Problems Confronting Contemporary Democracies
Essays in Honor of Alfred Stepan
Publication Year: 2012
Published by: University of Notre Dame Press
Title Page, Copyright
Download PDF (34.0 KB)
Preface and Acknowledgments
Download PDF (42.9 KB)
We celebrate Alfred Stepan’s career with these essays from among those presented at a conference in his honor at Columbia University in 2007. Many colleagues came from all parts of the world to discuss his work and demonstrate the fecundity of his contributions. These essays represent a sample, a window...
Download PDF (125.8 KB)
We have two primary goals and a secondary one with this book. We hope to advance understanding of some of the most pressing problems facing democracies across the world. And we wish to honor Alfred Stepan, who did pioneering work on the issues analyzed here. Finally, by highlighting the...
Part I: The Armed Forces, Police, and Democracy
Chapter 1: The Armed Forces and Society in Latin America
Download PDF (385.7 KB)
As a field of scholarly inquiry, the study of civil-military relations analyzes the interactions of the armed forces, the state, and society. However, for nearly three decades students of the Latin American militaries have focused almost exclusively on the military’s relations with the state. Studies of transitions from...
Chapter 2: Reconciling the Brazilian Military with Democracy
Download PDF (85.6 KB)
As a personal friend and also as a social scientist and former president of Brazil, I wish to acknowledge and praise the groundbreaking role that Alfred Stepan played in stressing the importance and challenging our understanding of the role played by the military...
Chapter 3: Managing Citizen Security in Latin America’s Changing States and Societies
Download PDF (145.3 KB)
Stepan’s work on the broad and complex challenges that have faced Latin America continues to provide a strong foundation of analysis even as those challenges change. One of the most difficult of those current challenges is citizen security. A 41 percent rise in homicides in the 1990s has made Latin...
Part II: The State and Democracy
Chapter 4: The State of the Market
Download PDF (276.9 KB)
This chapter revisits three interrelated claims made in Problems of Democratic Transition and Consolidation, the magnum opus of Juan J. Linz and Alfred Stepan. These claims were about the links between market reforms, state making, and democratization in the context of postcommunist...
Part III: Democratic Transitions and Democratic Regimes
Chapter 5: Revisiting “Paths toward Redemocratization”
Download PDF (154.1 KB)
The effort to conceptualize meaningful differences among regime transition scenarios—and to ask whether the contrasts between pathways to political freedom generate divergent consequences for the durability and quality of new democracies—has attracted the interest of numerous social scientists in the decades...
Chapter 6: Electoral Victory, Political Defeat
Download PDF (252.9 KB)
The Islamic Republic of Iran presents a puzzle for students of democratic transitions: in four consecutive elections, a democratic-minded opposition won overwhelming majorities at the ballot box. For a period of four years, these electoral victories gave the opposition control of the national legislature, the...
Chapter 7: Executive Approval under Alternative Democratic Regime Types
Download PDF (138.3 KB)
Among Alfred Stepan’s many contributions to the study of politics is his work on political institutions and, in particular, his research (in collaboration with Juan J. Linz and Cindy Skach) examining the differences in the institutional frameworks of parliamentarism and presidentialism and their effects...
Chapter 8: Cautionary and Unorthodox Thoughts about Democracy Today
Download PDF (140.4 KB)
I write from a disillusioned or at least realistic view of democracy. Some of you might at the end of this believe that I am not totally a bona fide democrat. I certainly do not embrace the National Endowment of Democracy kind of ideology or the one that some American intellectuals and politicians are trying...
Part IV: Federalism and Democracy
Chapter 9: Holding China Together
Download PDF (114.3 KB)
There is much debate among Western scholars about whether China will democratize but very little debate about how China should arrange its affairs, institutionally speaking, if the country succeeded in doing so. Due to the many contributions of Alfred Stepan, the political science literature on federalism...
Chapter 10: Of Swords and Shields
Download PDF (143.1 KB)
Alfred Stepan has long called for theory building about the relationship between federalism and democracy. As one of the founding fathers of the now-burgeoning field of comparative federalism, Stepan has also generated important theories of his own about this relationship. His insights into how federalism...
Chapter 11: Oil and the Corporate Reintegration of Russia
Download PDF (202.9 KB)
Alfred Stepan’s comparative work on federal systems has inspired this study on Russian federalism and the important role corporations could play in shaping center-periphery relations within a federation system.1 Russia’s political and economic transition under the first Russian Presi - dent Boris Yeltsin and his successor...
Part V: Religion, Tolerance, and Democracy
Chapter 12: Religion, Politics, and the State in a Stepanesque Perspective
Download PDF (225.4 KB)
Of the many contributions to the study of comparative politics, one of the most insightful and agenda-setting for future research is Al Stepan’s perspective on religion, politics, and the state in the consolidation of democracies. In Arguing Comparative Politics, he challenges some commonly held positions by previous scholars...
Chapter 13: Twin Tolerations or Siamese Twins?
Download PDF (375.2 KB)
Political Islam in Turkey has come a long way, from the National Order Party (Milli Nizam Partisi, banned by the Constitutional Court in 1971 for violating laiklik,1 or laicity) to the National Salvation Party (Milli Selamet Partisi, banned by the military Junta in 1980 along with all political parties) to the Welfare Party (Refah Partisi, banned by the Constitutional Court in 1998 for violating laiklik...
Chapter 14: Consociationalism versus Twin Tolerations
Download PDF (147.4 KB)
In his well-known article “The World’s Religious Systems and Democracy: Crafting the ‘Twin Tolerations,’” Alfred Stepan provides a theoretical framework for evaluating the democratic relationship between religion and state.1 Based on broad comparative analysis, Stepan defines minimal boundaries of freedom...
Download PDF (52.9 KB)
Download PDF (159.0 KB)
Page Count: 504
Illustrations: 1 halftone; 18 tables
Publication Year: 2012