We cannot verify your location
Browse Book and Journal Content on Project MUSE

From Villain to Hero

Odysseus in Ancient Thought

Silvia Montiglio

Publication Year: 2011

Praise for Silvia Montiglio "[A] brilliant and important book. . . . " ---Journal of Religion, on Silence in the Land of Logos "[A]n invigorating reevaluation of both the ancient symbolic landscape and our preconceptions of it." ---American Journal of Philology, on Wandering in Ancient Greek Culture Best known for his adventures during his homeward journey as narrated in Homer's Odyssey, Odysseus remained a major figure and a source of inspiration in later literature, from Greek tragedy to Dante's Inferno to Joyce's Ulysses. Less commonly known, but equally interesting, are Odysseus' "wanderings" in ancient philosophy: Odysseus becomes a model of wisdom for Socrates and his followers, Cynics and Stoics, as well as for later Platonic thinkers. From Villain to Hero: Odysseus in Ancient Thought follows these wanderings in the world of ancient Greek and Roman philosophy, retracing the steps that led the cunning hero of Homeric epic and the villain of Attic tragedy to become a paradigm of the wise man. From Villain to Hero explores the reception of Odysseus in philosophy, a subject that so far has been treated only in tangential or limited ways. Diverging from previous studies, Montiglio outlines the philosophers' Odysseus across the spectrum, from the Socratics to the Middle Platonists. By the early centuries CE, Odysseus' credentials as a wise man are firmly established, and the start of Odysseus' rehabilitation by philosophers challenges current perceptions of him as a villain. More than merely a study in ancient philosophy, From Villain to Hero seeks to understand the articulations between philosophical readings of Odysseus and nonphilosophical ones, with an eye to the larger cultural contexts of both. While this book is the work of a classicist, it will also be of interest to students of philosophy, comparative literature, and reception studies.

Published by: University of Michigan Press


pdf iconDownload PDF (25.1 KB)
pp. vii


pdf iconDownload PDF (22.0 KB)
pp. ix

read more


pdf iconDownload PDF (160.7 KB)
pp. 1-19

The philosopher: such is the name the twelfth-century Byzantine bishop Eustathius time and again gives Odysseus.1 The man of many turns, the most versatile of all Greek heroes both in Homeric epic and in his later incarnations, by the twelfth century could also boast of a long journey across philosophy, and one that was bound to continue, down through the ages, even to the modern world...

read more

Chapter One: “Odysseus was not . . .”: Antisthenes’ Defense of an Abused Hero

pdf iconDownload PDF (171.1 KB)
pp. 20-37

Our inquiry begins with Antisthenes (circa 445–365 BC), Socrates’ disciple, to whom we owe the first extensive endorsement of Odysseus’ actions and character. Antisthenes probably inherited his appreciation for Odysseus from his teacher. Socrates’ admiration for Odysseus indeed cannot be doubted,1 and in a later period was contrasted with Anytus’, his accuser’s, negative view of the...

read more

Chapter Two: Plato’s Odysseus: A Soldier in the Soul

pdf iconDownload PDF (209.7 KB)
pp. 38-65

The dialogue begins as a discussion between Socrates and the Sophit Hippias over the characters of Achilles and Odysseus. Asked which one is the better hero and how he distinguishes them, Hippias states that Achilles is "the best"...

read more

Chapter Three: Yearning for Excellence: Odysseus in Cynic and Stoic Thought

pdf iconDownload PDF (190.9 KB)
pp. 66-94

We now step onto more familiar territory: Odysseus in his Cynic and Stoic garb is a well-known figure to readers acquainted with the hero’s reception in antiquity. If we believe the available sources, Diogenes, the father of the Cynic movement, was an enthusiastic admirer of Odysseus. The same is likely to be true for Zeno, the founder of the Stoa, of whom we know that he wrote five books of...

read more

Chapter Four: King, Friend, and Flatterer: Odysseus in Epicureanism and Beyond

pdf iconDownload PDF (192.5 KB)
pp. 95-123

Is, then, Seneca correct to say that the Epicureans applauded Odysseus for “praising the condition of a state at peace where life is spent in feasting and song?” Other sources maintain that they unfairly exploited Odysseus’ eulogy of feasting in Odyssey 9 to uphold their theory of the supremacy of pleasure. For instance, the allegorist Heraclitus (Hom. Probl. 79.2–3) argues that Epicurus stole...

read more

Chapter Five: Between Contemplation and Action

pdf iconDownload PDF (189.8 KB)
pp. 124-147

The image of a moralized Odysseus gained in publicity toward the end of the first century BC: witness Virgil’s reliance on it in the Aeneid to describe the charismatic leader who quiets the storm; Horace’s mocking exploitation of the same image in his Satires to portray the type of the legacy-hunter; and his endorsement of it in his “pedagogic” Ep. 1.2. Perhaps the most telling indication of the popularity of an...

read more

Epilogue: Odysseus’ Virtus and Thirst for Knowledge in the Renaissance

pdf iconDownload PDF (105.9 KB)
pp. 148-156

Echoes of the ancient discussion over Odysseus’ drive to contemplation in relationship to his duties in the world are heard again in the allegorical interpretation of the Odyssey offered in the sixteenth century by the French scholar Jean Dorat, who taught the poets Pierre de Ronsard and Joachim Du Bellay and quite likely influenced their own treatments of Odysseus (the best known of which...


pdf iconDownload PDF (259.5 KB)
pp. 157-200


pdf iconDownload PDF (127.3 KB)
pp. 201-211


pdf iconDownload PDF (69.7 KB)
pp. 213-228

E-ISBN-13: 9780472027507
E-ISBN-10: 0472027506
Print-ISBN-13: 9780472117741
Print-ISBN-10: 0472117742

Publication Year: 2011