Learning from the Other
Levinas, Psychoanalysis, and Ethical Possibilities in Education
Publication Year: 2003
Published by: State University of New York Press
Title Page, Copyright Page
Download PDF (26.8 KB)
Download PDF (93.2 KB)
This book has been written across many continents and time zones, each place having contributed something unique to my experience of writing in situated contexts. In addition to what I have learned from these experiences, my colleagues, friends, and students have had the most impact on the form and content of my ideas. First and foremost, I thank Deborah Britzman, not only for...
INTRODUCTION: Learning from the Other: A Question of Ethics, a Question for Education
Download PDF (163.2 KB)
What, or where, is ethics in relation to education? Ethics, insofar as it potentially offers us a discourse for rethinking our relations to other people, is central to any education that takes seriously issues of social justice. It seems crucial, then, that any philosophical investigation into the ethical possibilities of education—which is how I characterize this present work—cannot only not...
ONE: “Bringing More than I Contain”: On Ethics, Curriculum, and Learning to Become
Download PDF (189.5 KB)
We read Simon Wiesenthal's The Sunflower in a graduate seminar I teach on ethics and education.1 The central story consists of a grueling meeting that Wiesenthal has with a dying member of the Nazi Schutzstaffel (SS) while himself an inmate in a concentration camp.The SS man, Karl, has asked that a Jewish prisoner be brought to him so that he may be granted forgiveness...
TWO: Being-for or Feeling-for? Empathic Demands and Disruptions
Download PDF (157.9 KB)
Empathy is often invoked in social justice educational discourse and practice as an indispensable emotion for working across differences. As Megan Boler writes: “in the last fifteen years in Western ‘multiculturalism,’ empathy is promoted as a bridge between differences, the affective reason for engaging in democratic dialogue with the other.”1 The idea is that the more...
THREE: A Risky Commitment: The Ambiguity and Ambivalence of Love
Download PDF (188.6 KB)
What do love and eros1 have to offer a discussion on the ethical possibilities of education? In considering the work across differences that social justice education engages in, how might that most seemingly private of emotions, love, lend itself to such work? Does eros have anything to do with learning from and not merely about the Other? These questions are by no...
FOUR: Strangely Innocent? Guilt, Suffering, and Responsibility
Download PDF (171.6 KB)
In classrooms dealing with traumatic histories of injustice or with the troubling violence and inequities that continue to mark everyday life in this new millennium, guilt often surfaces, persistently and indelibly, as a relation between the stories of suffering being retold and those who listen to their retelling. The fact that guilt is so commonplace in accounts of...
FIVE: Listening as an Attentiveness to “Dense Plots”
Download PDF (164.9 KB)
“Sometimes I forget I have a face.” The quote comes from Maggie Cogan, the title subject of Michel Negroponte’s documentary film Jupiter’s Wife.1 The film chronicles the filmmaker’s relationship with Maggie, a homeless woman living in Central Park, over the course of two years. It is a powerful portrayal of the nature of listening in responding to the Other—a relation...
POSTSCRIPT: Where Are Ethical Possibilities?
Download PDF (106.7 KB)
This book has been a consideration of ethical possibilities as they exist as modes of relationality across difference in education. In my discussions of empathy, love, guilt, and listening, I have argued for an understanding of ethics that refuses to locate responsibility within a rational, autonomous subject but in the very forms of relationality that structure our encounters with...
Download PDF (194.4 KB)
Download PDF (132.9 KB)
Download PDF (105.0 KB)
Page Count: 188
Publication Year: 2003
Series Title: SUNY series, Second Thoughts: New Theoretical Formations