First the Seed
The Political Economy of Plant Biotechnology
Publication Year: 2004
1988 Cloth, 1990 Paperback, Cambridge University Press
Winner of the Theodore Saloutos Award of the Agricultural History Society
Winner of the Robert K. Merton Award of the American Sociological Association
Published by: University of Wisconsin Press
Title Page, Copyright
List of tables
Download PDF (81.7 KB)
List of figures
Download PDF (26.8 KB)
Preface to the second edition
Download PDF (26.5 KB)
Sixteen years after the initial publication of First the Seed, I am presented with the opportunity to revisit my work and evaluate it against the backdrop of subsequent events. I find I am both pleased and disappointed. I am pleased by the accuracy with which I limned the historical trajectories that were shaping the development and the deployment...
Preface to the first edition
Download PDF (268.4 KB)
It is only March 8, but I planted today. It has been one of the mildest winters on record here in Wisconsin. Warmed by the heat reflecting off the stone facade of my house, the soil in my south-facing front garden has already thawed...
Download PDF (94.3 KB)
It is with mingled senses of relief and pleasure that I complete tis book. It is the fruit of a project begun some four years ago as a graduate student at Cornell University. In my work at Cornell I was fortunate to have had the advice...
Lists of abbreviations
Download PDF (25.3 KB)
Download PDF (1.3 MB)
This book is a political and economic history of what has been one of the most fundamental of humanity's "productive organs": plant biotechnology. Whatever the historical period, whatever the mode ofproduction, plants and their products have been necessary components...
2. Science, agriculture, and social change
Download PDF (2.1 MB)
Before moving on to the historical matter that constitutes the greater part of First the Seed, it is useful to treat a number of thematic elements more completely than was possible in Chapter I. This chapter provides an elaboration of the theoretical framework that informs my interpretation of the historical and contemporary records...
3. The genetic foundation of American agriculture
Download PDF (1.2 MB)
It is said that an army travels on its stomach. Ultimately we all travel - and live or die - on our stomachs, and this is, of course, no less true of the first European settlers in what was to become the United States than it is of us today. An adequate food supply was the material prerequisite for the establishment of a permanent...
4. Public science ascendant: plant breeding comes of age
Download PDF (1.8 MB)
The eighteenth and nineteenth centuries saw the development of a plant genetic foundation on which American agriculture could successfully expand. This was accomplished principally through the appropriation of plant germplasm from other parts of the globe...
5. Heterosis and the social division of labor
Download PDF (2.8 MB)
The development of hybrid corn has long been regarded as the supreme achievement of public agricultural science. Given Soviet premier Nikita Khrushchev's 1958 visit to hybrid seed-corn producer Roswell Garst's Iowa farm, and his plans for a Soviet Corn Belt...
6. Plant breeders' rights and the social division of labor: historical perspective
Download PDF (1.5 MB)
Hybridization furnished capital with an eminently effective technical means ofcircumventing the natural constraints on the commodification of the seed. But not all crops submitted to hybridization. There is, however, a second route to the commodification of the seed: the extension of property rights to plant germplasm. Plant breeders' rights (PBR) have now been an issue in the plant science community for over a century...
7. Seeds of strugle; plant genetic resources in teh world system
Download PDF (2.6 MB)
Plant genetic resources enjoy a unique distinction: They are considered the "common heritage of mankind" (FAO 1983a:6; Myers 1983:24; Wilkes 1983:156), humanity's collective "genetic estate" (Frankel 1974). As such, PGRs have been available as a free good...
8. Outdoing evolution: biotechnology, botany, and business
Download PDF (3.5 MB)
It would be interesting to know the source of the Wellsian prescience apparent in the quotation from Hyland C. Kirk. Kirk's comments came in the course of congressional testimony during a hearing on proposed legislation that would eventually become the Plant Patent Act of 1930. Kirk doubtless wanted to emphasize the extent to which new plant...
9. Directions for deployment
Download PDF (2.7 MB)
What forms will the products of the new plant biotechnologies take? CibaGeigy's Mary-Dell Chilton has written that "Biotechnology is a completely new approach to solving old problems" (quoted in Rossman 1984). But qualitatively different tools do not necessarily imply qualitatively different sorts of solutions to those problems...
Download PDF (955.2 KB)
Let me give my "take-home" message straight away as well. Atlantic Richfield's J. Eugene Fox has paraphrased Clausewitz by saying that "Research priorities are too important to be left in the hands of research directors and other kinds of management types...
11. Still the seed: plant biotechnology in the twenty-first century
Download PDF (251.8 KB)
The reissue of First the Seed has given me the opportunity to add a chapter to the book. My history of plant breeding has, so far, taken its narrative and analytical structure from the interaction of scientific development with three themes of political economy: progressive commodification, the changing division of labor between public...
Download PDF (1.5 MB)
Download PDF (189.2 KB)
Download PDF (70.7 KB)
Publication Year: 2004