was drawing on...

read more

II. Progressives and Counter-Progressives

pdf iconDownload PDF (231.6 KB)
pp. 35-78

To enter the domain of historiography one has to pass through the thorny thicket in which scholars are sorted out by “schools.” The dangers in such exercises have been persistently deplored by scholars of almost all persuasions. Jameson’s lament to Beard...

read more

III. New Left , New Social History

pdf iconDownload PDF (165.9 KB)
pp. 78-105

Among historians there were two New Lefts: the first around Studies on the Left (1959 – 67), a journal founded by graduate students in history at the University of Wisconsin associated with William Appleman Williams and the “radicalism of disclosure,” the second, beginning later in the 1960s, associated with Staughton Lynd and Jesse Lemisch...

read more

IV. Synthesis

pdf iconDownload PDF (197.6 KB)
pp. 105-138

In 1949, when I started to prepare for my Ph.D. exam at Northwestern University, I began a loose-leaf notebook, devoting a page to each important scholar in early American history I assumed I was responsible for: Henry Adams, Andrews, Bancroft , Becker, Beer, Beard, through Gipson, Jameson, Perry Miller, Morison,...

read more

Historians Extend the Reach of the American Revolution

pdf iconDownload PDF (54.3 KB)
pp. 139-142

Could the study of the American Revolution ever be over? It may have seemed that way to some historians attending the annual meeting of the Organization of American Historians — held, quite appropriately, in Boston — on a late Friday aft ernoon in March 2004...

read more

I. Refocusing on the Founders

pdf iconDownload PDF (79.1 KB)
pp. 142-149

Some the most familiar faces have found renewed life in the new century, and they now invite careful scrutiny in the context of the times, both their own and ours. One compelling indication of the continuing interest in the Revolution is an outburst of biographical studies of the Founders, quite a few of which became sudden...

read more

II. Redefining Freedom in the Revolution

pdf iconDownload PDF (164.4 KB)
pp. 150-178

John Hope Franklin, in a 2006 ceremony at the Library of Congress honoring his long and distinguished career as a pioneering scholar of African American history, spoke of his personal confrontation with a fundamental issue that lies at the heart of the American Revolution: “I have struggled to understand how it is that we could fight...

read more

III. Facing the Revolution from Indian Country

pdf iconDownload PDF (131.0 KB)
pp. 179-200

At the beginning of the twenty-first century, Daniel Richter challenged early American historians to do what he and other scholars of Native Americans had been doing for years: to look at the colonial and Revolutionary eras by “facing east from Indian country.” Making that simple-seeming shift in perspective had important implications...

read more

IV. Reconsidering Class in the American Revolution

pdf iconDownload PDF (184.7 KB)
pp. 200-233

To talk about “White Americans” as the winning side raises another question about historical perspective, this one largely internal to white society itself. The near-monolithic identity implicit in the term might well make sense when we consider, as Native Americans...

read more

V. Writing Women into the Revolution

pdf iconDownload PDF (188.6 KB)
pp. 233-265

In 2005, a ballroom-full of scholars in Philadelphia at the annual meeting of the Society for Historians of the Early American Republic (SHEAR) turned their attention from discussing events that happened two centuries ago to reflect on a significant phenomenon only a quarter century...

read more


pdf iconDownload PDF (78.3 KB)
pp. 266-273

If J. Franklin Jameson were alive again today, he might well want to revise his metaphor for the American Revolution. It may still be fine to say, as he did in 1925, that the “stream of revolution, once started, could not be confined within narrow banks, but spread abroad upon the land,” but even that image hardly captures...

read more


pdf iconDownload PDF (43.2 KB)
pp. 274-275

The authors are greatly indebted to our editor at NYU Press, Deborah Gershenowitz, for her wise counsel, reassurance, and good cheer, particularly in the latter stages of writing. Gabrielle Begue very helpfully managed the manuscript at the press...


pdf iconDownload PDF (1.3 MB)
pp. 276-295

About the Authors

pdf iconDownload PDF (37.9 KB)
p. 296-296

E-ISBN-13: 9780814789124
E-ISBN-10: 0814789129
Print-ISBN-13: 9780814797105
Print-ISBN-10: 0814797105

Page Count: 304
Publication Year: 2011

Research Areas


UPCC logo

Subject Headings

  • United States -- History -- Revolution, 1775-1783 -- Historiography.
  • United States -- History -- Revolution, 1775-1783 -- Influence
  • United States -- History -- Revolution, 1775-1783 -- Social aspects.
  • You have access to this content
  • Free sample
  • Open Access
  • Restricted Access