Friendship and Politics
Essays in Political Thought
Publication Year: 2008
Published by: University of Notre Dame Press
Download PDF (88.6 KB)
Download PDF (59.3 KB)
Introduction: The Persistence of Friendship in Political Life
Download PDF (138.8 KB)
Throughout the greater part of the history of political philosophy, friendship has occupied a central place in the conversation. If we draw on conventional historical distinctions, friendship perennially figured as the sine qua non of discussions among ancient and medieval political thinkers regarding good political order and the good human life. ...
Part I. Ancient Perspectives
Download PDF (107.0 KB)
1. Platonic Philia and Political Order
Download PDF (198.2 KB)
Recall the political life of Athens from the outbreak of the Peloponnesian War to the execution of Socrates. Democratic and oligarchic factions took turns ruling the polis, harming opponents, and enriching themselves. The leaders were notorious for power lusts, mendacity, fraud, diverting public moneys and war booty into personal fortunes and payoffs to cronies, and fanning the flames of toxic passions. ...
2. Taking Friendship Seriously: Aristotle on the Place(s) of Philia in Human Life
Download PDF (199.7 KB)
For present-day readers, Aristotle’s discussion of friendship (in Greek, philia)1 is both intriguing and perplexing—intriguing because of his unique emphasis on friendship as an essential topic for moral and political theory, perplexing because his lengthy discussions of friendship do not result in any clear moral or political principles. ...
3. Cicero’s Distinctive Voice on Friendship: De Amicitia and De Re Publica
Download PDF (187.2 KB)
The model of friendship, so beautifully described in these words of Cicero,1 could be seen as a rival to politics. Politics in the classical sense was especially oriented to “the highest good of nature.” Aristotle, who systematically articulated the dominant classical understanding of political life, located his treatise of friendship in a richly significant way at the very heart of his practical philosophy. ...
Part II. Christian Perspectives
Download PDF (104.3 KB)
4. The Luminous Path of Friendship: Augustine’s Account of Friendship and Political Order
Download PDF (174.5 KB)
Cicero was Augustine’s principal ancient teacher and interlocutor about politics and Augustine knew he had to go through his teaching, as it were, in order to demonstrate the superiority of the Christian contribution to political life over the ancient.1 Yet, as much as Augustine thought that he had surpassed Cicero, he depends on Cicero’s identification of, as opposed to answers to, the perennial questions of political order...
5. A Companionship of Caritas: Friendship in St. Thomas Aquinas
Download PDF (175.9 KB)
“When friendships were the noblest things in the world,” Jeremy Taylor observed, “charity was little.”1 So begins Gilbert Meilaender’s thoughtful examination of the theological significance of friendship. Meilaender features Taylor’s observation because he thinks it captures an important shift in Western culture, specifically the shift from a classical period...
6. Friendship in the Civic Order: A Reformation Absence
Download PDF (190.8 KB)
In Michael Pakaluk’s anthology of the key writings in the Western literary and philosophical tradition concerning friendship, which begins with Plato and Aristotle, there is a major lacuna. So, too, in several recent collections of scholarly treatments of the topic in the self-same tradition, or even in wider comparative context.1 Missing in every case are all of the sixteenth-century Reformers. ...
Part III. Modern Perspectives
Download PDF (98.7 KB)
7. Plato and Montaigne: Ancient and Modern Ideas of Friendship
Download PDF (141.9 KB)
My aim in this essay is to reflect on ancient and modern ideas of friendship by considering Plato’s dialogue on friendship, the Lysis, and Montaigne’s essay “Of Friendship.” In so doing, I must pass over many other significant reflections on friendship, especially those of Aristotle, that equally should claim our attention. ...
8. Hobbes on Getting By with Little Help from Friends
Download PDF (194.9 KB)
Hobbes’s political thought contains a sustained attack on friendship. At the outset of Leviathan, for instance, he draws immediate attention to the problems that friendships present. The book opens with the dedication “To My Most Honour’d Friend Mr. Francis Godolphin, of Godolphin.” ...
9. Social Friendship in the Founding Era
Download PDF (154.7 KB)
The founding era does not yield up any sustained treatment of the role of friendship per se for a properly ordered civil society or for individual fulfillment and well being. Nevertheless, the need for the goods that flow from it—for example, loyalty, trust, understanding, forbearance, empathy—and the extent to which they could be realized in the new and extended republic were matters of utmost concern in light of the political divisions and conflicts leading up to the adoption of the Constitution. ...
10. It Is Not Good for Man to Be Alone: Tocqueville on Friendship
Download PDF (146.9 KB)
...The locus classicus to which historians of political thought return to consider the question of friendship is, of course, Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics. What we find in that compilation, among other things, is the ready distinction between three kinds of friendship: friendships based on pleasure, friendships based on use, and friendships based on virtue.1 ...
Part IV. Contemporary Perspectives
Download PDF (99.3 KB)
11. Zarathustra and His Asinine Friends: Nietzsche and Taste as the Groundless Ground of Friendship
Download PDF (178.7 KB)
To ask of Nietzsche sage wisdom regarding friendship seems somewhat misguided—like turning to Henry VIII for marriage advice or to Jean-Jacques Rousseau for tips on parenting. By most accounts Nietzsche was something of a misanthrope, and his biography recounts a litany of failed friendships and long periods of loneliness.1 ...
12. Friendship, Trust, and Political Order: A Critical Overview
Download PDF (196.3 KB)
It is appropriate to begin with the question: Does friendship count in modern politics? At first glance there are reasons for an answer in the negative, as the following reflection on the modern political discourse seems to suggest. ...
Download PDF (87.7 KB)
Download PDF (95.1 KB)
Page Count: 368
Publication Year: 2008