The Allotment Plot
Alice C. Fletcher, E. Jane Gay, and Nez Perce Survivance
Publication Year: 2012
The Allotment Plot reexamines the history of allotment on the Nez Perce Reservation from 1889 to 1892 to account for and emphasize the Nez Perce side of the story. By including Nez Perce responses to allotment, Nicole Tonkovich argues that the assimilationist aims of allotment ultimately failed due in large part to the agency of the Nez Perce people themselves throughout the allotment process. The Nez Perce were actively involved in negotiating the terms under which allotment would proceed and simultaneously engaged in ongoing efforts to protect their stories and other cultural properties from institutional appropriation by the allotment agent, Alice C. Fletcher, who was a respected anthropologist, and her photographer and assistant, E. Jane Gay. The Nez Perce engagement in this process laid a foundation for the long-term survival of the tribe and its culture.
Making use of previously unknown archival sources, Fletcher’s letters, Gay’s photographs and journalistic accounts, oral tribal histories, and analyses of performances such as parades and verbal negotiations, Tonkovich assembles a masterful portrait of Nez Perce efforts to control their own future and provides a vital counternarrative of the allotment period, which is often portrayed as disastrous to Native polities.
Published by: University of Nebraska Press
List of Illustrations
Download PDF (46.1 KB)
Download PDF (46.1 KB)
Since the early eighteenth century the federal government of the United States of America has exercised a unilateral and presumptive right to manage the sovereign Native groups classified by the Marshall Supreme Court in 1831 as “domestic dependent nations...
Download PDF (53.4 KB)
This book owes its existence to a network of generous researchers, archivists, and friends. Three deserve special thanks, for they shared with me large numbers of primary sources that they had gathered and processed. At the very beginning of this undertaking, while...
Introduction: Allotment and Nimiipuu Survivance
Download PDF (830.4 KB)
In late June 1890, during the second of four summers devoted to assigning lands in severalty to the Nez Perces, Alice C. Fletcher, the government allotting agent, posed for a photograph with Chief Joseph and James Stuart, her interpreter. Segments of this...
Part One. Beginnings
Introduction: After the End of Nez Perce History
Download PDF (223.4 KB)
Presbyterian missionary George L. Deffenbaugh found the celebration held on 4 July 1885 at the Nez Perce Agency in Lapwai, Idaho, to be a notable one. In his annual report to the commissioner of Indian affairs, Deffenbaugh remarked on “the absence of the...
1. A False Beginning
Download PDF (176.7 KB)
By the end of the nineteenth century the rationalized extension of 160- acre individually owned homesteads into western territories seemed to demand that Native lands, enclosed in reservations thought to be too generously sized, should be similarly apportioned. In...
2. Another Beginning
Download PDF (307.6 KB)
A week or so after the meeting at the Kamiah Presbyterian Church, Fletcher announced she would establish a base camp in the field where she would meet allottees upon their lands and finalize their deeds. The allotting party — Fletcher, Gay, James...
Part Two. Land
Introduction: Map and Territory, Space and Place
Download PDF (71.6 KB)
In January 1890 Commissioner of Indian Affairs Thomas Jefferson Morgan declared that “pupils” in federally supported Indian schools “should understand the significance of national holidays and be permitted to enjoy them.” He listed eight such...
3. “The Square Idea”
Download PDF (909.4 KB)
The presence of Alice Fletcher, a lame, middle-aged white woman in smoked glasses and a flower-trimmed bonnet sitting under an umbrella in her wagon on the southwestern border of the Nez Perce Reservation, signaled that the federal expeditions undertaken...
4. Ethnographic Knowledge and Native Cartography
Download PDF (652.1 KB)
As she prepared to return to Idaho for her second summer’s work in 1890, Fletcher was intent upon giving more attention to her ethnological investigations. Such work was, to her way of thinking, entirely congruent with her allotting duties. However, as...
Part Three. Citizens
Introduction: E Pluribus Unum
Download PDF (67.5 KB)
In early July 1890 Idaho Territory stood poised to enter the union as the forty-third state. The process by which territories become states is intended to produce uniformity in the land and its inhabitants. The Ordinance of 1785 mandated that territorial possessions...
5. Technologies of Citizenship
Download PDF (313.2 KB)
On 3 July 1890, having demonstrated that its citizens could overcome their differences sufficiently to perform the functions of democratic self-rule, Idaho became a state. With duly elected representatives to stand for their interests in the legislative assemblies...
6. Fictions of Coherence
Download PDF (147.0 KB)
While Alice Fletcher and Jane Gay expected the Nez Perces to be consistently predictable in their behaviors, Gay’s accounts of the allotment expedition present herself and Fletcher in multiple guises. The Photographer, the Cook, the friend, and “I” keep company...
Part Four. Endings
Introduction: “If the Work Is Ever to Be Finished”
Download PDF (51.9 KB)
Having left the reservation early in October 1890 after abbreviating her second field season, Alice Fletcher returned to Idaho earlier than was her wont, in April 1891, hoping to complete the allotment so she could turn her full attention to the research she could...
7. Irresolutions and Incompletions
Download PDF (560.0 KB)
Were the accounts written by Jane Gay to be taken as fully accurate representations of events on the Nez Perce Reservation, Independence Day in Lapwai in 1891 might be seen as the end of traditional celebrations of that occasion. Wishing to emphasize the emergence...
8. The Ends of Nez Perce Allotment
Download PDF (196.5 KB)
The complexity of such deceptively simple terms as end and allotment becomes apparent as one seeks to establish the event or events that might be taken as the conclusion of Fletcher’s work. Endings, a convention of storytelling, are not always apparent within...
Part Five. Afterward
Introduction: “Double Pictures Have Met Us All along the Way”
Download PDF (250.8 KB)
In early July 1903, Independence Day was observed in Kamiah, Lapwai, and Nespelem as it had been for decades past. The celebration in Kamiah seemed to exemplify the success of the recently completed allotment. Here about a thousand celebrants...
Download PDF (306.9 KB)
In the early twentieth century Nez Perces supplemented their performances with the technology of voice recording as a way of preserving their histories and transmitting the old ways to generations to follow. At the Fourth of July celebration in Lapwai in...
Download PDF (1.5 MB)
Although federal officials made little or no response to the Memorial of the Nez Perce Indians . . . to the Congress of the United States, it has since become a cornerstone of Nimiipuu cultural history. Copies of the document were printed under Borah’s sponsorship...
Download PDF (369.8 KB)
Download PDF (146.3 KB)
Download PDF (85.8 KB)
Page Count: 440
Illustrations: 62 illustrations, 10 maps, 1 table
Publication Year: 2012