-
Selected Bibliography
- University of Pennsylvania Press
- Chapter
- Additional Information
Selected Bibliography SOURCES UNPUBLISHED SOURCES The two central collections of unpublished sources for the study of academic censures at the University of Paris are the Collectw errorum in anglia etparisius condemnatorum , also sometimes referred to in this study as the Collection of Parisian Articles, and the Register that the theologian Noel Beda (c. 1470-1536) compiled ofrecords concerning censures at the University ofParis. The Collectin errorum in anglia etparisius condemnatorum exists in several versions . The short version, which contains the lists of censured views of William of Auvergne (1241), Bishop Tempier (1270 and 1277) , and Robert Kilwardby (1277), has been preserved in more than thirty medieval manuscripts. The oldest of these seems to be Paris, BN lat. 1566I. During the fourteenth century this collection grew Significantly. The number ofcopies, however, ofthis longer Collectin errorum, sometimes referred to as the Collection of Novel Articles (articuli novi, novelli, orposteriores ) , is far smaller. In addition to the censures ofthe shorter version, it also includes the censured views of Nicholas of Autrecourt (1346), John of Mirecourt (1347), John Guyon (1348), Simon (1351), Guido (Giles ofMedonta?) (1354), Louis of Padua (1362), John of Calore (1363), Denis of Foullechat (1369), and John of Monzon (1389). The follOWing manuscripts are known: Auxerre, Bibliotheque municipale 243; Erfurt, B. Amploniana F.179 and Q 151; Munich, Bayrische Staatsbibliothek , Clm 3798, and Clm. 28126; Paris, BN lat. 16553; Rouen, Bibliotheque municipale 587 (A. 263). Separately from the manuscript tradition, there exists an early printed tradition of the Collectin errorum in anglia etparisius condemnatorum. It is often attached to the printed editions of Peter the Lombard's Sentences, for instance in: Venice: Vendelinum de Spira, 1477; Venice, 1480; Venice, 1507 (cum Nic. de Orbellis interpretatwne ) .Itfurther appears in the following editions ofthe Sentences together with the commentary by Henry ofGorichem (Gorkum): Nuremberg, 1478, 1499, 1528; Basel, 1492 [Hain 10197], 1498 [Hain 10198],1502,1507, and 1513; Rouen, 1653; Venice: Simon de Luere, 1506, 1570; Paris: Jean Roigny, 1536, 1550, and Paris: Jean Petit, 1536. To these latter editions can be added: Basel, 1487 [Hain 10192],1488 [Hain 10195], 1489 [Hain 10196]. Moreover, the following separate editions ofthe Collection of Parisian Articles can be mentioned: Articuli Parisius condemnati: Padua: Mathaeus Cerdonis, c. 1485 [no. 2709] ;Articuli inAngliaetParisius condem- 168 Selected Bibliography nati: Paris: Antoine Caillant, c. 1483 [no. 2710]; Cologne: Heinrich Quentell, c. 1488, and c. 1490 [nos. 271 I and 2712]. The numbers refer to the Gesamtkatalog der Wiegendrucke (Leipzig, 1925- ). On October 15, 1523, the faculty oftheology approved Noel Beda's suggestion to compile a survey ofits pronouncements and judgments. Beda's activities resulted in the production of two Registers, namely the Liber primus registri [determinationumJfacultatis theologie schole Parisiensis in materia.fidei et morum incipiens ab anno domini I284 and the Liber secundus registri determinationum ... ab anno domini I524, currendypreserved in Paris, BN ms. nouv. acq.lat. 1826 and ms.lat. 3381-B, respectively . The first register, which is the only one relevant here, covers the period 12101523 . Despite its tide, the first entry is from 1210, not from 1284. Ifone were to look in this register at the documents concerning suspect teaching from the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries, one would find that it contains only some records concerning the censures of John of Brescain (1247), Denis of Foullechat (1369), and John of MonzOn (1389). The register does not reproduce any documents of the censures of Stephen of Venizy (1241), Nicholas of Autrecourt (1346), John of Mirecourt (1347),JohnGuyon (1348), Simon (1351), Guido (GilesofMedonta?) (1354), Louis of Padua (1362), or John of Calore (1363). Nor does it contain Bishop Tempier's condemnations of December 10, 1270, and March 7, 1277. The reason is that the archive of the faculty of theology on which Beda relied when drawing up his Register did not have any documents pertaining to these censures. Almost all the original records that were copied in Beda's Register are still extant in the Archive ofthe University ofParis. The Collectio errorum in angliaetparisius condemnatorum has been lime studied. Manuscripts ofits shorter version are listed in CUP I: 556-57, and in Luca Bianchi, IIvescovo eifilosofi. La condannapariginadel I277 eP~oluzione delParistotelismo scolastico (Bergamo, 1990),207-8 n. 7. See also pp. 25-27 ofthis study for a briefdiscussion ofthe Parisian Articles. This collection is studied and edited in HenrykAnzulewicz, "Eine weitere Uberlieferung der Collectio errorum in Anglia et Parisius condemnatorum im JI.1s. lat. fol. 456 der Staatsbibliothek Preussischer Kulturbesitz zu Berlin;' Franziskanische Studien 74 (1992), 375-99...