The Philosophy of Hegel as a Doctrine of the Concreteness of God and Humanity: Volume One: The Doctrine of God

Table of Page Equivalents for the Lectures on the Philosophy of Religion

299 Table of Page Equivalents for the Lectures on the Philosophy of Religion As Il’in implied in the bibliographic appendix, he evidently used the original 1832 Werke edition of the Lectures on the Philosophy of Religion, edited by Marheineke , as opposed to the 1840 Werke edition also issued under Marheineke’s name, but actually edited by Bruno Bauer. The former is commonly referred to as the W1 edition, and the latter, as the W2 edition. However, after 1840, the W2 edition became the standard one; consequently the original 1832 edition is now very much more difficult to obtain. For the reader’s convenience, I have supplied the page equivalents in the Suhrkamp edition for the W1 references that Il’in made, given that the Suhrkamp edition is the one most widely available. However, because the Suhrkamp edition, like the Glockner Jubiläumsausgabe, reproduces what is basically the W2 edition, there are occasional variations between the 1832 text and these modern ones, even where the page equivalents can be identified more or less accurately. Note: Given that the topic of theodicy is central to Il’in’s commentary, one might expect him to make extensive use of Hegel’s Lectures on the Philosophy of Religion. However, this is not the case; Il’in opines that “Hegel succeeded in giving a well thought-out and mature expression only to the doctrine of human ethical life, and left the systematic doctrine of religion in the form of rough sketches” (chapter 15 of volume 2). On the other hand, Il’in made very extensive use of Hegel’s sixteen “Lectures on the Proofs for the Existence of God” and the three separate essays from 1831 on the proofs (all of which were appended to the second volume of the Lectures on the Philosophy of Religion), as can be seen from the tables below. Lectures on the Philosophy of Religion, Volume One W1 edition Suhrkamp edition (vol. 11) (vol. 16) 56 99–100 57 100–101 75 129 bot.–30 76 130–31 text altered 125 195–96 153 213–14 W1 edition Suhrkamp edition (vol. 11) (vol. 16) 163 233–34 text altered 170 236–37 173 239 bot.–40 text altered 174 240–41 175 241–42 176 242–43 text altered 300 T A B L E O F P A G E E Q U I V A L E N T S W1 edition Suhrkamp edition (vol. 11) (vol. 16) 177 243–44 text altered 179 246 text altered 183 251–52 text inserted W1 edition Suhrkamp edition (vol. 11) (vol. 16) 195 265–66 199 270–71 Lectures on the Philosophy of Religion, Volume Two W1 edition Suhrkamp edition (vol. 12) (vol. 17) 50 63–64 text altered Appendix Vorlesungen Über Die Beweise vom Dasein Gottes* (“Beweise”) W1 edition Suhrkamp edition (vol. 12) (vol. 17) 294 1st Lecture 349–50 296 351–52 297 352–53 300 355–56 301 2nd Lecture 356–57 306 361–62 307 362–63 309 364–65 311 3rd Lecture 366–67 312 367–68 313 368–69 314 369–70 315 370–71 top 316 371–72 top 317 4th Lecture 372 318 373 319 373 bot.–74 320 374–75 321 375–76 322 376–77 324 5th Lecture 378–79 328 382–83 329 383–84 330 384–85 335 6th Lecture 389–90 336 390–91 337 7th Lecture 391–92 339 393–94 341 395–96 342 396–97 W1 edition Suhrkamp edition (vol. 12) (vol. 17) 343 397–98 344 398–99 345 8th Lecture 399–400 top 350 404 351 405–6 top 354 9th Lecture 407–8 356 409 bot.–10 359 10th Lecture 412 bot.–13 360 413 bot.–14 364 417–18 365 418–19 366 419–20 367 420–21 369 The Insertion 422–23 373 426–27 379 432–33 381 434–35 382 435–36 383 436–37 388 441–42 top 389 442–43 top 390 443–44 top 392 445 393 446 top–47 top 395 11th Lecture 448 396 448 bot.–49 397 449 bot.–50 398 450 bot.–51 399 451 bot.–52 400 452 bot.–53 301 T A B L E O F P A G E E Q U I V A L E N T S W1 edition Suhrkamp edition (vol. 12) (vol. 17) 403 12th Lecture 455–56...