Composition and the Rhetoric of Science
Engaging the Dominant Discourse
Publication Year: 2007
Published by: Southern Illinois University Press
Download PDF (88.8 KB)
Title Page, Copyright, Dedication, Quotes
Download PDF (49.7 KB)
Download PDF (34.6 KB)
Download PDF (44.9 KB)
Scientific discourse is a ‘power rhetoric.’ Rhetoric must attend to discourses that matter.” So stated Jack Selzer when he introduced a session on scientific discourse at the 2005 Conference on College Composition and Communication in San Francisco. ...
Download PDF (35.3 KB)
A multiplicity of voices inhabits this book. Friends, colleagues, and mentors who have read and commented on drafts of parts of this work are Michelle Comstock, Bill Hart-Davidson, Tom Moriarty, Tim Peeples, Ed Nagelhout, Graham Smart, Bud Weiser, Janice Lauer, Patricia Harkin, Johndan Johnson-Eilola, ...
Download PDF (110.8 KB)
The publication of The Bell Curve by Richard Herrnstein and Charles Murray in 1994 ignited a firestorm of controversy and, as one might expect, generated a tidal wave of reviews. Essentially, the book’s authors, after extensive study of decades worth of IQ data, concluded that intelligence is determined more by heredity than by environment; ...
Part 1: Contexts and Gateways
1. The Dominance of Scientific Discourse: Theoretical Contexts
Download PDF (128.8 KB)
Generally, scientific discourse can be understood to be the language used (a) to ascertain, describe, and explain the workings of our bodies and our surroundings and (b) to validate the methods used to accomplish these objectives (Kinneavy 78). Scientific discourse is a culturally contingent rhetoric, ...
2. The State of Scientific Discourse in Rhetoric and Composition
Download PDF (221.4 KB)
As they progressed from primary school to more advanced study, students of rhetoric in ancient Greece and Rome de-emphasized other types of texts—most notably works of literature—and began to spend a great deal of time analyzing and composing texts about law. ...
3. Scientific Discourse as a Cultural Studies Issue
Download PDF (129.2 KB)
In the “Truth and Power” interview, Foucault almost off-handedly remarks that a study of scientific dissidence since 1945 needs to be undertaken (69). Offhand or not, Foucault pinpoints a large problem— that dissidence in science is rarely noticed. ...
4. Scientific Discourse as a Literacy Issue
Download PDF (131.0 KB)
We live in a scientific culture; to be scientifically illiterate is simply to be illiterate,” says Harding (Whose Science? 55). The association of science and literacy is well recognized. Contextualizing the study of scientific discourse in terms of literacy focuses attention on its public-ness or lack thereof; ...
Part 2: Texts and Scenarios
5. Popularizations of Science
Download PDF (169.0 KB)
Science popularizations have only recently begun to gain widespread critical attention and to be recognized as important components of the perception and practice of the contemporary cultural institution of science. Their importance is undeniable, even if popularizations are still not universally acclaimed by scientists themselves. ...
6. Scientific Discourse of Another Culture
Download PDF (135.9 KB)
In some of my technical and scientific communication courses, I ask my students to compare Western and non-Western medical discourses in an effort to illuminate Western assumptions about science and medicine. This strategy has proven to be successful, especially when students compared U.S. National Cancer Institute information ...
Download PDF (162.2 KB)
A strategy that can contribute a great deal to a more sophisticated understanding of scientific discourse as a cultural phenomenon and promote an ideological scientific literacy is to study some of the scientific research article genre’s classics and attempt to determine why these texts command such wide respect. ...
8. You Are What Science Says You Are
Download PDF (109.5 KB)
One of the most effective and immediate ways for students to learn how science constructs individual identity is for them to study what science says about them in particular. For this purpose, social science studies of college students can demonstrate what kinds of questions are being asked ...
Download PDF (46.8 KB)
Some 2,500 years ago, an anonymous Sophist wisely observed that “It belongs to the same man to be politician, speaker, scientist” (Freeman 162). I didn’t know that until I was in my mid twenties. Earlier, when I was an undergraduate chemistry major, I took English classes for fun—a break, I thought, ...
Download PDF (101.2 KB)
Download PDF (116.6 KB)
Download PDF (88.8 KB)
Author Bio, Back Cover
Download PDF (216.2 KB)
Michael J. Zerbe teaches rhetoric, composition, and professional writing and editing courses at York College of Pennsylvania, where he is an assistant professor of English and humanities. He is the recipient of a Health Communications Fellowship from the National Cancer Institute in Bethesda, Maryland, ...
Page Count: 272
Publication Year: 2007