We cannot verify your location
Browse Book and Journal Content on Project MUSE

Harmony and the Balance

An Intellectual History of Seventeenth-Century English Economic Thought

Andrea Finkelstein

Publication Year: 2000

Frequently the achievements of pioneering economic writers are assessed by imposing contemporary theories of markets, econ-omics, politics, and history. At last, here is a book that appraises the work of the leading English economic writers of the seventeenth century using intellectual concepts of the time, rather than present-day analytical models, in order to place their economic theories in context. In an analysis that tracks the Stuart century, Andrea Finkelstein traces the progress of such figures as Gerard de Malynes, William Petty, John Locke, and Charles Davenant by inviting us into the great trading companies and halls of parliament where we relive the debates over the coinage, the interest rate, and the nature of money. Furthermore, we see them model their works on the latest developments in physiology, borrow ideas from bookkeeping, and argue over the nature of numbers in an effort to construct a market theory grounded in objective moral value. This comprehensive approach clarifies the relationship between the century's economic ideas and its intellectual thought so that, in the end, readers will be able to judge for themselves whether this really was the age of the Capitalist Geist. Finkelstein has crafted her book to be both inclusive and interdisciplinary by skillfully integrating biography, political history, economic history, and intellectual theory as well as the economic heritage of its subjects. While the concepts are far from simple, Finkelstein's adroit style presents her analysis in an extremely accessible manner. Andrea Finkelstein is Assistant Professor of History, City University of New York.

Published by: University of Michigan Press


pdf iconDownload PDF (48.6 KB)
pp. vii-viii


pdf iconDownload PDF (24.9 KB)
pp. ix

read more


pdf iconDownload PDF (90.4 KB)
pp. 1-12

The importance of the work done in seventeenth-century England to the development of modern economic thought has long been acknowledged, but studies of this work invariably end in verdicts of “confusion” and “inconsistency.” To take but one example: John Maynard Keynes credited John Locke (1632–1704) with “twin” quantity theories of money but ...

Part I. Geist vs. Weltanschauung

read more

1. Merchants and the Body Politic

pdf iconDownload PDF (89.4 KB)
pp. 15-25

The spirit, or Geist, presumed to animate the marketplace has long had a bad press. The citizens of ancient Athens feared its contagion so much they banned its practitioners from setting foot in the Agora (the square where the political assembly was held) unless summoned by the magistrate.1 When Cato recommended disposing of elderly slaves as one did worn-out oxen2...

read more

2. Gerard de Malynes: Institutio Mercatoris Christiani

pdf iconDownload PDF (167.3 KB)
pp. 26-53

Gerard de Malynes (fl.1586–1626) was a slightly older contemporary of Sir Francis Bacon (1561–1626) and William Shakespeare (1564–1616). A merchant, an autodidact, and a part-time spy, his was a mercantile career shaped by the cutthroat nature of Elizabethan commerce. But when his first two books, A Treatise of the Canker of England’s Commonwealth and St....

read more

3. Edward Misselden and the "Natural Freedom" of Trade

pdf iconDownload PDF (129.0 KB)
pp. 54-73

Edward Misselden (fl. 1608–1654) is known to posterity for two books, Free Trade, or the Means to Make Trade Flourish (1622) and The Circle of Commerce (1623), in which he crossed metaphors with Gerard de Malynes over the true cause of England’s trade “crisis” and took up arms for the “Balance of Trade” and against the par pro pari as the First Commandment of commerce ...

read more

4. Thomas Mun and the Finite Zeitgeist

pdf iconDownload PDF (107.0 KB)
pp. 74-88

Thomas Mun (1571–1641), like his associate Edward Misselden, is known to posterity for two books, A Discourse of Trade, from England unto the EastIndies (1621) and Englands Treasure by Forraign Trade (posthumously published in 1664), in which seemingly opposing economic views are espoused. While the first book was simply too much like the common run of ...

read more

5. Harmony and the "Balance of Trade"

pdf iconDownload PDF (75.4 KB)
pp. 89-97

In the first third of the seventeenth century, merchants routinely accepted that one nation’s gain must come at another nation’s loss. How could it be otherwise in a world of finite resources anchoring a closed universe? And, as usual, the personal formed the model for the political.“ Covetousness,” as St.Thomas Aquinas explained, was “a sin directly against one’s ...

Part 2. The New Model Economics

read more

6. Mechanically Minded

pdf iconDownload PDF (66.1 KB)
pp. 101-106

The central decades of the seventeenth century were tumultuous ones for England. Rebellions in Scotland, Ireland, and England fused into a civil war that did not so much end with the execution of Charles I in January 1649 as transform into an unsuccessful eleven-year experiment in republican government. These same decades witnessed an unprecedented ...

read more

7. The Number, Weight, and Measure of Sir William Petty

pdf iconDownload PDF (148.0 KB)
pp. 107-129

Sir William Petty was a pioneer in the application of the new mechanico-physiological model of the body and its emerging mathematical method to the realm of economic ideas. He explored the concepts of division of labor, national income, velocity of circulation, the multiplier, and the components of value, albeit with uneven success, a century before Adam Smith explored...

read more

8. Sir Josiah Child: What Price Money?

pdf iconDownload PDF (111.2 KB)
pp. 130-146

Sir William Petty (1623–1687) and Sir Josiah Child (1630–1699) both came from minor mercantile families. Each, measured by the wealth he left behind, proved to be an excellent businessman. But, whereas Petty pushed himself out of those limited socio-intellectual confines into the ranks of the scientific innovators and the landowning elite, Child stayed closer to home,...

read more

9. John Locke: Nineteen Shillings do not a Pound make

pdf iconDownload PDF (149.8 KB)
pp. 147-170

John Locke’s monetary works present us with a split economic personality: a man who tried to use arguments for a market-determined interest rate to prove the necessity of reinstating a statutory monetary standard that had been ignored by the marketplace for over two decades, who believed solutions derived from a stagnant economy applied to an inflationary one, and...

read more

10. Accounting for Economics

pdf iconDownload PDF (65.0 KB)
pp. 171-176

Sometimes supporting and sometimes in competition with the mechanical philosophy was the mathematical orientation of the century’s intellectual revolution. This orientation, however, was itself subject to contradictory pulls as the century’s philosophers tried to decide if the essence of mathematical thinking (and of thought itself ) was deductive or inductive ...

Part 3. Balance vs. Equilibrium

read more

11. In the Balance

pdf iconDownload PDF (70.0 KB)
pp. 179-185

By midcentury the doctrine that the nation’s economic health was in jeopardy whenever imports exceeded exports was so fimly accepted that a massive political overhaul of the realm from monarchy to republic and back again could not dislodge it. The “Instructions to the Council of Trade” in 1650 required its members to consider of some way that a most exact account be kept of all ...

read more

12. Sir Dudley North: Merchants and Markets

pdf iconDownload PDF (124.5 KB)
pp. 186-204

There is no doubt that Dudley North relied more on self-regulating principles in his economic arguments than had any English writer before him. He could demonstrate the effect of changes in the interest rate on the price of land and changes in the price of produce on the rent land could command. But he also insisted that falling rents were not the cause of falling...

read more

13. Nicholas Barbon and the Quality of Infinity

pdf iconDownload PDF (103.3 KB)
pp. 205-218

The century’s most radical attack on balance of trade theory came not from the merchant class per se, but from a physician turned builder whose activities straddled the worlds of science and commerce. Whereas Thomas Munand Josiah Child had stressed the difficulties in constructing an accurate balance and the need to distinguish between bilateral and overall balances,...

read more

14. Charles Davenant and the Brave New World

pdf iconDownload PDF (165.3 KB)
pp. 219-246

Charles Davenant’s work presents us with our final variation on the efforts of seventeenth-century English writers to create a science of economics in support of their inherited value system. But Davenant’s chief concern was less with the values of the marketplace itself than with preventing those values from infecting society as a whole. He lived through a key ...

read more


pdf iconDownload PDF (122.3 KB)
pp. 247-266

One of the longest-running disagreements in the interpretative literature concerns who among these nine authors deserves to be considered a fore-runner of laissez-faire liberalism and who was simply some variety of mercantilist. E. A. J. Johnson saw Mun and Misselden as liberals, but Sir Eric Roll moved them (along with Malynes and Petty) into the mercantilist ...


pdf iconDownload PDF (491.6 KB)
pp. 267-343


pdf iconDownload PDF (156.3 KB)
pp. 345-364


pdf iconDownload PDF (115.5 KB)
pp. 365-381

E-ISBN-13: 9780472023844
E-ISBN-10: 0472023845
Print-ISBN-13: 9780472111435
Print-ISBN-10: 0472111434

Page Count: 392
Publication Year: 2000